Monday, February 17, 2025, 9:40PM |  24°
MENU
Advertisement
This chart of attorney H. Yale Gutnick's roles in late publisher Richard Mellon Scaife's business and personal life was produced and filed in court by attorneys for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife, the deceased's daughter and son.
1
MORE

Scaife children claim attorney improperly withholding documents

Allegheny County Court

Scaife children claim attorney improperly withholding documents

In a three-year-old lawsuit involving one of Pittsburgh’s largest estates, attorneys for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife contend in a court motion filed Friday that their late father’s longtime attorney and confidant is improperly withholding documents.

The siblings allege in the motion that attorney H. Yale Gutnick and his firm, Strassburger McKenna Gutnick & Gefsky, are trying to withhold communications involving late publisher Richard Mellon Scaife under attorney-client privilege, even though they held so many roles in his financial empire that they could not reasonably expect confidentiality.

By having roles in family trusts including a disputed fund created in 1935, in the Tribune-Review media properties for which that fund was emptied, and with Mr. Scaife personally, Mr. Gutnick and the firm were “in a conflict of interest,” according to attorneys for Jennie Scaife, 54, of Florida, and David Scaife, 51, of Shadyside.

Advertisement

"Gutnick served as Trustee of the 1935 Trust and also as personal legal counsel to Mr. Scaife and Mr. Scaife's agent under power of attorney. Gutnick also served as an officer and member of the Board of the Tribune-Review, as well as its counsel,” according to the motion, which includes a detailed chart of the roles. “By serving in these roles, Gutnick was in a conflict of interest."

This chart of attorney H. Yale Gutnick's roles in late publisher Richard Mellon Scaife's business and personal life was produced and filed in court by attorneys for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife, the deceased's daughter and son.
Rich Lord
Scaife fund case mired in disputes

The disputed trust fund at the center of the case was created 82 years ago by Richard Mellon Scaife's mother, Sarah Mellon Scaife. She dedicated it to supporting her son's welfare, with the balance upon his death to go to his children. There was nothing left for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife upon the publisher’s 2014 death.

The vast bulk of the $450 million withdrawn from the fund over 20 years propped up the Tribune-Review. Now the late publisher’s daughter and son want trustees Mr. Gutnick, James Walton and PNC Bank to pay them an unspecified amount to make up for the spent funds.

The siblings want to see "hundreds of pages of responsive documents, which Gutnick and SMGG have wrongfully withheld from production under erroneous assertions of privilege,” according to the motion.

Advertisement

The pages are listed in a log of documents withheld from the daughter and son in the discovery phase of the case. The daughter and son argue that attorney-client privilege does not apply, because of the conflicts inherent in Mr. Gutnick’s roles, and because he claims to have relied on advice of counsel in his decisions on the trust fund.

David A. Strassburger, one of the attorneys representing Mr. Gutnick, could not be reached Tuesday morning for comment.

Attorneys William Pietragallo and Peter St. Tienne Wolff, representing Ms. Scaife, intend to formally present their motion to Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Kathleen Durkin on Jan. 4.

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542

First Published: December 26, 2017, 3:40 p.m.
Updated: December 26, 2017, 3:40 p.m.

RELATED
The late Jennie Scaife at an event on Dec. 9, 2015. Her health problems were the subject of court filings that, according to Judge Kathleen Durkin's ruling this week, should not have been filed under seal in violation of an earlier order.
Rich Lord
Judge: Sealed filings in Scaife case were in violation of court-sanctioned pact
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Head coach Mike Tomlin and offensive coordinator Arthur Smith watch a receivers and defensive backs drill at Steelers Minicamp at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex Thursday, June 13, 2024.
1
sports
Gerry Dulac: Next season’s major decisions loom this week for Mike Tomlin, Steelers staff
This image taken from video shows emergency crews responding at Toronto Pearson Airport after a plane crash on Monday.
2
news
At least 8 reported injured after Delta jet flips during landing at Toronto airport
The impacted workers include personnel hired for FAA radar, landing and navigational aid maintenance, one air traffic controller told the Associated Press.
3
news
President Trump begins firings of FAA air traffic control staff just weeks after fatal D.C. plane crash
The Federal Bureau of Investigation seal outside the headquarters in Washington, D.C.
4
opinion
Vanni Cappelli: The FBI purge could lead to another 9/11
Cincinnati Bengals wide receiver Ja'Marr Chase (1) catches a pass from quarterback Jake Browning for a first down with Pittsburgh Steelers cornerback Joey Porter Jr. (24) defending during the second half of an NFL football game in Cincinnati, Sunday, Nov. 26, 2023.
5
sports
Brian Batko's Steelers chat transcript: 02.17.25
This chart of attorney H. Yale Gutnick's roles in late publisher Richard Mellon Scaife's business and personal life was produced and filed in court by attorneys for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife, the deceased's daughter and son.  (Allegheny County Court)
Allegheny County Court
Advertisement
LATEST local
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story