Thursday, February 20, 2025, 10:25PM |  22°
MENU
Advertisement
In this July 2017 photo, pipes for the Sunoco Mariner East pipeline are placed in South Lebanon Township, Pa.
1
MORE

Sunoco's Mariner East pipeline ordered shut down — again

Jeremy Long /Lebanon Daily News via AP

Sunoco's Mariner East pipeline ordered shut down — again

Sinkholes, contaminated water wells, and Sunoco’s alleged poor judgment have convinced an administrative law judge to suspend the flow of natural gas liquids on the company’s Mariner East 1 pipeline and prevent any further construction of its Mariner East 2 pipelines in West Whiteland Township, Chester County, until further study.

In a scathing decision, Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission judge Elizabeth Barnes took the company to task for making “deliberate managerial decisions to proceed in what appears to be a rushed manner in an apparent prioritization of profit over the best engineering practices available in our time that might best ensure public safety.”

Sunoco’s parent company, Energy Transfer Partners, charged that the decision was based on “conjecture or extrajudicial claims,” rather than evidence and due process.

Advertisement

“The entire energy industry should be concerned about today’s order and consider this result when making decisions regarding future capital investments in the state as it upends Pennsylvania’s entire regulatory environment,” the company’s statement declared.

Pipes for the Sunoco Mariner East 2 pipeline are placed in South Lebanon Township , Pa., in July 2017.
Laura Legere
Mariner East 1 pipeline gets OK to flow again

The order came in response to a petition filed by Pa. Sen. Andy Dinniman last month. The Chester County Democrat has been a vocal critic of Sunoco and the project.

Sunoco is building two pipelines to carry natural gas liquids from Western Pennsylvania to a refinery in the Philadelphia area.

A company representative testified earlier this month that the Mariner East 2 pipeline is nearly done and needs only 20 more miles of its 350 mile trajectory to be completed. Mariner East 2X will follow the same route.

Advertisement

Sunoco told analysts recently that it expects the first pipeline to be operational toward the end of the third quarter, while ME2X is expected to come online in mid-2019. The company said on Thursday it doesn’t expect those deadlines to change.

Meanwhile, the company operates a 1930s vintage pipeline, Mariner East 1, along the same right of way that has been repurposed to ferry natural gas liquids.

In March, a series of sinkholes caused by the construction of the new pipelines prompted the Pennsylvania PUC to suspend operation of Mariner East 1 after portions of that pipeline were exposed when the soil around it was disturbed. The shutdown had a $6 million impact on the company’s earnings during March, Sunoco officials told analysts during a recent earnings call, and advised that a similar loss was expected for the month of April.

The company was allowed to resume the flow through the Mariner East 1 pipeline earlier this month after the PUC was satisfied that integrity tests showed the exposed pipeline had not been impacted.

A sinkhole is fenced off in West Whiteland Township, Chester County.
Anya Litvak
Sinkholes prompt Pa. regulators' move to stop gas flow on Sunoco pipeline

Mariner East 2 construction had also been suspended for periods of time by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, which fined the company $12.6 million for violations earlier this year.

Judge Barnes’s decision drew on Sunoco’s record of construction and operational mishaps in Pennsylvania and beyond.

She noted an incident in Texas two years ago when Sunoco was found to have used untested/unqualified welders in the construction of a new pipeline which subsequently failed.

In Pennsylvania, she charged, the company failed to notice and report three leaks from the Mariner East 1 pipeline within the past year, “all in high consequence areas.”

In legal filings over the past few weeks, Sunoco has disputed the validity and relevance of nearly everything that Judge Barnes used to justify her verdict.

“Pennsylvania law is clear — past conduct or harm cannot form the basis for injunctive relief,” Sunoco’s lawyers argued, responding to Mr. Dinniman’s petition for an immediate halt to activity in West Whiteland Township while the court evaluates his broader complaint about the pipelines.

Judge Barnes also found Sunoco’s efforts to educate emergency responders and the community lacking.

“Two large school districts have asked Gov. (Tom) Wolf what to do in an emergency,” she wrote. “Residents request specific instructions, but only receive boilerplate general information. Chester County Emergency Services requested an emergency management plan and this request has not been fulfilled.”

Sunoco, in turn, said in filings that it trained more than 2,000 first responders and public officials during 16 meetings last year, including those in Chester County.

Throughout its comments, Sunoco emphasized what it felt was the most powerful rebuttal: that by granting the company permission to restart Mariner East 1 in early May, the PUC’s enforcement staff found the pipeline to be safe.

As for ME2 construction, a Sunoco geologist testified, “No further sinkholes will develop from the construction remaining in West Whiteland Township.”

In a lengthy rebuke of Sen. Dinniman’s petition, Sunoco painted the politician and his witnesses as lay people who could not appreciate the technical work that Sunoco and the PUC staff had done to ensure safety.

The company also warned of wage losses, as pipeliners are unable to work and financial losses at natural gas companies, such as Range Resources, that will once again lose a conduit for their product.

Construction unions, oil and gas companies, and industry groups showed up to support Sunoco in this matter, while several environmental groups joined Sen. Dinniman in his plight.

Judge Barnes was clearly more swayed by the latter.

“The public needs protection from sinkholes, water contamination, damage to public and private property, degradation of natural resources, physical injury and death,” she wrote. “It would be injurious to the public to not slow down this project.”

The judge also rejected Sunoco’s request that Sen. Dinniman should be obligated to post bonds totalling $192 million for the losses that Sunoco would incur during the shutdown if an injunction is granted.

Sunoco promised it would file an appeal in the next week asking the PUC to overturn this decision.

PUC spokesperson Nils Hagen-Frederiksen declined to give the agency’s position on the order, saying only, “The commission has encouraged individuals and organizations with concerns related to the Mariner pipelines to file their own formal complaints or intervene in existing complaints.”

“Today’s order,” he said, “is the result of the exact process highlighted by the commission, which allows citizens to have their voices heard.”

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.

Updated at 5:10 p.m. May 24, 2018.

First Published: May 24, 2018, 3:58 p.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Longtime KDKA-TV host Jon Burnett on May 22, 2019.
1
a&e
Jon Burnett, long a KDKA-TV staple, leaves legacy of ‘putting good out into the world’
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro delivers his budget address for the 2025-26 fiscal year  at the Capitol, Feb. 4,  in Harrisburg, Pa.
2
news
Trump taps Shapiro to join bipartisan governor's council
WASHINGTON, DC - FEBRUARY 6:  U.S. Sen. John Fetterman (D-PA) speaks to a reporter following a vote to confirm Russell Vought as director of the Office of Management and Budget on February 6, 2025 in Washington, DC. The Senate will continue to vote into the night to proceed to the confirmation of the remaining Trump cabinet nominees. (Photo by Anna Rose Layden/Getty Images)
3
news
Pair of John Fetterman's staffers reportedly leaving senator's office
Dr. Sylvia Owusu-Ansah helped writers of "The Pitt" with her perspective working in emergency medicine.
4
a&e
'It's very real,' says the Pittsburgh ER doctor who consulted on 'The Pitt' TV show
The Breezewood Interchange is dotted with gas stations, chain restaurants and souvenir shops. The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission has selected Chicago-based Alfred Benesch and Company to spearhead a major redesign of the notorious roadway.
5
business
So long, Breezewood: Chicago firm selected to redesign infamous Pa. Turnpike interchange
In this July 2017 photo, pipes for the Sunoco Mariner East pipeline are placed in South Lebanon Township, Pa.  (Jeremy Long /Lebanon Daily News via AP)
Jeremy Long /Lebanon Daily News via AP
Advertisement
LATEST business
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story