Saturday, February 22, 2025, 12:11AM |  27°
MENU
Advertisement
Steelers linebacker Devin Bush celebrates an interception of Chargers quarterback Philip Rivers in October.
1
MORE

Steelers rookie report cards are in

Peter Diana/Post-Gazette

Steelers rookie report cards are in

All NFL teams rely on some rookies to make immediate impacts. It’s just a matter of how many and to what degree. The economic realities of the business side of the NFL create opportunities for young players on cheaper contracts while older players that command more money become expendable.

All rookie classes aren’t equal. For example, it would be hard to top the Steelers 2017 rookie class. Linebacker T.J. Watt and JuJu Smith-Schuster not only were starters but had star power on a team that finished 13-3 and earned the No. 2 seed in the AFC playoffs.

The top three picks of the 2016 rookie class – though not as dynamic as Watt and Smith-Schuster – all earned starting jobs in their first seasons on a team that advanced to the AFC championship game. Cornerback Artie Burns, safety Sean Davis and defensive tackle Javon Hargrave started all three postseason games against the Dolphins, Chiefs and Patriots.

Advertisement

This year’s rookie class is unique because of the sheer number of players that have taken on roles at various points of the season. It’s not just the top picks such as Devin Bush and Diontae Johnson, either. It’s been a parade of mid-round picks, a rookie tryout quarterback and an undrafted free agent running back that was plucked from another team’s practice squad late in the season.

Steelers wide receiver JuJu Smith-Schuster pulls in a pass against Jets cornerback Maurice Canady in the third quarter Sunday, Dec. 22, 2019, at MetLife Stadium.
Gerry Dulac
Gerry Dulac's Steelers chat transcript: 12.26.19

Of course, depending heavily on rookies is a fairly risky endeavor. Usually, a lighter mix of young and old is preferred. Learning curves are steep in the league, and young players aren’t always the most reliable members of the 53-man roster. Certainly, the Steelers can attest to that after what’s happened the past two weeks.

But it’s also hard to imagine where they would be without the contributions from quarterback Duck Hodges, Benny Snell, Kerrith Whyte and others. It’s safe to say the Steelers probably would have been eliminated from the playoffs long ago if Hodges didn’t save them for a stretch. The same can be said of Snell when he became the feature back for a few games when James Conner was injured and Johnson when he became the offense’s top receiver when Smith-Schuster was injured.

Here are this year’s rookies and their report cards for the 2019 season:

Advertisement

ILB Devin Bush (first round): The Steelers traded up 10 picks in the first round to draft Bush, and he has not disappointed. He enters the regular-season finale against the Ravens second on the team in tackles with 97, only one off the team lead. He also has two interceptions, one forced fumble and four fumble recoveries, one of which was returned for a touchdown. He’s struggled a bit in pass coverage. The coaching staff has alleviated some of those issues by substituting veteran Mark Barron into the game in certain situations down the stretch. In time, Bush is expected to flourish in all areas of the game. But even with a more limited role in the second half of the season, Bush has played 82% of the defensive snaps. He’ll be filling up the stat sheet even more once he masters all facets of the game.

Grade: B+

WR Diontae Johnson (third round): When the Steelers traded Antonio Brown to the Raiders in the spring they received a third-round pick in return. The Steelers used that pick to select Johnson. Brown never played a down with the Raiders while Johnson is among the rookie leaders at his position. Not a bad trade for GM Kevin Colbert. Johnson is second among rookies in receptions with 55, sixth in yards with 626 and tied for seventh in touchdowns with five. And he’s developed into a dangerous punt returner late in the season. He’s had some mental errors and lapses in his play, but that’s expected for rookies. He said last week he’s trying to fight through the the very real rookie wall. His performance against the Cardinals earlier this month – when he returned a punt for a touchdown and had some highlight reel plays as a receiver – suggest he has star potential. When Ben Roethlisberger returns next season, look out. Johnson could break out as one of the top receivers in the entire league.

Grade: B+

Steelers running backs James Conner, right, and Benny Snell practice blocking at training camp in July, 2019.
Brian Batko
Steelers mailbag: How high to draft a running back?

CB Justin Layne (third round): Layne hasn’t taken one defensive snap this season, but he has played in nine games as a contributor on special teams. In fact, late in the season he supplanted Burns, who hasn’t been active for the past several weeks. The Steelers knew when they drafted Layne that he was a project. The hope is he can develop into the top backup at outside corner next season behind starters Joe Haden and Steven Nelson. He has the size and athleticism to excel on the outside, but he still has a long ways to go in his development as a corner.

Grade: C

RB Benny Snell (fourth round): When Conner was injured in the middle of the season it was Snell who emerged and sparked a stagnant running game. After missing three games with a knee injury, Snell returned to the lineup led the Steelers in rushing in three consecutive games. He rushed for 202 yards over those three games, all victories that kept playoff hopes alive when the team was ravaged by injuries. Entering the final game, he has 335 yards on 90 carries. He has to get better as a pass protector. Once he proves himself in that area he’ll see his playing time increase.

Grade: B

TE Zach Gentry (fifth round): Gentry has dressed for just four games this season and has just one catch for four yards. For the third pick of the fifth round (No. 141 overall), it’s fair to expect a bit more. The Steelers drafted Jesse James in the fifth round (No. 160 overall) in the 2015 draft. By the second half of his rookie season, James was a contributor to the offense, compiling eight catches for 56 yards and another 22-yard catch in a playoff game in Denver. The Steelers haven’t shown that type of confidence in Gentry. He doesn’t have the luxury of Roethlisberger throwing the ball to him, but he’ll have much to prove next season. Rookie tight end Foster Moreau of Oakland was selected four picks before Gentry late in the fourth round. Moreau has 21 catches and five touchdowns. The Steelers never saw Gentry as a future starter, but there was hope he could develop into another James. He needs to have a good offseason and be ready to contribute more next season.

Grade: C-

DL Isaiah Buggs (sixth round): Like Layne, Buggs hasn’t seen the field much in his first pro season. He’s logged just 68 snaps and has two tackles. He has dressed for eight of the past nine games, suggesting he’s progressed to the point where he’s become a valued player on the defensive line rotation. He could have a much bigger role next season. With Hargrave likely to sign elsewhere as an unrestricted free agent, Buggs has an opportunity to make a bigger impression in 2020.

Grade: C

LB Ulysees Gilbert III (sixth round): Until a back injury forced him to injured reserve midway through the season, Gilbert carved out a role as a core special-teams player. He flashed playmaking ability on defense during the preseason and forced the Steelers to keep him on the 53-man roster, beating out another linebacker, Sutton Smith, who was selected 32 picks before Gilbert in the sixth round. If he can return to full health the Steelers look like they have a good backup inside linebacker and role player on special teams.

Grade: B-

QB Devlin Hodges (free agent): Duck Mania was running wild for a few weeks, but consecutive losses have highlighted some of the deficiencies in his game. He has thrown six interceptions in the past two games and was pulled in favor of Mason Rudolph against the Jets. He’ll get another start Sunday against the Ravens because Rudolph has a shoulder injury that will prevent him from playing. But even if the Steelers don’t make the playoffs, Hodges will be remembered for leading the team to three consecutive victories in the most unlikely fashion. He was undrafted and unsigned for a week after that. It wasn’t until he impressed at a rookie tryout camp a week after the draft that the Steelers signed him. For a guy who wasn’t even supposed to be in the league, he’s had a heck of a run no matter what happens in Baltimore.

Grade: C

RB Kerrith Whyte (free agent): Signed off the Bears practice squad in Week 12, Whyte has been a contributor for the offense and on special teams. He is averaging 5.8 yards per carry and 20 yards per kickoff return. He’s the change-of-pace back the Steelers were missing in the first half of the season, and he could have a big role against the Ravens this week if Conner doesn’t play.

Grade: B-

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1. 

First Published: December 25, 2019, 5:59 p.m.

RELATED
Steelers running back James Conner picks up yardage against the Jets, Sunday, Dec. 22, 2019, at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, N.J. (Peter Diana/Post-Gazette)
Ray Fittipaldo/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Steelers starters James Conner and Steven Nelson sit out practice with injuries
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger reacts after an offsides call against the Steelers Sunday, December 15, 2019, at Heinz Field Pittsburgh.
Ray Fittipaldo/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Ben Roethlisberger refutes report about his future
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Pittsburgh Penguins fans hold up cards for recently retired Hockey Hall of Fame announcer Mike Lange in a tribute him during a break in the first period of the team's NHL hockey game against the Dallas Stars, Tuesday, Oct. 19, 2021, in Pittsburgh.
1
sports
Mike Sullivan, longtime Penguins players reflect on life and legacy of Mike Lange
An airplane lands at Pittsburgh International Airport Tuesday, Feb. 4,  2025.
2
news
Pittsburgh International Airport can attract more flights with landing fee waivers, airport authority says
Cars drive through snow on Washington Road in Bethel Park Sunday, Feb. 16, 2025.
3
news
Pittsburgh will climb out of an Arctic cold snap and into above-average temperatures soon. Will it last?
President Donald Trump speaks Friday at the Governors Working Session in the State Dining Room of the White House in Washington.
4
news
President Trump spars with Maine's governor at the White House over transgender athletes
People walk through campus at Clarion University on Wednesday, Oct. 27, 2021. Appropriations hearings began this week, with Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education and the Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency taking the spotlight.
5
news
Higher education in Pennsylvania faces declining enrollment and federal uncertainty
Steelers linebacker Devin Bush celebrates an interception of Chargers quarterback Philip Rivers in October.  (Peter Diana/Post-Gazette)
Peter Diana/Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story