Monday, January 27, 2025, 2:48AM |  32°
MENU
Advertisement
A view  of one of the tree platforms on Ellen and Stephen Gerhart's property in Huntingdon County in June 2017.  Protesters against the building of the Sunoco Mariner East 2 Pipeline project through the Gerhart's property occupied trees to prevent construction of the pipeline. Trees with platforms were cut down Sunday.
5
MORE

Predawn timbering raid ends tree-sitters' pipeline protest

Darrell Sapp/Post-Gazette

Predawn timbering raid ends tree-sitters' pipeline protest

At daybreak on Sunday, the company building the Mariner East 2 natural gas liquids pipelines across Pennsylvania cut down three trees on the Gerhart property in Huntingdon County that tree-sitting opponents of the pipeline had occupied for more than a year to block construction.

The three white pines, which contained housing structures 50 feet above ground and were connected by ropes and zip-lines, were not occupied when they were cut down,according to Elise Gerhart, the 29-year-old daughter of Stephen and Ellen Gerhart, owners of the 27-acre wooded property.

Ms. Gerhart said the timing of the tree cutting indicated that the pipeline company, Energy Transfer Partners, and its security contractor, TigerSwan, had conducted extensive surveillance to determine when the trees would be unoccupied and could be safely cut. In a release announcing the action, she called the cutting an “underhanded and cowardly attack.”

Advertisement

Lisa Dillinger, an Energy Transfer spokeswoman, issued a statement Friday confirming the trees were removed in preparation for pipeline construction work in the area.

A view  of one of the tree platforms on Ellen & Stephen Gerhart's property in Unity Township, Huntingdon County.
Anna Spoerre
Despite order to vacate, tree sitters protesting Sunoco pipeline are staying put for now

“This was carefully orchestrated with law enforcement to ensure the safety of everyone involved — the safety of our workers, the landowners and all other interested parties,” Ms. Dilinger said. “It was verified prior to our cutting the trees that they were unoccupied.”

Ellen Gerhart said in a Friday phone call that the company’s tree cutters arrived in the pipeline right-of-way at day’s first light, before she got up to let her chickens out at 6:45 a.m.

“I saw them in their green vests on the easement and went over to watch,” she said. “They were already going up into the trees and cutting the ropes. And after the ropes were cut away they cut down the trees.”

Advertisement

She said pipeline opponents had been in the pines tree-sitting the day before the trees were cut but came down because of high winds.

“We managed to hold them off for two years from building the pipeline through the property, so I’d call that a partial victory.” Mrs. Gerhart said. “And we’re not done yet.”

There are trees still standing in a wetland on the easement, Mrs. Gephart said, and a group of between 5 and 20 pipeline opponents remain camped on the Gerhart property.

Asked if some of those opponents might try to recolonize the remaining trees, she said, “Nothing is off the table.”

A view of one of the tree platforms  on Ellen and Stephen Gerhart's property in Huntingdon County.  Protesters object to the building of the Sunoco Mariner East 2 Pipeline project through the Gerhart property.
Don Hopey
Tree sitters seek to prevent Sunoco from working on a pipeline in Huntingdon County

Opponents of the $2.5 billion, pipeline project began sitting in three trees next to the company’s right-of-way, acquired through eminent domain, in March 2016. The Gerhart property is in rural Huntingdon County, about 100 miles east of Pittsburgh.

Two of those trees, unoccupied at the time, were cut down a month later, but in February 2017, activists went back up into three new tree-sit platforms — an encampment they dubbed “Camp White Pine.” Activists remained in the trees throughout the year, even after Sunoco, a subsidiary of Energy Transfer Partners, went to court in June seeking injunction that allowed the company to call in county sheriffs to remove the protesters.

The trees occupied by the protesters were located in a 25-foot-wide workspace the company was trying to clearcut alongside of the 50-foot-wide easement.

Rich Raiders, the Gerharts’ attorney, said additional trees remain in the workspace, but he doesn’t know if pipeline opponents will attempt to re-colonize those.

Mr. Raiders said the company’s Sunday morning tree cutting may have violated a U.S. Forest Service seasonal prohibition against cutting trees in forested areas where the endangered Indiana bat is known to reside.

“There’s no evidence Sunoco received an incidental take permit or applied for a waiver from the Forest Service that would allow the cutting,” said Mr. Raiders, who filed a Freedom of Information Act request Monday to determine if such a request had been filed.

Ms. Dilinger said Energy Transfer partners “had permission from the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service to remove these trees.”

Mr. Raiders said the Gerharts also are pursuing a challenge to Sunoco’s wetlands disturbance permits with the state Environmental Hearing Board in Harrisburg.

“The basic question is do you have to look up to characterize a wetlands,” he said. “The state has characterized the wetlands on the Gerhart property as emergent, but the Gerhart wetlands are in a forested area that the state has told Sunoco it doesn’t need to consider.”

The state requires more protection for forest wetlands than emergent wetlands.

Sunoco is building the 350-mile-long, twin 24-inch-diameter pipelines to transport natural gas liquids from shale gas wells in western Pennsylvania to terminals near Philadelphia, where most of the liquids will be shipped to Scotland for plastics production.

Its parent firm, Dallas, Texas-based Energy Transfer Partners, is the same company that in 2016 used attack dogs, pepper spray and fire hoses on Native American protesters and their supporters blocking the construction route of the Dakota Access Pipeline near the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation in North Dakota.

CORRECTION: A former version of this article misspelled Elise Gerhart’s first name. This version has the correct spelling. 

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey

First Published: April 13, 2018, 7:07 p.m.

RELATED
A view  of one of the tree platforms on Ellen and Stephen Gerhart's property in Unity, Huntingdon County. A judge Thursday ordered that all structures, platforms, tents, vehicles and equipment be removed from the area of an easement between the property and land that Sunoco will be building its Mariner East 2 pipelines.
Paula Reed Ward
Judge rules in favor of Sunoco in Huntingdon County pipeline dispute
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Pedestrians walk past the Pennsylvania Capitol in Harrisburg, where the governor's office is located. Republicans are planning their 2026 bid to unseat incumbent Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro..
1
news
Pa. Republicans planning 'unified and strategic' approach to unseating Josh Shapiro in 2026
Bill Sunseri, president of Pennsylvania Macaroni Co., stands in his family’s store on Jan. 6 in the Strip District.
2
life
Pennsylvania Macaroni Co. has a new full owner at the helm
Texas A&M's Shemar Stewart (4) runs off the field during the second half of an NCAA college football game against Auburn, Saturday, Nov. 23, 2024, in Auburn, Ala.
3
sports
Ray Fittipaldo's first 7-round Steelers mock draft: Deep DL class too enticing?
Firefighters responded to a house fire in Upper St. Clair on Thursday, Jan. 23, 2025. One person was killed, and four were injured, including two police officers.
4
local
A wave of deadly Pittsburgh-area house fires puts a spotlight on safety
Meredith Miller of Upper St. Clair.
5
news
Woman who died in Upper St. Clair fire remembered as devoted churchgoer and teacher
A view of one of the tree platforms on Ellen and Stephen Gerhart's property in Huntingdon County in June 2017. Protesters against the building of the Sunoco Mariner East 2 Pipeline project through the Gerhart's property occupied trees to prevent construction of the pipeline. Trees with platforms were cut down Sunday.  (Darrell Sapp/Post-Gazette)
A view of one of the tree platforms on Ellen and Stephen Gerhart's property in Huntingdon County on June 27, 2017. Protesters against the building of the Sunoco Mariner East 2 Pipeline project through the Gerharts' property occupied tree platforms until Sunday, when trees were cut down.  (Darrell Sapp/Post-Gazette)
A project sign on Ellen and Stephen Gerhart's property in Unity Township In Huntingdon County on June 27, 2017.  (Darrell Sapp/Post-Gazette)
Signs from protesters hanging over Ellen and Stephen Gerhart's property in Huntingdon County in June. Protesters against the building of the Sunoco Mariner East 2 Pipeline project through the Gerhart's property occupied tree stands until Sunday, when the trees were cut down.  (Darrell Sapp/Post-Gazette)
Josh Michener, of Idaho, stands in his "kitchen" where he cooks, on Ellen and Stephen Gerhart's property in Huntingdon County in June. Trees with platforms occupied by protesters to prevent construction of a Sunoco pipeline were cut down Sunday.  (Darrell Sapp/Post-Gazette)
Darrell Sapp/Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST business
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story