Saturday, February 22, 2025, 7:30AM |  26°
MENU
Advertisement
A Pittsburgh police officer walks past the Tree of Life Synagogue and a memorial of flowers and stars in Pittsburgh on Oct. 28, 2018.
1
MORE

After the Squirrel Hill massacre, synagogues across the U.S. weigh adding more security

AP photo/Gene J. Puskar

After the Squirrel Hill massacre, synagogues across the U.S. weigh adding more security

Tree of Life synagogue had practiced active-shooter drills. Staff members knew the protocols, and they had assessed the building’s security just last year. On high holidays, police officers would keep watch outside the synagogue.

But like many synagogues across the country, Tree of Life had its doors open for Saturday’s Shabbat services, welcoming its congregants. After a gunman entered and killed 11 people in the worst single attack on American Jews in U.S. history, President Donald Trump and others have suggested that armed guards stationed outside the synagogue might have prevented the carnage.

Now political and Jewish leaders across the country are grappling with whether that suggestion makes sense. How can they best secure religious spaces and still strike the proper balance between protecting congregants and creating a welcoming place of worship?

Advertisement

For the Jewish community, the debate surrounding synagogue security is not new, but Saturday’s massacre could usher in a new era of ramped-up security measures.

This courtroom sketch depicts Robert Gregory Bowers, who was wounded in a gun battle with police as he appeared in a wheelchair at federal court on Monday, Oct. 29, 2018, in Pittsburgh. Bowers, accused in the Pittsburgh synagogue massacre, appeared briefly in federal court in a wheelchair and handcuffs Monday to face charges he killed 11 people.
Rich Lord, Christopher Huffaker and Liz Navratil
A high school dropout and trucker, Robert Bowers left few footprints — except online

Rabbi Aaron Alexander of Adas Israel Congregation in Washington said the attack is a “game changer” for Jews, and for security at synagogues. While security budgets at synagogues have increased in recent years, Jewish communities have felt - accurately or not - a bit safer than smaller religious minorities in America, such as Muslims or Sikhs. That, he predicts, is about to change.

“Many of us knew a moment like this would happen and people would begin to feel more vulnerable in Jewish spaces, as many minorities feel,” he said. “In that way, I think the culture is shifting.”

On Sunday morning, Jewish leaders from across the country took part in a phone call with the FBI over security concerns, and many have been in close communication with the Secure Community Network, a nonprofit clearinghouse for information and training on how to handle potential threats to Jewish institutions.

Advertisement

Michael Masters, the network’s chief executive and national director, said there has been a significant increase in security precautions at Jewish centers across the country in response to a rise in mass shootings and anti-Semitic attacks in the United States and Europe.

When the Secure Community Network was formed in 2004, only two of the 147 Jewish Federations found in most U.S. metropolitan areas with a large Jewish population had a full-time security director. Now that number is at 30, and Mr. Masters expects it to continue to grow. “I think we’re going to see the trend continuing.”

The Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh, for example, two years ago hired former FBI Agent Brad Orsini as the director of Jewish community security. Since then, the region has focused on building security, better coordination among synagogues and Jewish agencies and training staff on handling emergencies, according to Adam Hertzman, director of marketing at Pittsburgh’s federation.

Security measures depend largely on a synagogue’s size and budget. Larger synagogues generally have more robust security infrastructure than smaller congregations like Tree of Life, Mr. Masters said.

The Tree of Life synagogue in Squirrel Hill.
Shelly Bradbury
Pittsburgh's Jewish leaders, FBI worked together in aftermath of Tree of Life shootings

Har Shalom, the largest Conservative synagogue in Potomac, Md., for example, has an armed police presence during services, Hebrew school sessions and on-site events, Rabbi Adam Raskin said. “Security is now a big part of our budget, unfortunately,” he said.

Rabbi Raskin’s rabbinical career has spanned 16 years, but this is the first time his congregation has had a security committee. For years, synagogues have ignored the occasional kooky piece of mail or message. Now, Rabbi Raskin said, the temple contacts the police immediately.

The synagogue has never held an active-shooter evacuation drill during services, Rabbi Raskin said. “Now, I think we’re going to have a serious conversation about it.”

For smaller synagogues with tighter budgets, paying for security measures such as armed guards might be financially impossible.

“To add a security guard could be prohibitive, and it could really cause people to choose between the kind of security that they have come to believe they need and the ability to gather in the first place,” said Jack Moline of the Washington-based Interfaith Alliance.

Rabbi Alexander, the rabbi at Adas Israel, said there is talk of trying to create a shared fund to help smaller synagogues or all small religious minorities that need assistance hiring security.

Ron Halber, executive director of the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Washington, said he feels the federal government needs to provide more resources to help synagogues fund security measures.

“How do we sustain this long term?” Mr. Halber asked. “. . . We can’t go back to business as usual.”

Edward Hamburg, a past president of Rodfei Zedek, a synagogue on the south side of Chicago, said he worried that U.S. synagogues could begin to mirror those in Europe with heavy security.

“We have taken steps to secure the synagogue, and will take more, but it will fall far short of what Mr. Trump is suggesting,” Mr. Hamburg said. “There are cameras, there will be controlled traffic, there will be increased police patrols. I think the question will be how much further do we have to go in response to the situation?”

Some Orthodox congregations might have religious barriers to putting in place certain security measures, such as electronic identification systems, Mr. Moline said. Orthodox Jews refrain from using electronic devices from sundown on Friday to Saturday evening.

If synagogues start ratcheting up their security, with metal detectors and armed guards, some worry about the message it would send to congregants seeking a place of peace and holiness.

“We’ve always had this tension between wanting to be open to the community and wanting to be secure and a safe place,” said Karen Brean, president of the board of trustees at Rodef Shalom, a Pittsburgh synagogue located down the road from Tree of Life. “Is this the kind of thing that we’re going to expect on Shabbat morning, every week?”

First Published: October 29, 2018, 8:30 a.m.

RELATED
An FBI agent stands behind a police cordon outside the Tree of Life Synagogue after a shooting there left 11 people dead in Squirrel Hill on Oct. 27, 2018.
Kayla Epstein and Alex Horton
Many Orthodox Jews turned their phones on at the Sabbath’s end — then learned of a massacre
Law enforcement officers secure the scene where multiple people were shot, Oct, 27, 2018, at The Tree of Life Congregation synagogue in Squirrel Hill.
Liz Navaratil
Federal prosecutors seek death penalty for Robert Bowers
Samina Mohamedali, of North Hills, prepares to place flowers on a memorial, as other members of Pittsburgh's Dawoodi Bohra Muslim community look at the memorial, in front of the Tree of Life Congregation, Sunday, Oct. 28, 2018, in Squirrel Hill.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Names of deceased victims in Squirrel Hill massacre released
Married couple Sylvan and Bernice Simon were among the 11 people killed in the attack at the Tree of Life synagogue on Oct. 27, 2018, in Squirrel Hill.
Related Story
Bernice and Sylvan Simon, a married couple, were victims of synagogue shooting
From left, Mayor Bill Peduto, CEO of the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh Jeffrey Finkelstein, U.S. Attorney Scott Brady, Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Karl Williams, and Special Agent Robert Jones with the FBI, stand together as the names of the eleven victims are released a day after the Tree of Life Congregation shooting Sunday at the Allegheny County Emergency Services building in Point Breeze.
Shelly Bradbury and Ashley Murray
'Darkest day in Pittsburgh's history': Officials discuss new details in Squirrel Hill massacre
In this file photo, President Donald Trump speaks with reporters before departing Indianapolis International Airport for a rally in Illinois on Oct. 27, 2018, in Indianapolis.
Felicia Sonmez, Michelle Ye Hee Lee and Paul Kane
Don’t link political rhetoric to the Pittsburgh synagogue attack, Trump’s White House says
Allderdice head coach Jerry Haslett watches during a preseason football practice on Wednesday, July 26, 2017.
Mike White
City League football championship rescheduled in wake of Squirrel Hill shooting
David Lasky, of Lancaster, left, and Anya Weitzman, of Wilkinsburg, are illuminated by candles as they attend a vigil for the victims of the Tree of Life Synagogue mass shooting at Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall and Museum on Sunday October 28, 2018, in Squirrel Hill. (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Peter Smith
'We will not be broken:' Emotional vigil held for victims of Squirrel Hill synagogue shooting
A sign on the front door of Pinskers, a Jewish gift store on Murray Ave. in Squirrel Hill, says
Andrew Goldstein
A vibrant, welcoming neighborhood is infused with anguish after shooting
Rich Gottfried, center, carries the main Torah as members of the New Light Jewish congregation march with Torah scrolls along Denniston Street Nov. 12, 2017,  to their new home at Tree of Life synagogue.
Marylynne Pitz/ Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Richard Gottfried, synagogue shooting victim, worked to help refugees and immigrants
Daniel Stein, who died in the mass shooting incident at a Squirrel Hill synagogue.
Related Story
"He would do anything for anybody:" Daniel Stein made even the toughest tasks enjoyable
Joyce Fienberg, 75, of Oakland, seen here in an undated photo, was shot and killed Saturday, Oct. 27 in the Tree of Life Congregation on Wilkins Avenue in Squirrel Hill. Photo provided by Christopher Genovese
Related Story
Joyce Fienberg, longtime Pitt researcher, devoted grandmother
Tree of Life shooting victim Irving Younger with his grandson Jaden.
Related Story
'He would never walk away from anybody': Shooting victim Irving Younger remembered for friendly spirit
Brothers David and Cecil Rosenthal
Related Story
Brothers killed in synagogue attack had 'a love for life and for those around them'
Dr. Jerry Rabinowitz, who was killed in the mass shooting at a Squirrel Hill synagogue.
Related Story
Synagogue shooting victim Dr. Jerry Rabinowitz remembered as 'one of the finest people'
Mourners place flowers at a memorial Sunday, Oct. 28, 2018, for the 11 victims killed in the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Squirrel Hill.
Gary Rotstein
Talking to kids about Tree of Life horror: Be honest but brief, avoid media excess
Melvin Wax, 87, is survived by one daughter, Jodi Kart, her husband Todd Kart, and their son Matthew Kart.
Related Story
Melvin Wax, retired accountant always ready with a joke
Pittsburgh police officer Tim Matson is seen here after receiving an award at the 19th Annual Law Enforcement Agency Directors Awards Ceremony on Jan. 27, 2017. Officer Matson was one of four officers wounded in the Squirrel Hill synagogue mass shooting on Oct. 27, 2018.
Shelly Bradbury
Veteran police officer, UPMC chaplain among wounded in synagogue mass shooting
Vigil participants hold candles and sing a Jewish prayer during a Havdalah vigil for the victims of the Tree of Life Congregation shooting in front of the White House on October 27, 2018 in Washington, DC.
Julian Routh
Vigils held nationwide to honor victims of Squirrel Hill synagogue shooting
Law enforcement officers check possible entrances to the Tree of Life synagogue where 11 people were killed Saturday.
Shelly Bradbury
Timeline of terror: A moment-by-moment account of Squirrel Hill mass shooting
Robert Bowers, the suspect in Saturday's mass shooting at the Tree of Life Congregation in Squirrel Hill.
Rich Lord and Ashley Murray
Bowers' favorite social media site reeling, defiant
The man behind the Tree of Life 'Stronger Than Hate' image says every posting is 'a WIN for love'
Maria Sciullo
The man behind the Tree of Life 'Stronger Than Hate' image says every posting is 'a WIN for love'
Midtown Towers in Downtown Pittsburgh was the site of a fatal fire that sparked a discussion about mandating sprinklersin older high rises.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Pittsburgh pushes back public hearing on sprinkler proposal
“There’s just so many people in that community that I care about that shouldn’t have to go through with that,” Steelers defensive captain Cam Heyward said.
Sean Gentille
Sean Gentille: Cam Heyward isn't just a Steeler. He's part of Squirrel Hill.
A message left with flowers at the corner of Shady and Wilkins Avenues near the  Tree of Life Synagogue, Tuesday morning Oct.30, 2018 in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Show your support: Leave messages for the Tree of Life and Squirrel Hill communities
Rose Mallinger was one of 11 people killed in the mass shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Squirrel Hill on Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018. Photo provided by UPMC on behalf of the family
Related Story
Synagogue victim Rose Mallinger was a young 97
Law enforcement runs with a person on a stretcher at the scene where multiple people were shot, Oct, 27, 2018, at The Tree of Life Congregation synagogue in Squirrel Hill.
Paula Reed Ward
Authorities: Mass shooting suspect said he wanted 'all Jews to die'
Steelers guard Ramon Foster congratulates running back James Conner after he scored against the Browns in the third quarter Sunday, Oct. 28, 2018, at Heinz Field.
Ed Bouchette
'Our city took a hit': Steelers put aside heartbreak, pound Browns at Heinz Field
A Steelers fan attaches a tribute to the shooting victims at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Squirrel Hill before the team's game against Cleveland Oct. 28, 2018, at Heinz Field.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Steelers, fans honor Squirrel Hill shooting victims
Kyle Parker and Lorea Stallard of Washington, D.C. embrace in front of the Tree of Life Congregation as the FBI continues its investigation of a mass shooting at the synagogue that killed 11 people on Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018, in Pittsburgh's Squirrel Hill neighborhood. The two wanted to pay their respects while in town for Sunday's Steelers game.
David Shribman
Dispatch from Squirrel Hill: Dread in a peaceful place
Mourners silently pray and pay their respects at the memorial for the victims of the Tree of Life Synagogue mass shooting on the intersection of Wilkins Ave and Murray Ave on Sunday October 28, 2018, in Squirrel Hill.
Arthi Subramaniam
After synagogue attack, Squirrel Hill restaurants help out in their own quiet way
Penguins offer ample assistance after Squirrel Hill tragedy
Jason Mackey
Penguins offer ample assistance after Squirrel Hill tragedy
Never the same
Related Story
Never the same
Editorial: Heal we must
the Editorial Board
Editorial: Heal we must
Flowers and homemade signs left by mourners at the memorial for the victims of the Tree of Life Synagogue mass shooting on the intersection of Wilkins Ave and Murray Ave on Sunday October 28, 2018, in Squirrel Hill.
Ashley Murray
Vigil for Squirrel Hill victims to be held at Soldiers and Sailors; Port Authority offering extra service
Amanda Godley hugs Joseph Creiman, both of Squirrel Hill, during a vigil, outside of the Sixth Presbyterian Church in Squirrel Hill Saturday
Ashley Murray
A roundup of resources for residents dealing with aftermath of mass shooting
A man holds his head as he is escorted out of the synagogue by police on the scene where multiple people were shot, Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018, at the Tree of Life Congregation in Squirrel Hill.
Kris Mamula, Andrew Goldstein, Paula Reed Ward, Liz Navratil and Shelly Bradbury
Eleven dead, six wounded in massacre at Squirrel Hill synagogue
Isabel Kinnane Smith of Allderdice High School is comforted by a math teacher from the school, Lesley Britton, at a vigil blocks from where a shooter shot and killed 11 people at Tree of Life Congregation synagogue on Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018, in Squirrel Hill.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
'Simply unconscionable': Nation, world mourn with Pittsburgh, react to deadly attack
In this Wednesday, July 20, 2016 photo, Israeli Dani Dayan speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in Jerusalem.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Israeli general consul stops in Pittsburgh for 'heartbreaking' visit
Pitt wide receiver Maurice Ffrench pulls in the go-ahead touchdown against Duke safety Leonard Johnson in the fourth quarter Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018, at Heinz Field.
Brian Batko
Pitt's offense — and a late touchdown pass — power rally past Duke
People gather for a vigil at Murray and Forbes avenues, blocks from where an active shooter shot multiple people at Tree of Life Congregation synagogue on Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018, in Squirrel Hill.
Marylynne Pitz and Peter Smith
Thousands gather for vigil honoring victims in Squirrel Hill shooting
Robert Bowers, the suspect in Saturday's mass shooting at the Tree of Life Congregation in Squirrel Hill.
Paula Reed Ward, Rich Lord and Liz Navratil
Dozens of federal, state charges filed against shooting suspect Robert Bowers
Law enforcement officers check possible entrances to the synagogue on the scene where multiple people were shot, Oct, 27, 2018, at The Tree of Life Congregation synagogue in Squirrel Hill.
Peter Smith
Shooting prompts Pittsburgh synagogues to go on lockdown but worship services continue
President Donald Trump speaks to supporters during a rally at the Southern Illinois Airport on Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018 in Murphysboro, Illinois.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Trump to visit Pittsburgh in wake of shooting; calls incident a 'wicked act of mass murder'
Dr. Don Yealy, chairman of emergency medicine at UPMC, provides an update on the victims during a press conference at the Allegheny County Emergency Management Center Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018 in Point Breeze.
Adam Smeltz
UPMC chaplain, in critical condition, identified among Squirrel Hill shooting survivors
Penguins captain Sidney Crosby works through drills during practice Tuesday, Sept. 25, 2018 at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex.
Matt Vensel
Sidney Crosby, Penguins react to 'terrible news' of Squirrel Hill mass shooting
Gov. Tom Wolf updates the media on the mass shooting at the Tree of Life Congregation in Squirrel Hill on Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018 in Pittsburgh.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Gov. Tom Wolf orders flags lowered to half-staff after Squirrel Hill mass shooting
A Port Authority bus in Downtown Pittsburgh
Ashley Murray
Port Authority will continue to detour 74 bus, other Squirrel Hill routes return to normal operations
A man holds his head as he's escorted out of the synagogue by police on the scene where multiple people were shot, Oct, 27, 2018, at The Tree of Life Congregation synagogue in Squirrel Hill.
the Editorial Board
Good and evil: Pittsburgh must rally after Saturday's shooting
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Preston Coleman, 52, was beaten and strangled inside an Aliquippa VFW on Jan. 5, 2025, in what police described as a vicious, unprovoked attack.
1
news
Bartender working at Aliquippa VFW during beating that left man unconscious facing charges
The University of Pittsburgh's Cathedral of Learning
2
business
Amid funding uncertainty, Pitt pauses doctoral admissions
Mayor Ed Gainey during  a press conference at the Downtown Public Safety Center on Thursday. He angrily criticized what he believes negative media coverage of his work as mayor.
3
opinion
Brandon McGinley: ‘The wheels are coming off’ the Gainey administration
Dr. Sylvia Owusu-Ansah helped writers of "The Pitt" with her perspective working in emergency medicine.
4
a&e
'It's very real,' says the Pittsburgh ER doctor who consulted on 'The Pitt' TV show
Longtime KDKA-TV host Jon Burnett on May 22, 2019.
5
a&e
Jon Burnett, long a KDKA-TV staple, leaves legacy of ‘putting good out into the world’
A Pittsburgh police officer walks past the Tree of Life Synagogue and a memorial of flowers and stars in Pittsburgh on Oct. 28, 2018.  (AP photo/Gene J. Puskar)
AP photo/Gene J. Puskar
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story