Thursday, March 13, 2025, 5:52AM |  49°
MENU
Advertisement

Penn Hills woman faces stabbing trial

Penn Hills woman faces stabbing trial

A Penn Hills woman was ordered to stand trial on charges that she killed a man after a district judge heard testimony Friday from a witness who at times contradicted statements included in a police affidavit.

Constance Carey, 54, is accused of killing Deontay Hamilton, 34, of Braddock, on May 16 at a home on Pine Way in Braddock.

A key part of Friday’s hearing was the testimony of Thomas Pitts, 27, who was arraigned the day after the stabbing on charges that he sexually assaulted a 4-year-old girl.

Advertisement

Ms. Carey’s attorney, James Sheets, said he intends to argue at trial that Mr. Pitts was not at the house when the stabbing occurred and that he offered his testimony in the killing to get leniency in his case.

But Kevin Abramovitz, who is representing Mr. Pitts, said no one has contacted him to discuss any potential deals for his client, whose case is based upon “next to no evidence.”

A spokesman for the Allegheny County district attorney’s office declined comment.

Friday’s hearing before District Judge Hugh McGough was at times colorful.

Advertisement

Ms. Carey turned around to her relatives in the courtroom and smiled at one point. Other times, she snorted at parts of Mr. Pitts’ testimony, prompting a warning from the judge that she could be removed from the hearing. Mr. Sheets attributed his client’s behavior to anxiety.

Mr. Pitts testified that he knew Ms. Carey for about two months prior to the stabbing. He said he went to the house on Pine Way around midnight, about seven hours before the stabbing, and smoked marijuana and drank two cups of straight vodka.

At some point, he said, Ms. Carey said she didn't like Mr. Hamilton and “she didn't want him around anymore.”

He said Ms. Carey went to the kitchen and he watched from the living room while she tussled with Mr. Hamilton. He said Ms. Carey took a knife off the counter and attacked Mr. Hamilton, thrusting the knife toward Mr. Hamilton's neck.

Mr. Pitts said he left the house and saw Mr. Hamilton stumble outside, a red stain on his shirt.

Mr. Sheets asked Mr. Pitts about information in court documents that indicates he told police Ms. Carey grabbed the knife from a rack. Mr. Pitts said that was an error.

Mr. Sheets also asked about Mr. Pitts’ statements that Ms. Carey swung at Mr. Hamilton's neck, given that the Allegheny County medical examiner's office said Mr. Hamilton died of a single stab wound to the chest. The attorney said he disagreed with statements by the prosecutor and the judge that the two body parts were not far apart and could be confused in such a situation.

In the end, Judge McGough ordered Ms. Carey to stand trial.

It was a bittersweet day for Mr. Hamilton's family. Relatives remembered him as a hard-working family man who spent the day before his death supporting one of his nieces at her school function. Mr. Hamilton is the fifth man in his family to be killed in five years, and his case is the only one in which an arrest has been made, according to his aunt, Joy Renee Burgwin.

First Published: July 31, 2015, 6:19 p.m.
Updated: August 1, 2015, 3:26 a.m.

RELATED
Comments Disabled For This Story
Partners
Advertisement
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin greets New York Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) after an NFL football game, Sunday, Oct. 20, 2024, in Pittsburgh.
1
sports
Gerry Dulac: Steelers have made offer to Aaron Rodgers, but holdup has nothing to do with money
The dome of the U.S. Capitol is seen in December 2024, when the House previously approved a stopgap funding bill to avert a government shutdown.
2
news
Fetterman says he won't back government shutdown as funding deadline looms over Senate
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin talks to quarterback Russell Wilson (3) during an NFL football game, Sunday, Oct. 20, 2024, in Pittsburgh.
3
sports
Joe Starkey: Steelers staging the saddest quarterback derby there ever was
The Social Security Administration Building at 6117 Penn Circle North in East Liberty Wednesday, Jan. 2, 2019 in Pittsburgh.
4
news
Social Security Administration to begin withholding full benefits from overpaid recipients
Keeanu Benton, left, and Cam Heyward work on a defensive line drill at Steelers Minicamp Tuesday, June 11, 2024, at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex on the South Side.
5
sports
With their free agency focus on QB, Steelers missed out on landing a top defensive lineman
Advertisement
LATEST local
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story