Sunday, February 23, 2025, 10:40AM |  27°
MENU
Advertisement
Fans cheer on the Steelers during their second preseason game Saturday night against the Bills at Acrisure Stadium.
1
MORE

Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag: What’s the best-case (and worst-case) scenario for this team?

Benjamin B. Braun/Post-Gazette

Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag: What’s the best-case (and worst-case) scenario for this team?

Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko, or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL, or anything out of bounds.


Angelo D: With optimism abound in Steelers camp I’m wondering what you think the Steelers’ worst case scenario (W-L) is for the upcoming season? Notwithstanding the impact of injuries/team health and assuming a plausible scenario where Pickett, while better, struggles with inconsistency and bogs down the pass game. The OL while improved, doesn’t have the earth movers to consistently run. Heyward starts showing his age, the revolving door at ILB nets more of the same journeyman type play, and the secondary becomes more patchwork because Porter/Petersen can’t defend the perimeter.

Brian: To be honest, I don’t love doing best-case/worst-case scenarios for a team because I’m a bit of a literalist. The best-case scenario is they go 17-0 and win the Super Bowl. The worst-case scenario is they go 0-17.

Advertisement

But of course I understand the exercise here and the idea behind it. So, I’ll play along. Just don't get mad at me if my answers lean toward both ends of the spectrum being more unrealistic than you may see elsewhere (it would be pretty boring to give them a window between 7 and 12 wins) ...

George Pickens #14 of the Pittsburgh Steelers leaps for a reception over Natrone Brooks #35 of the Atlanta Falcons during the first quarter of a preseason game at Mercedes-Benz Stadium on August 24, 2023 in Atlanta, Georgia.
Gerry Dulac
Steelers dominate preseason finale in dazzling fashion with shutout win

Best case — Steelers go 14-3, nab the No. 1 seed in the AFC, then use homefield advantage at Acrisure Stadium to make the Super Bowl. There, they continue to rely on their formula of an elite run game, the NFL’s best defense and Kenny Pickett’s second-year jump to win their seventh Lombardi Trophy. Joe Burrow wasn't the same after his preseason calf injury, the Chiefs defense was a sieve as Chris Jones sat out the whole season, and the Bills couldn't keep mercurial star wideout Stefon Diggs happy.

Worst case — Everything Angelo mentioned plays out, with Pickett failing to make the leap and being just OK at the helm of the offense. The tackles struggle against top-tier pass rushers and lack of a potent passing game allows teams to stack the box to stop the run. And yeah, the secondary doesn’t hold up as one cornerback is too old, one is too raw and one is too slow. A 3-14 season with wins against the Texans, Cardinals and Seahawks has the city eagerly anticipating when pitchers and catchers report.


Tom in Dallas: Hope you survived Latrobe! Question: How different is it between being a punt returner vs a kick-off returner? I would think there are a majority of similarities: if you decide to catch the ball, you better catch it; if you catch it in the endzone, you decide whether to run it out, and I’m thinking the coaches may have already made that decision for them in advance; and if you catch it, run!

Advertisement

Brian: I did survive Latrobe, but did my car? It ran out of gas the other day. Sure, I drove it around for a while on low fuel, but that’s not uncommon. And I had never not made it to the gas station in time. Fortunately, I was in my driveway. But that was weird.

Anyway, the two return responsibilities are similar, obviously. But kick returners have blockers set up in front of them and almost always set up in the same spot. Punt returners could have their heels in the end zone or in front of the 50, and can thus be much more susceptible to angled or directional punting that puts them in a bind.

Speaking of which, the fair catch is much tougher to gauge on a punt than a kickoff. There’s more of a decision-making component to fielding a punt. On top of that, I would say kick returns are more about pure speed to gain as much ground as possible behind your blockers, while punt returners need to have a bit more shiftiness and vision.


Nate from Fort Wayne: Why was Alex Highsmith not rewarded a sack on Josh Allen on that play where he missed first and then got him later? It wasn't a designed run, was it because Josh Allen crossed the line of scrimmage and then retreated and then got tackled by Highsmith for a 6-yard loss?

Atlanta Falcons running back Godwin Igwebuike is tackled by Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker Elandon Roberts during the first half of a preseason NFL football game Thursday, Aug. 24, 2023, in Atlanta.
Ray Fittipaldo
Who's rising and falling after the Steelers' final preseason game?

Brian: Yes, that is the reason. I did stop Highsmith in the locker room briefly to ask about that, and he confirmed it was because Allen scrambled to the point of crossing the line of scrimmage, which officially made it a rushing play.

But Highsmith smiled and said it’s a sack in his book. I can’t disagree with him there.

More concerning should be Allen’s willingness to run around that much, especially in a meaningless preseason game. Bills fans had to be wiping their brow when Highsmith laid him down rather gently.


Turk in MD: Hi Brian! The Bills were not sharp, but Holcomb's pass break up on Diggs was excellent. Could our ILB play finally improve? What did you see in camp?

Brian: Actually, that was Highsmith again on that play, not Cole Holcomb. That’s an impressive breakup for an edge rusher to make in coverage.

It does have me pondering the possibility of a three-outside linebacker package including some combination of Highsmith, T.J. Watt, Markus Golden and Nick Herbig. That’s particularly intriguing with how well Herbig has played in training camp and preseason, trying to force his way onto the field. You can disguise a lot with really effective pass rushers who also are capable of dropping instead of blitzing.

The Steelers already have a number of chess pieces on defense and various sub-packages to deploy, so there might not even be enough time and practice reps to tinker with something like this. But hey, it’s a long season.


Dave F: Hey Brian, do you think B.Jones will start week 1? I think we throw Dan Moore as a sacrificial lamb vs Nick Bosa, Myles Garrett and Maxx Crosby. After that B.Jones has better technique and will be ready.

Brian: Dan Moore Jr. might be more than a sacrificial lamb, as I wrote about Tuesday. He’s risen to the challenge of keeping Broderick Jones at bay.

Really, if you’re the Steelers, it doesn't necessarily matter how you get above-the-line left-tackle play in 2023, as long as you get it. Now, would it feel a bit like a missed opportunity in the draft if Jones doesn't play right away? Perhaps, but he’ll have ample time to round into someone who helps your offensive line.

Moore starting the season puts the Steelers in a position where they’re playing with house money. If he does his job, that’s great for your offense. Keep developing Jones behind the scenes. If Moore eventually struggles, you can turn to someone who you believed in as the 14th overall pick of the draft. 

Think you have better questions? Email bbatko@post-gazette.com or write him on Twitter @BrianBatko

Go to section

First Published: August 24, 2023, 3:00 p.m.
Updated: August 24, 2023, 9:43 p.m.

RELATED
Pittsburgh Steelers running back Najee Harris runs over Atlanta Falcons linebacker Mike Jones Jr. during the first half of a preseason NFL football game Thursday, Aug. 24, 2023, in Atlanta.
Paul Zeise
Paul Zeise: Steelers offense might more explosive than anyone could have imagined
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin looks on during the first half of an NFL football game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Friday, Aug. 11, 2023, in Tampa, Fla.
Ron Cook
Ron Cook: Should we really be buying this Steelers hype?
Steelers receiver Gunner Olszewski runs the ball while playing the Buffalo Bills during an NFL preseason game at the Acrisure Stadium on Saturday, Aug. 19, 2023, in the North Shore. The Pittsburgh Steelers won 27-15.)
Ray Fittipaldo
With rule changes and cut day looming, Steelers kickoff returners are fighting to remain relevant
Pittsburgh Steelers long snapper Christian Kuntz (46) warms up before an NFL football game, Sunday, Oct. 2, 2022, in Pittsburgh, PA. (AP Photo/Matt Durisko)
Brian Batko
Remembering when Steelers long snapper Christian Kuntz had a sack in the preseason
Should Greedy Williams be a free agent target for the Steelers to shore up their secondary depth?
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
WATCH: Should Greedy Williams be a Steelers free agent target? PSU vs. WVU angst?
Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver George Pickens (14) breaks a tackle from Buffalo Bills cornerback Dane Jackson (30) during an NFL preseason game at the Acrisure Stadium on Saturday, Aug. 19, 2023, in the North Shore.
Gerry Dulac
Gerry Dulac's Steelers chat transcript: 08.23.23
Steelers left tackle Dan Moore Jr. (65) blocks against Cleveland Browns defensive end Myles Garrett (95) last season at Acrisure Stadium.
Brian Batko
How Steelers left tackle Dan Moore Jr. keeps holding on to his starting spot
SHOW COMMENTS (8)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
The University of Pittsburgh's Cathedral of Learning
1
business
Amid funding uncertainty, Pitt pauses doctoral admissions
Pirates outfielder DJ Stewart gets congratulations from teammates after his home run against the Baltimore Orioles in the first game of the Grapefruit League season at Ed Smith Stadium in Sarasota, Fla., on Saturday, Feb. 22, 2025.
2
sports
5 takeaways from Pirates' spring training victory over Orioles
A new report advises retirees in 2025 to aim for just 3.7% when withdrawing from savings -- down from 4%. Over a 30-year retirement, that could mean the difference between financial security or outliving your cash in your 80s or 90s, financial experts say.
3
business
How much can retirees safely withdraw from their nest eggs? Financial experts weigh in.
York County District Attorney Timothy J. Barker reacts during a news conference regarding the shooting at UPMC Memorial Hospital in York, Pa. on Saturday, Feb. 22, 2025.
4
news
Police officer killed, gunman dead in shooting at UPMC Memorial Hospital in York
Preston Coleman, 52, was beaten and strangled inside an Aliquippa VFW on Jan. 5, 2025, in what police described as a vicious, unprovoked attack.
5
news
Bartender working at Aliquippa VFW during beating that left man unconscious facing charges
Fans cheer on the Steelers during their second preseason game Saturday night against the Bills at Acrisure Stadium.  (Benjamin B. Braun/Post-Gazette)
Benjamin B. Braun/Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story