Friday, February 21, 2025, 10:16AM |  21°
MENU
Advertisement
Oakland Athletics' Brent Rooker bats during a baseball game against the Pittsburgh Pirates in Pittsburgh on Wednesday, June 7, 2023.
2
MORE

Joe Starkey: Right offer to A’s could help Pirates make playoffs this year and beyond. Do they have the guts?

AP

Joe Starkey: Right offer to A’s could help Pirates make playoffs this year and beyond. Do they have the guts?

Don’t get me wrong. I’m thrilled that the Pirates drafted a bunch of high school students the other day, getting a head start on the post-Paul Skenes era and maybe positioning themselves to upset Avonworth in the WPIAL playoffs next season.

On a related note, I believe the Pirates now lead all of Major League Baseball in shortstop prospects at the lowest levels of the minors. They could have their own shortstop prospect Olympics.

Advertisement

It’s just that I’m slightly more interested in the big league club and what is happening right here, right now.

Pittsburgh Pirates starting pitcher Paul Skenes, center, looks out from the dugout with fellow pitchers Mitch Keller, left, Jared Jones, second from right, and Bailey Falter, in a baseball game against the Chicago Cubs Friday, May 17, 2024, in Chicago.
Noah Hiles
Off the Bat: Looking over the complicated puzzle that is the Pirates starting rotation

Like, whether the Pirates will capitalize on having maybe the greatest young pitcher in baseball history while he’s healthy and how it might only take a few good prospects to help get them where they want to go.

This team is a game-and-a-half out of a playoff spot and built to win a short series or three. But they need a slugger, which means they must be willing to part with a few prospects — and to hear some of the chatter around town, you’d think that somehow translates into asking Pirates executives to part with their own children, not merely a couple of unproven young baseball players after years of hoarding the like.

“They’re not ready,” is what I keep hearing people say about the Pirates. Fact is, they might never be more ready, because we cannot predict the future health of young fireballers. The Pirates have a massive opportunity here.

Advertisement

Better said, it’s a massive responsibility.

They must seize the moment. They need a high-impact hitter, and it might only take one phone call and a few prospects not named Bubba Chandler to get one.

The Oakland A’s reportedly are willing to trade slugger Brent Rooker by the July 30th deadline. Rooker has pounded 51 home runs since the beginning of last season and ranks seventh in the majors in slugging percentage this season with a figure (.573) that would lead the Pirates by nearly 90 points, putting him just behind Bryce Harper and just ahead of Juan Soto.

Rooker’s .942 OPS would top the Pirates by more than 100 points and rank eighth, just behind Gunnar Henderson and just ahead of Christian Yelich. And get this: Rooker is not a rental. He comes cheaply (Bob Nutting’s ears just perked) the rest of this season and has three-and-a-half years of club control remaining.

The Opening Week 2024 logo is seen on the field before the Pittsburgh Pirates' home opener against the Baltimore Orioles at PNC Park on April 5, 2024, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Andrew Destin
Pirates announce 2025 MLB regular season schedule

Why would the A’s trade him, you ask?

Good question. Easy answer: The A’s are rebuilding, and even though Rooker has all that team control remaining, he is 29. The A’s need to get younger. They’d be wise to sell high on Rooker, a late bloomer who has played the equivalent of only two full big-league seasons.

Oakland obviously would want prospects. The Pirates, after five years of abject tanking, obviously have prospects — and the willingness to part with just one of their top five could clinch a deal.

There seems to be this idea, by the way, that the Pirates can only afford one big trade involving prospects in their near future. Just one. And if they don’t get it right, the franchise is doomed for eternity.

Meanwhile, after all the prospect hoarding that has gone on here, there ought to be room enough for several such trades with plenty of good young minor leaguers left over. That’s assuming GM Ben Cherington and his staff have done their jobs (and that might be assuming too much).

Anyway, I keep seeing the Phillies, Reds, Yankees and Braves mentioned in the Rooker sweepstakes, and the prices thrown about are hardly exorbitant.

The Athletic, in a piece co-authored by longtime MLB executive Jim Bowden, suggested an Atlanta-Oakland trade in which the Braves prospect headliners—pitcher Cade Kuehler and center fielder Luis Guanipa—are ranked between 6 and 10 in their system. Another proposed trade I saw had the Reds relinquishing three of their top 13 prospects but none of their top five.

The Pirates could top those offers, even blow them away, without severely damaging their prospect pipeline. I mean, if there is one bidding war the Pirates should win, it’s a prospect bidding war. This isn’t just about helping this year’s team make a playoff push, either. It’s about nudging the window open for a few more years and addressing an organizational crisis.

The Pirates have precisely zero homegrown, high-impact hitters at the major league level. Worse, they have a mind-blowing shortage of promising hitters in the minors, considering they just spent five years collecting prospects the way Tom Brady collected Super Bowl titles.

Fan Graphs has just one of the Pirates' top eight prospects as a position player (Termarr Johnson). There is no enticing Triple-A hitter knocking at the door. Double-A Altoona has played 87 games and has nobody with double-digit home runs.

Rooker would be a dream, though there are some drawbacks. He isn’t exactly Andruw Jones in the outfield, which is why he has been mostly a DH.

What would that mean for Andrew McCutchen? Well, he and Rooker would have to play some outfield, I suppose, with Michael A. Taylor as a ready defensive replacement? I don't know. Those details can be worked out. The Pirates need a bat like this so desperately that Rooker can leave his glove in the car if it comes to that.

The Pirates have multiple options for putting together a winning offer. They could sacrifice Henry Davis — if the A’s are interested — and have several highly rated young pitchers beyond Chandler with the likes of Braxton Ashcraft, Thomas Harrington and Anthony Solometo.

I hear they also might have some young shortstops available.

Joe Star­key: jstar­key@post-ga­zette.com and @jo­e­star­key1 on X. Joe Star­key can be heard on week­days from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan

First Published: July 18, 2024, 1:31 p.m.
Updated: July 19, 2024, 9:37 a.m.

RELATED
Pittsburgh Pirates manager Derek Shelton, left, celebrates with Nick Gonzales after the Pirates defeated the Chicago Cubs in a baseball game in Chicago, Sunday, May 19, 2024.
Joe Starkey
Joe Starkey: Contrary to popular belief, Pirates manager Derek Shelton is doing a decent job
National League's Paul Skenes, left of the Pittsburgh Pirates, greets William Contreras, of the Milwaukee Brewers, after the first inning of the MLB All-Star baseball game, Tuesday, July 16, 2024, in Arlington, Texas.
Jason Mackey
Jason Mackey: Paul Skenes believes the Pirates have ‘a real shot’ to make a push in the second half
Bryce Harper #3 of the Philadelphia Phillies looks on during the 94th MLB All-Star Game presented by Mastercard at Globe Life Field on July 16, 2024 in Arlington, Texas.
Andrew Destin
Former top MLB draft picks Bryce Harper, Adley Rutschman marvel at Paul Skenes’ meteoric rise
Pirates first baseman Rowdy Tellez, center, celebrates his 8th inning grand slam with Bryan Reynolds, right, and Joshua Palacios seal a 14-2 win over the Mets at PNC Park Friday, July 5, 2024.
Noah Hiles
Second-half storylines: 5 questions for the Pirates’ post-All-Star break campaign
Pittsburgh Pirates starting pitcher Bailey Falter, right, walks to the dugout with a team trainer after removing himself in the third inning of a baseball game against the New York Mets in Pittsburgh, Saturday, July 6, 2024.
Noah Hiles and Andrew Destin
Pirates mailbag: What will the starting rotation look like once Bailey Falter returns?
Attendees look on during the MLB baseball draft at the Cowtown Coliseum in Fort Worth, Texas, Sunday, July 14, 2024.
Noah Hiles
3 takeaways from the Pirates’ 2024 MLB draft
In this Sept. 6, 2019, file photo, New York Yankees' Domingo German pitches during the first inning of the team's baseball game against the Boston Red Sox, in Boston.
Noah Hiles
Sources: Domingo German opts out of minor-league contract with Pirates
SHOW COMMENTS (88)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Longtime KDKA-TV host Jon Burnett on May 22, 2019.
1
a&e
Jon Burnett, long a KDKA-TV staple, leaves legacy of ‘putting good out into the world’
The Breezewood Interchange is dotted with gas stations, chain restaurants and souvenir shops. The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission has selected Chicago-based Alfred Benesch and Company to spearhead a major redesign of the notorious roadway.
2
business
So long, Breezewood: Chicago firm selected to redesign infamous Pa. Turnpike interchange
Pennsylvania Secretary of State Al Schmidt testifies Thursday before the Senate Appropriations Committee in the Capitol in Harrisburg.
3
news
Top elections official says Pa. should replace its system for 'early voting'
Police investigate the scene of a double shooting in Pittsburgh's Garfield neighborhood on Thursday, Feb. 20, 2025.
4
news
Suspect at-large after 2 shot and killed, toddler unharmed in car in Garfield
Commerce Secretary nominee Howard Lutnick speaks after President Donald Trump signed an executive order in the Oval Office on Feb. 13.
5
news
Trump expected to take control of USPS, fire postal board, officials say
Oakland Athletics' Brent Rooker bats during a baseball game against the Pittsburgh Pirates in Pittsburgh on Wednesday, June 7, 2023.  (AP)
Oakland Athletics' Brent Rooker bats during a baseball game against the Pittsburgh Pirates in Pittsburgh on Tuesday, June 6, 2023.  (AP)
AP
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story