Sunday, March 30, 2025, 3:27PM |  69°
MENU
Advertisement
2
MORE

'The Fearless Benjamin Lay': A Pennsylvania Quaker dwarf who was a giant in abolitionism

'The Fearless Benjamin Lay': A Pennsylvania Quaker dwarf who was a giant in abolitionism

Quakers were early opponents of slavery in Pennsylvania and instrumental in establishing the state’s gradual emancipation act of 1780, often described as the first law of its kind in the nation. However, Quakers did not gravitate automatically to the slave’s cause; some were slaveholders who ruthlessly suppressed anti-slavery dissent. In 1730s Philadelphia, one Quaker’s anti-slavery agitation cost him dearly.


"THE FEARLESS BENJAMIN LAY: THE QUAKER DWARF WHO BECAME THE FIRST REVOLUTIONARY ABOLITIONIST"
By Marcus Rediker
Beacon Press ($26.95).

This is the story that Marcus Rediker tells in “The Fearless Benjamin Lay: The Quaker Dwarf Who Became the First Revolutionary Abolitionist.” Mr. Rediker, a history professor at the University of Pittsburgh whose previous books include “The Slave Ship: A Human History” (2007), carefully traces the development of Lay’s anti-slavery sensibilities. Contemptuous of authority, Lay had running battles with Quaker leaders in England, gained an appreciation for cosmopolitanism during a stint as a sailor, and recoiled at the mistreatment of slaves who toiled on the sugar plantations in Barbados. His wife, Sarah, a Quaker minister who lived with him on the Caribbean island from 1718 to 1720, was equally appalled by the barbarism of the plantation owners. Mr. Rediker suggests that Lay’s diminutive stature helped to sensitize him to the plight of the less fortunate.

In 1732, the Lays arrived in Philadelphia, hoping, Mr. Rediker says, “to join William Penn’s ‘Holy Experiment.’” Instead, Lay was sickened to find slave owners among the city’s leading Quakers, some of whom also wielded great political authority in the colony. His ensuing campaign against these “apostates” included attention-grabbing protests and publication of a book in 1738 that outlined the religious, philosophical and other arguments against slavery. Mr. Rediker calls it “the fourth major anti-slavery publication in North America.”

Advertisement

The treatise, printed by Benjamin Franklin and quickly denounced by leading Quakers, contained language so fiery that Mr. Rediker likened Lay to a prophet. Lay was self-educated but well-read — Mr. Rediker gives a painstaking reconstruction of his subject’s “enlightenment” — and his reasoned arguments landed with the sharpness of a blade.

Yet Lay’s entreaties drew scorn, as did the efforts of so many prophets before him, and he suffered the additional indignity of ridicule because of his dwarfism. His religious community shunned him. He lived in a cave, with a few friends and many more books to comfort him.

In more ways than one, Lay was ahead of his time. His demand for immediate emancipation — as opposed to the gradual kind that first took root in Pennsylvania and other Northern states — anticipated the radical abolitionists who arrived on the scene a century later. His religious inspiration, defiance of community elites, uncompromising stance and willingness to endure personal abuse for the cause were other traits Lay shared with the later generation of abolitionist agents, Theodore Dwight Weld and his Band of Seventy chief among them.

Mr. Rediker is not the first historian to note Lay’s work, but he rues that the abolitionist is little known today. He believes Lay’s size and eccentric behavior are partly why history has dismissed him. He also suggests that the working-class Lay, by turns a shepherd, tradesman and sailor, is lost in the common view of abolitionism that focuses on wealthy activists such as the New York merchant Lewis Tappan, a leader in the radical American Antislavery Society founded in 1833.

Advertisement

However, working-class support for anti-slavery is not missing from the historiography. Among other scholars, Edward Magdol documented working-class support for abolition in early-19th-century Massachusetts and New York manufacturing towns, and Leonard L. Richards showed that working-class men were more likely to be abolitionists than members of the mobs that attacked anti-slavery gatherings in New York during the 1830s.

“The Fearless Benjamin Lay” is an important contribution to the history of abolitionism. “I seek in this book to treat Benjamin with the respect he deserves,” Mr. Rediker writes. In that, he succeeds.

Lay, a lover of books, would have appreciated this one, less for the praise lavished on him than the attention given his message. As Mr. Rediker says, “Benjamin’s prophecy speaks to our time.”

Joe Smydo: jsmydo@post-gazette.com or 412-163-1548.

First Published: October 22, 2017, 4:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
John Streicher, professor of neuroscience and pharmacology at the University of Arizona, pipetting samples in his lab.
1
news
Cannabis terpenes shown to prevent pain in new study
Wendle Hopkins, 69, said he was once thrown 40 feet during a mine explosion in McDowell County, W.Va., that left him severely burned and hospitalized for six weeks in 1974. “All I saw was a row of fire and it burns you,” he recalled.
2
business
Deep fear in coal country: DOGE cuts put region's miners and families on edge
FILE - A worker pulls leaves from the flower of a cannabis plant at Greenlight Dispensary, Oct. 31, 2022, in Grandview, Mo. The Biden administration's push to reclassify marijuana as a less dangerous drug won a strong endorsement Wednesday, July 17, 2024, from Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear, who said “the jury is no longer out” on its medical uses as an alternative to opioids that ravaged the Bluegrass State with overdose deaths. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel, File)
3
opinion
Editorial: Recreational marijuana is not the answer to Pa.'s long-term budget woes
A barren Carnegie Mellon University campus on Wednesday, April 15, 2020, in Oakland
4
news
What federal probes could mean for Carnegie Mellon University
Police said Gerhardt Konig, a former UPMC doctor, tried to throw his wife off of a massive cliff in Oahu on Monday, March 24, 2025.
5
news
Harrowing details surface into former UPMC doctor's alleged attempt to kill his wife in Hawaii
Marcus Rediker.  (Curtis Reaves)
Advertisement
LATEST ae
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story