Thursday, February 13, 2025, 12:47PM |  45°
MENU
Advertisement
Pittsburgh corporate and constitutional attorney David Porter at his Downtown offices at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney.
3
MORE

Why Bob Casey thinks the confirmation hearing for Pittsburgh attorney David Porter is breaking protocol

Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Why Bob Casey thinks the confirmation hearing for Pittsburgh attorney David Porter is breaking protocol

WASHINGTON — David Porter will almost certainly join the bench of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, but the Pittsburgh attorney and Trump judicial nominee first will have to run a gantlet of angry Democrats who believe he never should have gotten this far in the confirmation process.

Mr. Porter faces what promises to be a contentious confirmation hearing Wednesday, but not all of the angst will be directed toward him.

Democrats — particularly Sen. Bob Casey of Pennsylvania — are furious that Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, deviated from protocol when he scheduled the confirmation hearing in the first place.

Advertisement

Under Senate custom — but not a hard and fast rule — hearings are not scheduled without the consent of both of a nominee’s home-state senators, who sign off on forms known as blue slips. Mr. Casey has withheld his, but Mr. Grassley is proceeding anyway just as he did with three other nominees of President Donald Trump who lacked blue slips.

Pittsburgh corporate and constitutional attorney David Porter  at his Downtown offices at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney.  President Donald Trump has nominated Porter to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Tracie Mauriello
Pittsburgh judicial nominee tells senators his ideology won't influence his ability to apply precedent

During the Obama administration, Mr. Grassley held fast to the blue-slip custom by refusing to schedule a hearing for Rebecca Ross Haywood for the same court to which Mr. Porter has been nominated. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., withheld his blue slip because he didn’t like her answers to his questions about the constitutionality of executive actions.

At the time, Mr. Toomey criticized President Barack Obama’s “my way or the highway” approach and accused him of “blowing up a bipartisan working arrangement” by nominating Ms. Haywood over his objections.

Mr. Trump did the same with Mr. Porter after Mr. Casey made it clear that he did not support the nomination, only this time Mr. Grassley is pushing it through anyway.

Advertisement

Mr. Grassley also circumvented the blue slip tradition for 8th Circuit nominee David Stras, 7th Circuit nominee Michael Brennan and 9th Circuit nominee Ryan Bounds. All were nominated by Mr. Trump.

“Those are bad but this one is particularly bad because of what Toomey did with Haywood. Toomey wouldn’t move on a blue slip, and that was the end of it,” said Carl Tobias, a University of Richmond professor of law who tracks judicial nominations. “It’s such an incredibly double standard being applied now.”

That kind of inconsistency dishonors the traditions of the Senate, he said.

“Traditionally, the Senate operates on senatorial courtesy and values what the home-state senators have to say,” Mr. Tobias said.

Pittsburgh corporate and constitutional attorney David Porter in a April 10, 2018, file photo at his Downtown offices at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney. President Donald Trump has nominated Porter to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Tracie Mauriello
Even founders appear unaware of group at center of judicial nomination controversy

Mr. Casey said Monday that this nomination tarnishes the seven-year history of his and Sen. Toomey’s efforts to jointly nominate judges, 17 of whom were confirmed.

“When the shoe was on the other foot in 2015 and President Obama nominated Rebecca Haywood, not only did I respect Sen. Toomey’s decision not to return the blue slip, but the Senate Judiciary Committee did as well and didn’t hold a hearing,” Mr. Casey said Monday. “I am only asking for the same respect.”

His statement left out that back then he had asked for a “fair hearing and timely vote” on Ms. Haywood despite Mr. Toomey’s objections.

A spokesman for Mr. Grassley did not respond to a request for comment.

“Having separate policies based on whether the chairman and president are of the same party is inconsistent with a democracy operating under the rule of law,” Marge Baker, executive vice president of People for the American Way, told Mr. Grassley in a letter. “Seeing a confirmation system so lacking in integrity, the American people could not be blamed for increasingly regarding the courts as yet another partisan branch of government. That undercuts the legitimacy of our judicial system.”

Groups including the Alliance for Justice and Why Courts Matter Pennsylvania also oppose the nomination because they believe Mr. Porter is too conservative and even “hostile” toward workers’ rights, reproductive rights, LGBTQ rights and racial equality.

A report issued by the Alliance for Justice criticizes Mr. Porter for publishing articles critical of the Affordable Care Act; for his association with a think tank that hosts anti-LGBTQ speakers; and for praising former Attorney General John Ashcroft for his pro-life, pro-death penalty and anti-gun control views.

Supporters of Mr. Porter, including longtime friend Paul J. McNulty, president of Grove City College, have said he is smart, capable, respects precedent and would follow the law even if it conflicted with his personal beliefs.

Mr. Porter is a shareholder at the Pittsburgh office of Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney, where he has practiced law for more than 23 years.

The 3rd Circuit hears cases from Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and the Virgin Islands.

Correction: David Porter is a Pittsburgh attorney. His profession was incorrect in an earlier version of this story.

Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.

First Published: June 5, 2018, 1:06 a.m.
Updated: June 5, 2018, 3:29 a.m.

RELATED
David Porter
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Senate holds off on vote for federal judgeships, including Pittsburgh nominee for appeals court
Lou Barletta and Bob Casey.
Julian Routh
Lou Barletta and Bob Casey: I know you are but what am I?
Pittsburgh corporate and constitutional attorney David Porter poses for a portrait on Tuesday, April 10, 2018, at his Downtown offices at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney.  President Donald Trump has nominated Porter to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Tracie Mauriello
Pennsylvania senators split over Trump's David Porter nomination
Pittsburgh corporate and constitutional attorney David Porter poses for a portrait on Tuesday, April 10, 2018, at his Downtown offices at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney.  President Donald Trump has nominated Porter to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Tracie Mauriello
Trump nominates Pittsburgh attorney to U.S. Circuit Court
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Salem’s Market beat out three other finalists in 2021 for the right to operate the Hill District store.
1
business
Hill District Salem's Market halting operations one year after opening
Former detainee Marc Fogel stands with an American flag around his neck as he is welcomed to the White House after he was freed from Russia in Washington, D.C, on Feb. 11, 2025.
2
news
Ex-Venezuelan prisoner sheds light on Marc Fogel's ‘huge challenge’ as he reintegrates into society
Steelers coach Mike Tomlin walks off the field after losing to the Baltimore Ravens at M&T Bank Stadium on Saturday, Jan. 11, 2025, in Baltimore.
3
sports
Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag: Is player development the team’s primary problem?
Competitors in the Flagship Ice Open wait to get started in the predawn darkness on Feb. 1. The event drew 51 two-person teams.
4
life
Lake Erie Ice fishing tournament pulls in over 100 anglers and a 2.17-pound yellow perch
The Market Square rehab will include an anchor structure, new lighting and pavers, and other enhancements. Traffic will be limited to the north side of the square and all parking will be eliminated to create more outdoor dining space..
5
business
'A little worried': Market Square merchants greet multimillion-dollar rehab project with trepidation
Pittsburgh corporate and constitutional attorney David Porter at his Downtown offices at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney.  (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
Pittsburgh corporate and constitutional attorney David Porter  (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, arrives for a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington in 2017.  (Carolyn Kaster/Associated Press)
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story