Saturday, February 22, 2025, 5:13PM |  31°
MENU
Advertisement
Dave McElroy of Brookline likes being the only angler on the river. In recent weeks, using flies on waters not far from The Point, he's released some 20 smallmouth buffalo including a 20 pounder, and walleye as big as 7 and 10 pounds. He's pictured here with a smaller walleye.
1
MORE

Point / counterpoint on deer management

Point / counterpoint on deer management

On last week’s outdoors page, biologist, outdoors writer and noted deer authority C.J. Winand said that while other deer hunting states are “envious” of Pennsylvania’s deer management policy, he had bones to pick with details of the plan. Nothing nasty, just his belief that the Game Commission’s antler restrictions were the result of a bad but necessary compromise, and enforcing a minimum 15-inch inside spread would better protect young bucks. Wild­life man­ag­ers in general have “failed miserably” at educating hunters, said Winand, and squan­der cred­i­bil­ity when they de­fend bad com­pro­mises.

Winand speaks today at 11:30 a.m. and 1:45 p.m. at the Allegheny Outdoor, Sport and Travel Show at Monroeville Convention Center.

 

Chris Rosenberry, deer management section supervisor at the state Game Commission, wrote in to say he had bones to pick with Winand’s critique.

Advertisement

“In the case of antler point restrictions, I would argue we made the credible choice,” said Rosenberry. “Antler spread was not a viable option for Pennsylvania.”

The Eastern coyote is most adaptive and successful Pennsylvania predator.  SOURCE public domain
John Hayes
Top of the Food Chain | Hunters and other predators compete for game

The goal was to protect most yearling bucks while making most adult bucks eligible for harvest. A 15-inch inside spread rule in this state, said Rosenberry, would have made “nearly all yearling bucks and most 2 1/2-year-old bucks illegal for harvest.”

In addition to satisfying the policy’s biological needs, point restrictions also achieve certain social considerations, he said.

“Counting antler points is easier to apply in the field than estimating inside spread,” he said, and the policy has “continued majority support from hunters.”

Advertisement

As for squandering credibility and keeping hunters up to speed on wildlife science, Rosenberry said PGC has made “significant efforts” to get new information out there, citing a weekly blog on deer science and answering hunter questions on an “Ask the Deer Biologist” web page.

“In Pennsylvania, deer hunters continue to rank in the Top 5 nationally in deer harvested per square mile of land ... and antlered deer harvest success rates are similar to the 1980s and 1990s,” he said. “The big difference is that today, Pennsylvania deer hunters are taking twice as many adult bucks as they did in the past. In addition, only 22 percent of Pennsylvania deer hunters are dissatisfied with the deer program.”

Meet the warden

Mike Johnson, Allegheny County Waterways Conservation Officer for the state Fish and Boat Commission, will be the speaker at the Upper St. Clair Fly Fishing Club, 7 p.m. Wednesday[2/22], USC Municipal Building, 1770 McLaughlin Run Rd., 412-835-6107.

First Published: February 19, 2017, 5:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
The University of Pittsburgh's Cathedral of Learning
1
business
Amid funding uncertainty, Pitt pauses doctoral admissions
2
business
How much can retirees safely withdraw from their nest eggs? Financial experts weigh in.
Steelers receiver Calvin Austin III, left, celebrates with teammate George Pickens after scoring a 23-yard touchdown against the Cleveland Browns during the fourth quarter in the game at Huntington Bank Field on November 21, 2024.
3
sports
Steelers position analysis: Is there a path forward at wide receiver with George Pickens?
Preston Coleman, 52, was beaten and strangled inside an Aliquippa VFW on Jan. 5, 2025, in what police described as a vicious, unprovoked attack.
4
news
Bartender working at Aliquippa VFW during beating that left man unconscious facing charges
The Linden Street Tunnel in Duquesne on the Steel Valley Trail is a segment of the Great American Passage (GAP). The trail group wants to paint a mural on the graffiti-plagued tunnel.
5
local
Military 'Ghost Bomber' that landed in the Mon River in 1956 might be depicted in proposed mural
Dave McElroy of Brookline likes being the only angler on the river. In recent weeks, using flies on waters not far from The Point, he's released some 20 smallmouth buffalo including a 20 pounder, and walleye as big as 7 and 10 pounds. He's pictured here with a smaller walleye.
Advertisement
LATEST life
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story