Wednesday, February 19, 2025, 9:32PM |  24°
MENU
Advertisement
Pittsburgh Steelers Offensive Coordinator Arthur Smith looks on from the sideline during an NFL football game, Sunday, Oct. 20, 2024, in Pittsburgh.
1
MORE

Joe Starkey: The Arthur Smith honeymoon is over. Now it gets real

AP

Joe Starkey: The Arthur Smith honeymoon is over. Now it gets real

Steelers offensive coordinator is the third-most scrutinized position in town, ahead of anything Pirates- or Penguins-related and right behind Steelers head coach and Steelers quarterback. It beats Steelers defensive coordinator on the scrutiny meter because everybody thinks they can call plays.

And you know what? Anybody could have called a better play than a fade to Cordarrelle Patterson on a two-point conversion attempt in Cleveland.

Arthur Smith loves him some Patterson, and at times this season he has looked right. Not lately, though, and that goes for the entire Smith era, all 11 games of it, at the moment: stretches of brilliance mixed with stretches of mediocrity.

Advertisement

I feel safe in saying the Smitty honeymoon has ended. That doesn’t mean he is doing a bad job. It just means his grace period has expired and that he is facing increased and justified scrutiny after opening AFC North play with two duds.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Jameis Winston (#5) passes under pressure from Pittsburgh Steelers defensive tackle Keeanu Benton (#95) in the second half of an NFL game Thursday, Nov. 21, 2024, in Cleveland.
Ray Fittipaldo
Steelers wary of desperate Bengals, who need a victory Sunday to stay in playoff contention

But here’s the thing: The defining games lay ahead, and if the Steelers are going to have to match points with four of the 10 highest-scoring teams in the NFL (Cincinnati twice, Philadelphia, Kansas City and Baltimore) down the stretch, Smith’s offense needs to be much better than it has been in the Steelers’ toughest games this season.

They beat up the Giants, Jets and Raiders, but in their five games against teams in playoff position (Atlanta, Denver, L.A. Chargers, Washington, Baltimore), the Steelers have averaged just 19.4 points per game. In two of those games, they failed to score a touchdown — and they weren’t exactly The Greatest Show on Turf in Cleveland, either, with just 19 points in a horrible loss.

I’d grade Smith at a B- so far this season, giving him a break because he has been forced to work around some serious offensive line injuries and issues. James Daniels, for example, was off to a spectacular start before he was felled with a season-ending injury.

Advertisement

Smith is an obvious upgrade on Matt Canada — yes, I just redefined the term “damning with faint praise” — but still doesn't have the offense in the top 10 in scoring and has fallen short of some sad Canada benchmarks.

In 2022, which was Canada’s final full season, the Steelers finished 22nd in red-zone touchdown percentage at 52%. Smith’s outfit is eight spots lower, at 45%. That is somehow behind the Patriots and ahead of only the Giants and Cowboys.

In 2022, the Steelers were seventh in the NFL in third-down conversion rate at 45%. This season, they are 15th at 39%.

Smith’s group has also been guilty of some short-yardage malfunctions in the past two games, not the least of which was the ill-advised fade to Patterson. On other occasions, when only a yard is needed, I’m baffled as to why the Steelers don’t go to a full-scale tush push. Line up the 230-pound quarterback, Justin Fields, behind an excellent center in Zach Frazier with Najee Harris maniacally pushing from the back, and get a yard!

Pittsburgh Steelers coach Arthur Smith walks on the field before a game against the Cleveland Browns at the Huntington Bank Field on Thursday, November 21, 2024, in Cleveland, Ohio.
Ray Fittipaldo
Steelers OC Arthur Smith addresses rumors of North Carolina interest

See? Even I can call plays.

It is sensible to have Fields in the game in those situations. What isn’t sensible is to do nothing as the play clock dwindles, and the unit looks rushed, and you fail to call timeout — as was the case on a failed first-half fourth-and-1. Mike Tomlin spent timeouts like a drunken sailor in the second half; he couldn’t use one in that critical situation in the first half?

The run game failed on so many fronts in the past two games, often getting stopped at or behind the line of scrimmage. One of those horrible plays was a red-zone reverse for Patterson (please stop that, Artie).

On the other hand, the Steelers are more explosive under Smith than they ever were under Canada. They are scoring more. They are rolling up more yardage. They are averaging 25.6 points per game since Russell Wilson became the starting quarterback (note to Artie and Tomlin: When the game is on the line and Wilson is hot, let him and not Fields throw the ball on 3rd-and-6). And they lead the league in time of possession.

There is something to be said for that last stat because it keeps the defense fresh, although it should be noted that in Canada’s final full season, the Steelers were sixth in time of possession.

When Tomlin made the critical change at quarterback, his team was 4-2. He rationalized it, according to Jay Glazer, by saying, “I'm not trying to win games; I’m trying to win a world title here.”

I would assume the same rationale applied to bringing in a new coordinator. We’ll see over these next six games, and likely beyond, if Tomlin merely upgraded there or gave himself a real chance against the big boys of the AFC.

Big difference.

First Published: November 27, 2024, 2:54 p.m.
Updated: November 27, 2024, 11:52 p.m.

RELATED
Kyle Hamilton #14 of the Baltimore Ravens tackles Najee Harris #22 of the Pittsburgh Steelers in the second quarter of a game at Acrisure Stadium on November 17, 2024 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Ray Fittipaldo
Analysis: Predictable play-calling a factor in Steelers' lackluster red-zone offense
Pittsburgh Steelers tight end Pat Freiermuth (88) celebrates a first down during the first half of an NFL football game against the Cincinnati Bengals in Cincinnati, Sunday, Nov. 26, 2023.
Adam Bittner
Football betting trends: Recent history suggests Steelers-Bengals total is too high
Dallas Cowboys linebacker Micah Parsons eats a turkey leg as Fox sports personality Erin Andrews looks on after an NFL football game New York Giants in Arlington, Texas, Thursday, Nov. 28, 2024.
Gerry Dulac
Gerry Dulac's 2024 NFL picks: Week 13
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Justin Fields (2) throws the ball during warm-ups before a game against the Cleveland Browns at the Huntington Bank Field on Thursday, Nov. 21, 2024, in Cleveland, Ohio.
Paul Zeise
Paul Zeise Live: Should Steelers keep QBs Russell Wilson, Justin Fields around next season?
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin walks on the field after an NFL football game against the Cleveland Browns, Thursday, Nov. 21, 2024, in Cleveland. The Browns won 24-19.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
WATCH: Pressure on Steelers' Mike Tomlin to solve red-zone issues?
Pittsburgh Steelers running back Cordarrelle Patterson (84) misses a catch in the endzone while playing the Cleveland Browns at the Huntington Bank Field on Thursday, Nov. 21, 2024, in Cleveland, Ohio. The Cleveland Browns won 24-19.
Ray Fittipaldo
Steelers spending extra time identifying, fixing red-zone problems
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin walks on the sideline during an NFL football game against the Cleveland Browns on Thursday, Nov. 21, 2024, in Cleveland. The Browns won 24-19.
Gerry Dulac
Gerry Dulac: Puzzling Steelers have much to prove against 4-7 Bengals this Sunday
Jordan Akins of the Cleveland Browns runs with the ball against Minkah Fitzpatrick of the Pittsburgh Steelers during the fourth quarter in the game at Huntington Bank Field on November 21, 2024 in Cleveland, Ohio.
Gerry Dulac
Gerry Dulac's Steelers chat transcript: 11.27.24
Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker T.J. Watt (90) rushes during an NFL football game against the Cleveland Browns, Thursday, Nov. 21, 2024, in Cleveland, Ohio. The Browns defeated the Steelers 24-19.
Christopher Carter
Steelers film room: What's slowing down T.J. Watt?
SHOW COMMENTS (61)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Gov. Josh Shapiro is joined in the broadcast booth by Curtis Aiken before the start of Pitt-Syracuse on Tuesday night at Petersen Events Center.
1
sports
Gov. Josh Shapiro aims to make Pennsylvania 'compete' in NIL, bring 'stability' to transfer portal
Pittsburgh Steelers defensive tackle Keeanu Benton (95) celebrates an interception against the Cleveland Browns at Acrisure Stadium on Sunday, Dec. 8, 2024, in the Northshore. The Pittsburgh Steelers won 27-14.
2
sports
Gerry Dulac's Steelers chat transcript: 02.19.25
Pirates owner Bob Nutting talks to fans during spring training at the Pirates training facility, Pirate City in Bradenton, Florida, on Tuesday, Feb. 18, 2025.
3
sports
Joe Starkey: Pirates are more culpable than Dodgers in MLB’s payroll disparity farce
Dave Sunday makes points during an appearance in York, Pa.
4
news
Pa. attorney general to address national gathering of conservative activists
Gov. Josh Shapiro has nominated a former Beaver County superintendent to lead the Pennsylvania Department of Education.
5
news
Former Beaver County superintendent tapped by Shapiro to lead Pennsylvania Department of Education
Pittsburgh Steelers Offensive Coordinator Arthur Smith looks on from the sideline during an NFL football game, Sunday, Oct. 20, 2024, in Pittsburgh.  (AP)
AP
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story