Thursday, February 27, 2025, 3:25PM |  49°
MENU
Advertisement
In this 2011 photo, a drilling rig is set up to tap gas from the Marcellus Shale gas field near a barn in the Susquehanna County township of Springville, Pa.
1
MORE

Court won't rule on proper use of money from drilling Pa. forests

Alex Brandon/Associated Press

Court won't rule on proper use of money from drilling Pa. forests

Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court will decide whether upfront bonus and land rental payments from companies drilling for natural gas in state forests must be used for the same conservation purposes as royalty payments under a landmark state Supreme Court ruling last year.

But the court, which laid out the narrow scope of its review this week, will not hear a challenge to the Pennsylvania Legislature’s continued practice of using money from gas development in publicly owned forests to cover salaries and operating expenses for the state’s conservation agency.

That issue, the Commonwealth Court said in a brief opinion Monday, “exceeds the scope of the Supreme Court’s remand order.”

Advertisement

A 2017 state Supreme Court ruling held that royalties from oil and gas leases on state forests must be dedicated to conserving the commonwealth’s public natural resources, not spent on general budget items.

After the decision, the Legislature budgeted $61 million in oil and gas revenue from public lands to pay for Department of Conservation and Natural Resources operations this fiscal year. It has used nearly $610 million from drilling payments to cover the department’s day-to-day expenses since 2009.

Budget crafters have taken the position that spending oil and gas funds on DCNR operations is an allowable conservation purpose, but the Pennsylvania Environmental Defense Foundation, which challenged the state’s use of drilling revenue, argues that it violates the Supreme Court decision.

The environmental organization asked the high court to step in and take over the case last week to save time and separate appeals while “tens of millions of dollars of the public trust resources” are being spent contrary to the state constitution.

Advertisement

The foundation also urged the courts to resolve several other issues still pending in the case that were not addressed by the Supreme Court decision, such as whether money from state forest gas sales must be dedicated to conserving the public lands where the gas came from.

In its order Monday, the Commonwealth Court said it will stick to a single issue that the high court directed it to consider: Is there a distinction between upfront lease bonus payments and oil and gas royalties, which represent the state’s share of the value of the gas when it is sold?

If rents and bonus payments reflect revenue generated from the sale of gas from conserved lands, they, too, belong to the state’s collective environmental trust, the Supreme Court said, but it left that up to the Commonwealth Court to decide.

These days, Pennsylvania collects far more in gas royalties than bonus and rental payments on the public forest acres that are open for drilling — about 88 percent of the projected $80 million in gas revenue this fiscal year is expected to come from royalties and 12 percent from rents.

But in 2008 and 2010, bonus payments represented a significant windfall, earning the state $413 million.

Gov. Tom Wolf put a ban on opening any more state forest parcels to shale gas development in 2015.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com

First Published: January 11, 2018, 9:19 p.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Jeff Capel, head coach of Pitt looks on against Syracuse at the NCAA men’s basketball game on Tuesday Feb. 18, 2025 at Petersen Event Center in Pittsburgh, Pa.
1
sports
Paul Zeise: Pitt AD Allen Greene can save the basketball program by forcing some changes upon Jeff Capel
City leaders from Pittsburgh, New York City, Baltimore and Oakland, Calif. met Wednesday night for a Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership-led discussion on the future of Downtown.
2
business
City officials from NYC, Baltimore and Oakland, Calif. meet in Pittsburgh to discuss Downtown's future
Councilman Bobby Wilson of District 1 speaks at a press conference inside City Hall on April 11, 2024, in Downtown.
3
opinion
Editorial: Pittsburgh is withering. The region needs a strategy for growth
An Internal Revenue Service 1040 Individual Income Tax form for the 2019 tax year in an arranged photograph on March 20, 2020..
4
news
Trump, Republicans push tax cuts that helped cost them House majority last time
Gene Hackman arrives with his wife, Betsy Arakawa, for the 60th Annual Golden Globe Awards on Sunday, Jan. 19, 2003, in Beverly Hills, Calif.
5
a&e
Oscar-winning actor Gene Hackman and his wife and dog found dead in their New Mexico home
In this 2011 photo, a drilling rig is set up to tap gas from the Marcellus Shale gas field near a barn in the Susquehanna County township of Springville, Pa.  (Alex Brandon/Associated Press)
Alex Brandon/Associated Press
Advertisement
LATEST business
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story