Tuesday, February 25, 2025, 7:40AM |  43°
MENU
Advertisement
Jason Bay at the Home Run Derby in 2005.
1
MORE

The Pirates' Home Run Derby history is ... not great

Associated Press

The Pirates' Home Run Derby history is ... not great

It’s fair to say the Pirates don’t have much of a modern reputation for developing fearsome power hitters, but the club has put five players in the various iterations of the Home Run Derby since it debuted in 1985. Before Josh Bell joins them in the club Monday night, here’s a look at how his predecessors have fared. Spoiler alert: It’s mostly disappointing. 

Bobby Bonilla, 1990 — The good news is that he tied for fourth in the eight-player field. The bad news is that he did it with zero homers. He wasn’t alone. Four other players failed to hit even one out of Chicago’s Wrigley Field that year, and the leaders struggled, too. Hometown hero Ryne Sandberg of the Cubs won with just three blasts. Oakland’s Mark McGwire and San Francisco’s Matt Williams tied for second with one apiece. Collectively, they stunk up the show so badly that MLB changed the format the following season. Fortunately for the Pirates, Bonilla’s swings in games were much better. His total of 32 homers that year was the second-best of his 16-year career.

Barry Bonds, 1992 — The derby debut of baseball’s all-time home run leader was less than scintillating. He outperformed Bonilla, but barely. His two taters at San Diego’s Jack Murphy Stadium put him alone in last place in the eight-player field. Mark McGwire, still with the Athletics, won the event with 12 blasts. Seattle’s Ken Griffey Jr. was second with seven, while no one else had more than four. Bonds finished the season with 34 homers before bolting for the Giants after the Pirates’ infamous loss to Atlanta in Game 7 of the 1992 National League championship series. 

Advertisement

Jason Bay, 2005 — It was more than a decade before fans got to see another Pirate in the derby and it was ... not worth the wait. Bay, the NL’s rookie of the year in 2004, became the second player in club history to put up a goose egg when he failed to hit a ball out of Detroit’s Comerica Park. Needless to say, he failed to advance out of the first round.

Pirates first baseman Josh Bell heads back to the batter's box after taking a break during the Home Run Derby Monday, July 8, 2019, at Progressive Field in Cleveland.
Jason Mackey
Josh Bell makes early exit in Home Run Derby

The stadium is notoriously tough on hitters, but the other competitors didn’t struggle nearly as much. Winner Bobby Abreu, of Philadelphia, smacked 41, including 24 in the first round. Three other players hit 15 and all but Texas’ Mark Teixeira hit at least five. Bay did still have a nice season overall with 32 homers. 

Andrew McCutchen, 2012 — He didn’t make it out of the first round, but he was the first Pirate to finish higher than last overall. Hey, it’s progress. 

Advertisement

His four homers at Kansas City’s Kauffman Stadium left him three short of what he needed to advance in a rather pedestrian night for long balls overall. Detroit’s Prince Fielder won the event with 28 total. He was the only guy to get north of 20. McCutchen’s 31 homers in 2012 were a career high.

Pedro Alvarez, 2013 — The Pirates’ best performance in a Derby almost didn’t happen. Alvarez, who was raised in New York, was originally left out of the field for the event at the Mets’ Citi Field. Then Colorado’s Carlos Gonzalez sprained his finger and a slot opened up. In stepped Alvarez, and he was respectable. 

Pirates first baseman Josh Bell is greeted by Felipe Vazquez and former teammates Austin Meadows and Gerrit Cole after finishing with 18 home runs in the Home Run Derby Monday, July 8, 2019, at Progressive Field in Cleveland. (Matt Freed/Post-Gazette)
Nubyjas Wilborn
Jon Schwind has the night of his life at the Home Run Derby

His six homers left him two short of advancing to the second round. Oakland’s Yoenis Céspedes went on to win the event with 32 homers, beating out Washington’s Bryce Harper. Alvarez won in the long run, though. His 36 homers were enough to take the NL’s regular-season crown. 

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.

First Published: July 8, 2019, 11:00 a.m.

RELATED
Pirates closer Felipe Vazquez talks with teammates during batting practice before the Home Run Derby Monday, July 8, 2019, at Progressive Field in Cleveland.
Nubyjas Wilborn
MLB's best explain the challenge of facing Felipe Vazquez
Pirates first baseman Josh Bell gets interviewed before taking part in the Home Run Derby Monday, July 8, 2019, at Progressive Field in Cleveland.
Jason Mackey
What it would mean for Josh Bell to win the Home Run Derby
Pirates first baseman Josh Bell hits a 2-run home run against the Cubs in the second inning Monday, July 1, 2019, at PNC Park.
Jason Mackey
Will Josh Bell sign long term with Pirates? His agent explains
Pirates first baseman Josh Bell takes part in a press conference before the Home Run Derby on Monday at Progressive Field in Cleveland.
Jason Mackey
Josh Bell will be starting in the All-Star Game after all
Pirates first baseman Josh Bell works against the Brewers in the second inning Sunday, July 7, 2019, at PNC Park.
Paul Zeise
Paul Zeise: Josh Bell has chance to arrive as nationally recognized superstar
Pirates first baseman Josh Bell
Mike Persak
Willie Stargell's lessons are reaching Josh Bell — thanks to Kevin Young
Pirates first baseman Josh Bell comes out of the dugout for a curtain call after he hit a two-run home run against the Cubs in the eighth inniing Monday, July 1, 2019, at PNC Park.
Joe Starkey
Joe Starkey: Josh Bell perfect fit as Pirates' new ‘face of the franchise’
A young Josh Bell (right) stands with his father, Earnest, in a  Pirates little league uniform.
Jason Mackey
Star in the making: How Josh Bell's upbringing helped him on path to greatness
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Agents took Rachel Marie Powell, 40, of Sandy Lake, into custody in New Castle on Feb. 4, 2021.
1
news
Pardoned for Jan. 6, 'Pink Hat Lady' came home to a new reality in Western Pa.
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, shown delivering his budget address in early February, said on Monday that a federal freeze of money intended for Pennsylvania is over.
2
news
Gov. Shapiro says federal freeze and blockages of $2.1 billion for Pa. are now over
The Pennsylvania Capitol in Harrisburg, where state Acting Secretary of Education Carrie Rowe on Monday answered budget questions from lawmakers.
3
news
Pa. acting education secretary 'exceptionally concerned' after report on cyber charter school funding
The Downtown Pittsburgh skyline, with the view from Station Square on Thursday, May 30, 2024.
4
news
DHS director says Allegheny County could face reduction in millions of dollars for Medicaid, other services
Law enforcement respond to the scene of a shooting at UPMC Memorial Hospital in York, Pa. on Saturday, Feb. 22, 2025.
5
news
Gunman in UPMC mass shooting battled lifelong mental health issues, says ex-girlfriend
Jason Bay at the Home Run Derby in 2005.  (Associated Press)
Associated Press
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story