Tuesday, February 18, 2025, 4:31PM |  16°
MENU
Advertisement
Reproducing wild trout are a sign of clean, cool water. Fly fisherman Greg Reynolds of Harrison City released this gnarly native brook trout in a small, unstocked tributary in Westmoreland County.
1
MORE

Wild trout populations reveal the presence of clean water. Should anglers pay for that assessment?

Greg Reynolds

Wild trout populations reveal the presence of clean water. Should anglers pay for that assessment?

STATE COLLEGE -- Nearly 70 percent of the Pennsylvania fishing licenses sold in 2016 were purchased for the purpose of catching trout. The state Fish and Boat Commission estimates that the 3.2 million trout it raises and stocks each year generate some $500 million in economic activity each year.

In contrast, interest in Pennsylvania’s wild trout contributes just $16 million annually to the state’s economy.

 

But at a conference held in Bellefonte, Centre County, last week, a panel of speakers told reporters and wildlife managers that wild trout represent something more valuable than money.

Advertisement

Where there are wild trout, they said, there is clean water.

This Ohio River flathead took cut bait and was released in Allegheny County waters by James Swearingen of McKees Rocks on the night of Aug. 16.
John Hayes
Outdoors notebook:Resident goose hunt trimmed in northwest

Fish and Boat’s first Wild Trout Summit spent little time on regulation and management. Panelists spoke mostly about the role of wild trout in assessing water quality.

“This has been on my mind for seven years since I’ve been the director,” said John Arway, executive director of the Fish and Boat Commission, during a break at the day-long conference.

Presentations included the history of wild trout management in Pennsylvania, assessing small stream water quality, environmental review and permitting, the impacts of climate change, habitat improvement, genetic variation and radio-tracking studies of the movement of wild trout.

Advertisement

Fewer than a million of the state’s adult residents participate in fishing, yet panelists suggested that a stream of logic connects wild trout to the interests of every Pennsylvanian.

Indigenous brook trout and naturalized browns and rainbows, said some presenters, are the canaries in the coal mine of clean water conservation. Naturally reproducing trout can support a fishery only where waters are particularly clean. While some mature stocked trout hold over to the next year, they are not intended to reproduce.

And so, the theory goes, in stream sections where wild trout are found in sustaining abundance, the water must be clean. In order to maintain prime populations of that natural bellwether of water quality, special permitting forbids any development or activity that may degrade that standard.

Since 2010 Fish and Boat’s Unassessed Waters Initiative has searched for wild trout and taken baseline water-quality readings on nearly 13,000 miles of previously unassessed streams. Through the program, Fish and Boat staff and university volunteers have added 1,134 new entries to the list of wild trout stream sections.

The detection of previously unknown populations of wild trout is the central task in a complicated pollution-detection system that enables corporations to work around sensitive areas, warns of the release of water pollutants and protects a vital natural resource. Some speakers at the Wild Trout Initiative questioned why a program that benefits all Pennsylvanians should be funded primarily by license fees and excise taxes paid by anglers.

“We think there are probably about 53,000 Pennsylvania streams that our people have never been on -- only about 700 of [those streams[ have names,” said Arway. “The PFBC does not have the resources to assess those waters before their possible degradation.”

The Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources estimates the state has more than 86,500 miles of flowing water, second in the U.S. only to Alaska. Sixty-three of Pennsylvania’s 67 counties have naturally reproducing wild trout. None have been found in Beaver, Greene, Washington and Philadelphia counties.

Waters designated “wild trout streams” include more than 15,000 miles of stream and river sections where wild trout have been documented, plus another 20,273 miles of upstream tributaries that supply water to the wild trout below. Despite the environmental complications presented in an urban district, southwestern Pennsylvania includes hundreds of stream miles designated as wild trout waters. Allegheny County’s 1,225,000 residents are neighbors to two “wild trout streams” totalling 29.71 miles.

A subset of wild trout streams, the best of Pennsylvania’s naturally reproducing wild trout fisheries, is considered Class A. About 6 percent of wild trout waters get the Class A designation including 61.3 miles in Fayette and Westmoreland counties. Fish and Boat reports that 12,362 miles of wild trout streams, 35 percent of the total, flow through public land. Nearly 850 miles of Class A waters, 39 percent, are located on public land.

Several panelists at the Wild Trout Summit suggested that the state’s wild trout should be considered a vital natural resource, at least as valuable as the timber and minerals that could wipe out reproducing populations with a single industrial accident.

“I’ve been promoting a number of ideas about how to acquire funding so that just anglers don’t have to pay for the lion’s share of the benefits that the public receives [from wild trout],” said Arway.

A shale gas severance tax similar those applied when gas leaves every other major gas-drilling state has never gotten legislative traction in Harrisburg.

“We did get into the [surface] impact fee … and some of that is used to fund the Unassessed Waters program,” said Arway, “but the broader severance tax would have brought more money back.”

He’s been pushing, with little success, for a consumptive use water fee that would be applied whenever water collected in Pennsylvania leaves the state in bottles, is evaporated through power plant smokestacks or injected below the water table at shale gas wells, never to see the surface again for perhaps millions of years. Another idea: Pennsylvania anglers spend $1.2 billion a year on travel, hotels, food and other fishing-related activities, and about 6 percent goes to state taxes. Arway said he’d like to see some of that reinvested in fishing or water-quality assessment.

Dingell-Johnson license fees and excise taxes are well-protected by design, but the political vibe out of Washington suggests that federal funding for water quality, wildlife management and other conservation issues may soon be hard to get.

“It’s about a quarter of our budget, so we’re looking at about $20 million a year. If we lost it we’d be crippled,” said Arway. “We’d have to scale back to where we’d essentially be irrelevant.”

First Published: September 3, 2017, 10:30 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
The Allegheny County Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review approved a $25.9 million cut in One Oxford Centre's taxable value for 2025, bringing its new assessment to $54 million.
1
business
Taxable value of Downtown’s One Oxford Centre falls by $25.9M — its 3rd cut in 6 years
Sidequest on 44th in Lawrenceville on Dec. 27, 2024.
2
a&e
Canceled show leads ex-Misfits singer Michale Graves to lash out about being purged from Pittsburgh
Head coach Mike Tomlin and offensive coordinator Arthur Smith watch a receivers and defensive backs drill at Steelers Minicamp at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex Thursday, June 13, 2024.
3
sports
Gerry Dulac: Next season’s major decisions loom this week for Mike Tomlin, Steelers staff
Najee Harris of the Pittsburgh Steelers looks on before playing the Dallas Cowboys at Acrisure Stadium on October 06, 2024 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
4
sports
Joe Starkey’s mailbag: Will Najee Harris return, and how does he compare to Frank Pollard and Tim Worley?
The fire began at around 9:15 p.m. Monday at a warehouse owned by SPS Technologies in Abington Township, according to NBC10 and 6ABC.
5
news
Massive fire rips through Eastern Pa. industrial complex: residents told to shelter in place
Reproducing wild trout are a sign of clean, cool water. Fly fisherman Greg Reynolds of Harrison City released this gnarly native brook trout in a small, unstocked tributary in Westmoreland County.  (Greg Reynolds)
Greg Reynolds
Advertisement
LATEST life
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story