A Mozart opera peppered with 20th-century harmonies and (intentional) wrong notes? An artist’s satirical condemnation of debauchery in 18th-century London? A funny and entertaining show with a nasty bite, quite unlike anything else in the repertory? Any of these epithets might describe “The Rake’s Progress,” Stravinsky’s only full-length opera, which Pittsburgh Opera is mounting in high style at the Benedum Center this week.
The story of how general director Christopher Hahn purchased the splendid David Hockney production, when San Francisco Opera was about to scrap it, is a saga in itself. The acquisition was a coup for Pittsburgh Opera, making it possible for the company to present its first mainstage production of this unique and wonderful work.
When: 7 p.m. Tuesday; 7:30 p.m. May 6; 2 p.m. May 8.
Where: Benedum Center, Downtown
Tickets: $12.75-$157.75, 412-456-6666 or www.pittsburghopera.org. Footage of an interview between Andy Warhol and David Hockney, who designed this production of “The Rake’s Progress,” will be played in the Benedum Center lobby before each performance.
“The Rake’s Progress” is a product of Stravinsky’s “neoclassical” period, in which the composer assimilated older styles and made them his own. He used an 18th-century orchestra, including harpsichord, with clear divisions between musical numbers and recitative. But he didn’t limit himself to the 18th century. The heroine’s big scene is a Bellinian cavatina ending with a showy fast caballetta, while her lullaby to the dying Tom is cast in the form of a medieval motet. And Stravinsky liked to fool the listener by taking his melodies in unexpected directions, and placing accents on the wrong syllables, creating a topsy-turvy musical world to match the plot.
The libretto, by the great British poet W. H. Auden (with contributions from Auden’s lover, Chester Kallman), is a masterpiece of wit and irony, the plot based on a series of 18th-century engravings by William Hogarth: Tom Rakewell wishes for easy money, makes a pact with the devil (Nick Shadow), and leaves his farm girl sweetheart (Anne Trulove) for a profligate life in the big city. He ends up penniless in a madhouse but is saved from the devil’s clutches by his faithful Anne. It’s all caricature, and Hockney’s arresting sets and costumes carry on the motif of exaggerated simplicity.
But simple, in this case, does not mean easy. The production requires split-second timing and clear verbal projection, while the score demands impeccable ensemble work and singers who can negotiate intricate rhythms and awkward melodic leaps and intervals. On opening night, conductor Antony Walker kept his vocal and instrumental forces together with admirable proficiency, while stage director Roy Rallo elicited dexterous movement from the eager, animated cast.
In the title part, Alek Shrader combined boyish naivete with a callousness that made his eventual plight appropriately inevitable. His smallish tenor, pleasant and well produced, did not, however, project consistently through the theater – often at the expense of the words (and the supertitles were not always in sync). Layla Claire was a spunky and physically beautiful Anne, though her warm soprano tended to turn strident on her top notes, and she seemed uncomfortable with the craggy coloratura of her virtuoso solo turn.
The best singing, and also the most vivid characterizations, came from the two veterans in the cast. David Pittsinger used his resonant bass-baritone sound and seasoned stage skills to his advantage as the slimy Shadow. Jill Grove played Baba the Turk – the bearded lady at a glimpse of whom brave warriors swooned – with relish and braggadocio. She manipulated her voluminous deep mezzo-soprano for comic effect, adjusting her vocal coloration to affect sympathy when giving advice to the disconsolate Anne. In the briefer but still juicy role of Mother Goose, younger mezzo Laurel Semerdjian, a resident artist, sang strongly and played the madam of the brothel with a spirit of fun.
Keith Jameson, whose pungent tenor had more carrying power than Shrader’s, delivered the delightful auctioneer’s scene with gusto and comic flair. Basso Wei Wu showed promise and comfortable stage demeanor as Trulove, Anne’s hapless father.
First Published: May 1, 2016, 8:14 p.m.