Friday, March 14, 2025, 2:35AM |  62°
MENU
Advertisement
House Speaker Paul Ryan is facing a primary challenge from, among others, Paul Nehlen, a 47-year-old businessman who supports Donald Trump.
1
MORE

Paul Ryan stares down a GOP revolt in his backyard

Win McNamee/Getty Images

Paul Ryan stares down a GOP revolt in his backyard

JANESVILLE, Wis. — House Speaker Paul Ryan’s red-brick Georgian revival house in this tree-lined, kid-filled Midwestern neighborhood has long been his “refuge,” as his wife calls it, from the divisive world of politics. But no more — not in this Donald Trump-fueled, anger-filled year for a Republican Party leader facing a primary challenge.

Fuming activists have inched close to the Wisconsin congressman’s property several times as part of protests that have drawn the notice of the U.S. Capitol Police detail that watches his residence. A nearby billboard has portrayed Mr. Ryan as soft on terrorism. At one sidewalk standoff, his primary opponent — Paul Nehlen, a 47-year-old businessman with tattooed biceps and a deep affinity for Mr. Trump — cast Mr. Ryan’s backyard fence as an elitist barricade that protects the speaker while his constituents are exposed to the dangers of illegal immigration.

“You should tear down your wall and show everyone that you will live under the same conditions as they do,” Mr. Nehlen declared last month as his backers, in matching navy blue T-shirts, stood in front of Mr. Ryan’s bushes. They nodded solemnly as he called Mr. Ryan a tool of “corporate masters.”

Advertisement

Perhaps the most unsettling moment came when a group of mothers whose children had been killed by illegal immigrants staked out Mr. Ryan’s home while he was inside and tried to confront him with poster-size images of the deceased. Breitbart News, the conservative outlet that has extensively chronicled Mr. Nehlen’s bid, wrote that “Ryan and members of his security detail fled from his guarded estate” after he was spotted slamming a door on his porch.

A blurry picture of the departing motorcade was pasted on the website alongside the article, which has drawn thousands of comments, nearly all of them harshly critical of Mr. Ryan.

This is seen as the bracing new reality for the speaker. Though he is expected to easily win Tuesday, Mr. Ryan and most Republican leaders find themselves caught in an incendiary populist vortex that is unrelenting in its animus toward seasoned elected officials, in particular those like Mr. Ryan who have encouraged bipartisan immigration reform.

“It’s a weird time,” said former secretary of education William Bennett, a Ryan confidant for decades. “He’s doing everything he can to be Paul Ryan, the guy from Janesville who goes to the county fairs and who used to drive around the Oscar Mayer Wienermobile. But it gets nasty when they don’t leave the house, the wife and kids alone.”

Advertisement

Mr. Trump has inflamed the embers. The mogul coyly said in an interview with The Washington Post last week that he was not yet ready to endorse Mr. Ryan, possible payback for the delayed and pro-forma endorsement Mr. Ryan gave earlier this year to Mr. Trump. Mr. Trump’s move was viewed as extraordinary — a presidential nominee refusing to back his party’s House speaker — and instantly jolted Mr. Nehlen from obscurity to the roiling edge of the Republican hurricane.

Mr. Trump’s wavering lasted until Friday night when, under intense pressure from party leaders, he relented and endorsed Mr. Ryan at a rally in Green Bay.

“He’s a good man,” Mr. Trump said with muted enthusiasm. “We may disagree on a couple of things, but mostly we agree.”

Mr. Nehlen had driven to the event, about a three-hour drive north and outside of the district, to be with his people. His crushed supporters took bitterly to social media in the aftermath, though Mr. Nehlen said in a statement that Mr. Trump’s “early refusal” was more telling.

“Happy Warrior returns home,” Mr. Nehlen wrote in a Twitter post after the rally, smiling in a selfie with his Trump-style red tie loose and clutching a Trump campaign banner he called a “hard fought trophy.”

Mr. Trump’s needling began months ago when he held a rally in Janesville in late March ahead of the Wisconsin GOP presidential primary, which he lost to Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas. Supporters booed Mr. Trump’s mention of the town’s favorite son.

“How do you like Paul Ryan? You like him?” Mr. Trump asked the crowd. “I was told to be nice to Paul Ryan.”

Ryan supporters, then and now, have shrugged at those theatrics, pointing to Mr. Cruz’s double-digit victory over Mr. Trump, which included a 19-point win in Mr. Ryan’s suburban and blue-collar district, as compelling evidence of Mr. Trump’s limited political capital in the state.

GOP leaders in the state and community have flocked to Mr. Ryan’s side as he dealt with Mr. Trump’s lingering spite. Gov. Scott Walker and Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin did not attend Mr. Trump’s Friday rally. Republican National Committee Chairman Reince Priebus, who grew up in Kenosha, Wis., and is close with Mr. Ryan, played a central role in getting Mr. Trump to back down.

As GOP forces rush to protect Mr. Ryan from the wrath of Mr. Trump, stars from the conservative counter-establishment — former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, columnist Michelle Malkin and author Phyllis Schlafly, among others — have continued to stoke the fury here, with the faint and fading hope that Mr. Nehlen could close the gap in the final days and score an upset similar to the one in 2014 that toppled then-House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, R-Va.

“I think Paul Ryan is soon to be ‘Cantored,’ as in Eric Cantor,” Ms. Palin predicted to CNN in May. Minutes after Mr. Trump’s endorsement of Mr. Ryan on Friday, she took to Facebook to buck up Mr. Nehlen’s base, writing, “Wisconsin, please vote for this man ‘of the people’ this Tuesday!”

The races are not the same, though. Mr. Ryan has remained ubiquitous in his district after becoming speaker and spent more than $600,000 over the past month on television ads. Mr. Cantor was criticized for his lack of a presence at local events, dismissed the appetite for an alternative and thought that he would comfortably coast right up until the results started coming in.

Mr. Nehlen’s top advisers, Noel Fritsch and Eric Odom, bring with them experience with past insurgent conservative campaigns. Mr. Fritsch worked in the Mississippi Senate primary two years ago that drew national attention for its discord, and Mr. Odom was one of the original organizers of the tea party movement. Politico has reported that a handful of former Trump campaign staffers have traveled to Wisconsin to volunteer.

On Saturday, firebrand commentator Ann Coulter crisscrossed the sprawling southeastern Wisconsin district with Mr. Ryan’s rival, and some Democrats have been planning to vote for Mr. Nehlen in what is usually a sleepy open primary, with the mischievous, if unrealistic, aim of making Mr. Ryan’s margin of victory narrow — especially if turnout is low.

Mr. Ryan’s district has seen its share of economic turmoil in the past decade, which Mr. Nehlen’s campaign insists makes his message and his emphasis on his time on factory floors, when he worked for a water-filtration company, right for the times. Janesville is home to a General Motors plant that shuttered in 2009 and once employed 7,000 workers. Many of the white working-class and middle-class people in the area commute to corporate and service jobs in Chicago, Milwaukee and Madison, Wis.

At a news conference last week in Kenosha, Mr. Nehlen said anyone who doesn’t believe he has a chance is buying into the “narrative” of the political class.

In Trumpian fashion, Mr. Nehlen railed against the “worst” trade deals and against Mr. Ryan for “funding everything the Obama administration wants, and more, and they were shocked at what they got.”

“What’s Paul Ryan done?” Mr. Nehlen, in his flat monotone, asked as reporters and camera crews stood silent. “Paul Ryan has gone to mountain estates, behind closed doors to talk about, hmm, what do they talk about behind those closed doors at those mountain estates? They talk about bringing cheap labor into this country and flooding, flooding this country with as much free labor as we can possibly get, so we can keep the wages low.”

Mr. Nehlen’s peculiar, even menacing, approach has been a constant throughout the campaign, beyond the scrums near Mr. Ryan’s lawn.

On Twitter, he has skewered Mr. Ryan’s longtime associates Dan Senor and Cesar Conda as “puppets of billionaires” and scheming “globalists.” On Monday, he suggested there should be a “discussion” about deporting all Muslims from the United States, later saying he meant only “sharia compliant” Muslims.

Mr. Ryan hasn’t hidden his frustration. “It’s kind of petty to actually do that, to go to a person’s house,” he told a local television station last month. “Having a backyard fence for three dogs and three kids is not a half-bad idea.”

Mr. Ryan was worried about the personal attacks coming so close to his wife and children last October, when he was hesitant to become speaker. “I genuinely worry about the consequences that my agreeing to serve will have on them,” he said then. “Will they experience the viciousness and incivility that we all here face on a daily basis?”

Mr. Ryan said Friday on local host Jay Weber’s radio show that Mr. Nehlen’s campaign is fueled by “scam PACs” and “out of state” donors.

“They’re not pushing conservatism. They call this alt-conservatism,” Mr. Ryan said. When Weber said his foes had ties to white supremacists and fringe elements, Mr. Ryan did not argue the point.

“It’s a nasty, virulent strain of something,” Mr. Ryan said, repeating the host’s words back to him. “I don’t even know what it is other than that it isn’t us. It isn’t what we believe in.”

Polls show Mr. Ryan poised to romp. A poll released Thursday by Republican outfit Remington Research found Mr. Ryan up by 66 points, 80 percent to 14 percent, with 6 percent undecided.

Mr. Ryan’s campaign, typical of a well-known incumbent, has assiduously avoided doing anything that would give the race a whiff of competitiveness. He has not accepted Mr. Nehlen’s debate invitations, and Mr. Ryan’s spokesman has declined to share an advisory of his campaign stops with reporters. Instead, he has sent a listing of Mr. Ryan’s radio interviews.

“You guys came in to cover a race that’s not close,” a Ryan aide wrote in an email Thursday.

Brian Baker, president of the Ending Spending super PAC aligned with the wealthy Ricketts family that owns the Chicago Cubs and backs Mr. Ryan, said his group has closely monitored the race and commissioned private primary polls. After reviewing its data, he concluded that Mr. Ryan was safe and no outside support was necessary.

Whatever the result, Mr. Ryan will move forward with battle scars, which makes the contest at least intriguing — and depressing to Ryan allies.

No longer is the party’s highly respected 2012 vice-presidential nominee totally at ease in the district he has represented since he was 28. The winds that have lifted Mr. Nehlen still swirl on Capitol Hill, where the speaker has struggled at times to keep together his raucous Republican conference.

“What I’d tell Paul is, ‘I told you so.’ When he was thinking hard about becoming speaker, I said it was always going to be one rough ride,” Mr. Bennett said. “He anticipated the wayward members part of it — probably not Trump.”

First Published: August 7, 2016, 4:00 a.m.

RELATED
Comments Disabled For This Story
Partners
Advertisement
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin, left, reacts during the first half of an NFL football game against the Los Angeles Chargers, Sunday, Sept. 22, 2024, in Pittsburgh.
1
sports
Joe Starkey: Stories of freshly departed Steelers don’t reflect well on Mike Tomlin, Omar Khan
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin greets New York Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) after an NFL football game, Sunday, Oct. 20, 2024, in Pittsburgh.
2
sports
Gerry Dulac: Steelers have made offer to Aaron Rodgers, but holdup has nothing to do with money
Pittsburgh Steelers newly signed free agent wide receiver DK Metcalf meets with reporters in Pittsburgh, Thursday, March 13, 2025.
3
sports
Newly engaged DK Metcalf 'ecstatic' to be a Steeler, swap wisdom with George Pickens
After years of declining population, Allegheny County has experienced a rare turnaround due to a surge in immigration that began in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic..
4
local
After years of decline, wave of new immigrants boosts Allegheny County's population
In this file photo, former Pittsburgh Steelers running back Le'Veon Bell watches from the sideline as he waits for the end of the AFC championship, Sunday, Jan. 22, 2017, in Foxborough, Mass. Bell was ordered to pay $25 million in damages to a relative who claimed in a civil lawsuit that Bell sexually abused her when she was a child.
5
news
Former Steelers RB Le'Veon Bell ordered to pay $25 million in sexual abuse case
House Speaker Paul Ryan is facing a primary challenge from, among others, Paul Nehlen, a 47-year-old businessman who supports Donald Trump.  (Win McNamee/Getty Images)
Win McNamee/Getty Images
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story