Monday, February 17, 2025, 9:57PM |  23°
MENU
Advertisement
This chart of attorney H. Yale Gutnick's roles in late publisher Richard Mellon Scaife's business and personal life was produced and filed in court by attorneys for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife, the deceased's daughter and son.
2
MORE

Scaife fund case mired in disputes

Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas

Scaife fund case mired in disputes

Disputes over tens of thousands of pages of documents and at least one key deposition have bedeviled a three-year-old court fight over the late publisher Richard Mellon Scaife's use of a family trust, attorneys revealed at a three-hour courtroom argument Tuesday.

Attorneys for David Scaife, 51, and Jennie Scaife, 54, contended that a trio of family trustees have withheld documents that could detail their father's plan to spend money that they would otherwise inherit, while preserving assets they would not receive.

Attorney James Mannion, representing David Scaife, accused trustees H. Yale Gutnick, James Walton and PNC Bank of "gamesmanship ... to purposely insulate documents" that could prove the case.

Advertisement

The trustees countered that the late publisher's son and daughter were asking for far too much information, and added that it had proved impossible to get Ms. Scaife to sit for a deposition.

The late Jennie Scaife at an event on Dec. 9, 2015. Her health problems were the subject of court filings that, according to Judge Kathleen Durkin's ruling this week, should not have been filed under seal in violation of an earlier order.
Rich Lord
Judge: Sealed filings in Scaife case were in violation of court-sanctioned pact

The many disputes between the Scaifes and the trustees now rest with Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Kathleen Durkin, who has set a schedule that envisions an end this year to discovery in the case, which could have nine-figure implications.

The disputed trust fund at the center of the case was created in 1935 by Richard Mellon Scaife's mother, Sarah Mellon Scaife. She dedicated it to supporting her son's welfare, with the balance upon his death to go to his children. But with the trustees’ consent, Mr. Scaife steered some $400 million from the fund to the Tribune-Review newspapers, and there was nothing left for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife upon the publisher's 2014 death. The publisher's daughter and son want the trustees to pay them upwards of a hundred million dollars.

Mr. Gutnick's willingness to spend down the trust fund worried fellow trustee PNC, Mr. Mannion said. "PNC was nervous not only about the tax issues, but also that the trustees, quote 'mechanically honored' Mr. Scaife's demands for distributions."

Advertisement

Mr. Mannion alleged "a scheme between Mr. Gutnick and Mr. Scaife to deplete the 1935 Trust," and use its funds to prop up the Tribune-Review, when other funds could have been used instead. He described as a conflict of interest Mr. Gutnick's former roles as trustee for numerous Scaife family funds, estate co-executor, Tribune-Review board chairman and personal lawyer to the publisher.

He showed Judge Durkin a chart outlining Mr. Gutnick's many roles in the Mr. Scaife's business life. "This is Mr. Gutnick, your honor -- Mr. Gutnick at the center of this equation, and what he knew and what he was sharing, or not sharing with the other trustees."

He said that Mr. Gutnick was now using his multiple roles as an excuse to justify withholding some 4,400 pages of documents from Jennie and David Scaife.

James Schadel, one of Mr. Gutnick’s attorneys, said the roles of the late publisher’s confidant "do not conflict." In any case, the trustees had a straightforward duty, he said: "All the trustees had to determine was that the distribution [from the trust fund] was in Mr. Scaife's best interests." He said they fulfilled that duty.

This chart of attorney H. Yale Gutnick's roles in late publisher Richard Mellon Scaife's business and personal life was produced and filed in court by attorneys for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife, the deceased's daughter and son.
Rich Lord
Scaife children claim attorney improperly withholding documents

Jennie and David Scaife are also asking for documents held by PNC Bank related to their father's finances. PNC has identified some 4,750 documents as exempt from discovery.

Deborah Little, one of PNC's attorneys, held up one thick binder, and said, "We do have approximately 20 of these binders, your honor, stuffed approximately four inches thick, double-sided" of documents that may relate to Mr. Scaife's finances, but that don’t have to be disclosed.

Mr. Schadel said he has tried, since mid-2016, to schedule Ms. Scaife's deposition. She cancelled a deposition that was set for her home state of Florida, and later said she could not travel to Pittsburgh, for medical reasons. She later offered to be deposed in Florida in sessions of one or two hours, spread over multiple days, but declined to pay the costs of the attorneys who would have to travel and stay there.

"We are not unwilling to have her testify. She's actually looking forward to it," said William Pietragallo, one of Ms. Scaife's attorneys, after the court argument. "She had a couple of health episodes which she is responding nicely to, but it takes time."

Mr. Gutnick has sought to subpoena detailed financial records of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, and the newspaper has filed a motion to quash that document demand. Attorneys for the Post-Gazette argued Tuesday that the case revolves around the knowledge and states-of-mind of the trustees and of Mr. Scaife, none of which would depend on a rival newspaper's finances.

Attorney David Strassburger, representing Mr. Gutnick, argued that the Post-Gazette's finances could serve as a yardstick against which to measure Mr. Scaife's decisions to continue to fund the Tribune-Review.

Judge Durkin did not say when she expects to rule on the discovery disputes.

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542

First Published: January 23, 2018, 8:28 p.m.
Updated: January 23, 2018, 8:28 p.m.

RELATED
Richard Scaife
Rich Lord
Judge: Scaife children can't collect punitive damages
Rich Lord
Scaife daughter settles for memorabilia
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Head coach Mike Tomlin and offensive coordinator Arthur Smith watch a receivers and defensive backs drill at Steelers Minicamp at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex Thursday, June 13, 2024.
1
sports
Gerry Dulac: Next season’s major decisions loom this week for Mike Tomlin, Steelers staff
This image taken from video shows emergency crews responding at Toronto Pearson Airport after a plane crash on Monday.
2
news
At least 8 injured after Delta plane flips on landing in Toronto
The Federal Bureau of Investigation seal outside the headquarters in Washington, D.C.
3
opinion
Vanni Cappelli: The FBI purge could lead to another 9/11
The impacted workers include personnel hired for FAA radar, landing and navigational aid maintenance, one air traffic controller told the Associated Press.
4
news
President Trump begins firings of FAA air traffic control staff just weeks after fatal D.C. plane crash
5
news
Medicaid on the chopping block: Proposed cuts threaten coverage of vulnerable Pennsylvanians
This chart of attorney H. Yale Gutnick's roles in late publisher Richard Mellon Scaife's business and personal life was produced and filed in court by attorneys for Jennie Scaife and David Scaife, the deceased's daughter and son.  (Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas)
Richard Mellon Scaife
Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas
Advertisement
LATEST local
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story