Thursday, February 20, 2025, 11:58AM |  15°
MENU
Advertisement

Lawsuit against Cranberry detective advances

Lawsuit against Cranberry detective advances

A federal appeals court, in a lengthy opinion issued Monday, found that a lawsuit filed by a Butler County sexual assault victim against the lead investigating officer on her case can move forward.

Sara Reedy, of Mars, filed the lawsuit against Cranberry Detective Frank Evanson in August 2006, claiming unlawful search and seizure, false imprisonment and malicious prosecution.

Ms. Reedy reported her attack the night it happened on July 14, 2004, at a Cranberry gas station where she was working. She was later charged by Officer Evanson for reporting a false crime, theft and receiving stolen property.

Advertisement

However, a suspect in two other sexual assaults -- one in Cranberry three months later and one in Brookville, Jefferson County, in August 2005 -- confessed to assaulting Ms. Reedy, as well as the other victim in Cranberry.

The charges against Ms. Reedy were dropped a short time later, and she filed the lawsuit.

In July 2008, Officer Evanson filed a motion for summary judgment, asking U.S. District Judge David S. Cercone to find in his favor and end the lawsuit.

The judge did.

Advertisement

However, according to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Judge Cercone failed to follow the standards of summary judgment, which requires a court to view the evidence in the case in the light most favorable to the non-moving party -- in this case, Ms. Reedy.

The appeals court chastised Judge Cercone throughout the 77-page opinion, finding that he often viewed evidence as being inculpatory of Ms. Reedy, when that is not how it should have been considered.

The court also criticized Judge Cercone for finding fault with Ms. Reedy's decision not to seek professional counseling after her assault.

"More specifically, the district court's implication that there is a duty to attend counseling is incorrect. There is no such duty," Circuit Judge Kent A. Jordan wrote. "Moreover, implicit in the court's conclusion that an inculpatory inference can be drawn from Reedy's decision not to attend counseling is a value judgment about how the victim sought to respond to trauma. That is a highly debatable judgment, lacking any foundation in the record."

The appeals court remanded the case against Officer Evanson back to U.S. District Court.

First Published: August 4, 2010, 4:00 a.m.

RELATED
Comments Disabled For This Story
Partners
Advertisement
Penguins hall of fame broadcaster Mike Lange works the play-by-play during the Alumni game at Heinz Field on Dec. 31, 2010.
1
sports
Mike Lange, longtime Penguins broadcaster, dies at 76
Penguins broadcaster Mike Lange during a press conference at Consol Energy Center.
2
sports
Jason Mackey: What Mike Lange meant to me, and why we must carry on his incredible legacy
Allegheny Hospital Network's first baby of 2025, Luka Gold Cunningham, was born at 12:45 a.m. New Year's Day at AHN Wexford Hospital. He wouldn't have made the top baby names for 2024 but, for 2025, who knows?
3
news
AHN reveals its top baby names of 2024
Vice President JD Vance swears in Pete Hegseth to be Secretary of Defense.
4
opinion
David Mills: Why Christians cheer Donald Trump and his destructive crusade
Gov. Josh Shapiro has nominated a former Beaver County superintendent to lead the Pennsylvania Department of Education.
5
news
Former Beaver County superintendent tapped by Shapiro to lead Pennsylvania Department of Education
Advertisement
LATEST local
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story