Friday, February 28, 2025, 3:27PM |  41°
MENU
Advertisement
Tennessee Titans quarterback Will Levis (8) and Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Kenny Pickett, right, meet on the field after an NFL football game Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in Pittsburgh. The Steelers won 20-16.
1
MORE

Joe Starkey: I hate to ask, but is Will Levis better than Kenny Pickett?

AP

Joe Starkey: I hate to ask, but is Will Levis better than Kenny Pickett?

Kenny Pickett won the game. That is not a small thing. He made the biggest throws. He again saved his best for last, dropping a 32-yard dime to Diontae Johnson down the right sideline on the winning drive.

I’m not sure I’ve seen a recipe like his — stink for much of the game, then unbelievably lock in at winning time — since Tim Tebow’s second year in Denver.

But let’s also be honest here. You and I, and I’m guessing millions of others watching “Thursday Night Football,” had a similar thought at some point in the game:

Advertisement

Will Levis is better than Kenny Pickett.

Pittsburgh Steelers offensive tackle Broderick Jones (77) runs onto the field before an NFL football game, Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in Pittsburgh.
Gerry Dulac
Steelers drafted their rookies to be starters, and now it's their time

That doesn’t mean we were accurate. Just honest. Who knows how it all turns out? It was just a thought. Pickett is only a year into his career. Levis is only two games into his.

Thing is, such thoughts have struck me often this season in comparing Pickett to other young players, including C.J. Stroud and even Sam Howell. The 6-foot-4, 230-pound Levis simply had the look of a higher-caliber quarterback, even though his team lost and he finished with a passer rating of 66.4. He made a series of amazing throws in the first half, standing tall under immense pressure, behind a ravaged line.

Think of it this way: If Levis and Pickett suddenly became available to every team that needs a quarterback, how many would choose Pickett?

Advertisement

Any?

Again, I’m not saying those teams would be making the right choice. I’m just being honest.

“This kid (Levis) has an arm,” said studio analyst Tony Gonzalez at halftime, after Levis went 12 of 17 for 153 yards, including several 20-yard-plus completions. “His ability to stand in the pocket has been most impressive. He doesn’t need to set his feet. That is some natural ability that you cannot coach, when you can sit back and throw that ball off your back foot without setting your feet. That’s something that’s going to make this kid very, very good going forward.”

We’ll see about that. Defensive coordinators tend to catch up fast. But I get what Gonzalez was saying. Same with game analyst Kirk Herbstreit, who said of Levis, “I think there are a lot of people around the country watching right now with an eyebrow raised saying, ‘Wow. This kid’s showing something tonight.’”

Pittsburgh Steelers linebackers Elandon Roberts and Kwon Alexander celebrate an interception in the 4th quarter against the Tennessee Titans at the Acrisure Stadium during an NFL game on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023. The Pittsburgh Steelers won 20-16.
Ron Cook
Ron Cook: Steelers cannot keep winning games this way

The second half didn’t go nearly as well. Mike Tomlin improved to 14-1 at home against rookie quarterbacks (Dak Prescott has the only win) and found a way to survive another close game. Levis, the 33rd pick in the draft, did not finish the job. Pickett did, playing through sore ribs that might have accounted for some early throws that nearly sailed to Station Square.

Plus, with embattled offensive coordinator Matt Canada working from the sidelines instead of the press box, the Steelers finally scored a touchdown on their opening drive (at which point I was hoping Al Michaels would dust off his, “Do you believe in miracles?” line).

Pickett is now 12-8 as the starter. He finds ways to win. It truly is astounding how he turns from Clark Kent — or maybe Kent Graham — into Superman. He took the Steelers 92 yards in the fourth quarter, finishing the drive with a touchdown pass to Johnson, at which point Michaels really should have dusted off his line.

Johnson hadn’t crossed the goal line since Terry Hanratty played here.

“I wonder if he remembers how to do a celebration,” Michaels cracked.

Pro Football Focus has a number, going back to the beginning of last season. It’s the highest-rated quarterbacks (by PFF’s system) with the score within 7 in the fourth quarter and overtime, and here are the top three:

• Tom Brady 85.4

• Pickett 85.2

• Patrick Mahomes 84.9

Pickett now is 6-1 in prime-time games. This was his sixth game-winning drive in 20 starts, according to Pro Football Reference. He also finished with a better passer rating than Levis, who threw the game’s only interception and nearly was picked off a few other times in the fourth quarter.

Pickett should have had a touchdown pass earlier, too, except that George Pickens could not get a second foot down in the end zone, despite plenty of room.

I’m not sure what happened to Pickens in this game, by the way. He had two catches for minus-1 yard. His best play was a one-handed catch on the bench on a throwaway by the other team’s quarterback, and he seemed to react to Johnson’s touchdown the way many of us would react if somebody dropped dog poo on our porch.

Anyway, yes, Pickett thrives in those “weighty” late-game situations. He just does. We’ll see how Levis does in those as his career progresses. He already had the kind of game (four touchdown passes last week against Atlanta) we’re all waiting for from Pickett and this offense, and he sure had people talking Thursday night.

To be continued.

Joe Star­key: jstar­key@post-ga­zette.com and Twit­ter @jo­e­star­key1. Joe Star­key can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show week­days from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan

First Published: November 3, 2023, 1:30 p.m.
Updated: November 3, 2023, 8:20 p.m.

RELATED
Tennessee Titans wide receiver Treylon Burks is carted off the field after being injured during the second half of an NFL football game against the Pittsburgh Steelers, Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in Pittsburgh.
Associated Press
Titans' Treylon Burks in concussion protocol after being knocked unconscious, carted off field
Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver George Pickens celebrates a touchdown that was overturned while playing the Tennessee Titans at the Acrisure Stadium during an NFL game on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in the North Shore. The Pittsburgh Steelers won 20-16.
Ron Cook
Ron Cook: Steelers have to hope George Pickens keeps his eye on the prize
Tennessee Titans quarterback Will Levis throws the ball while under pressure by Pittsburgh Steelers defensive tackle Cameron Heyward at the Acrisure Stadium during an NFL game on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in the Northshore. The Pittsburgh Steelers won 20-16.
Ray Fittipaldo
Cam Heyward making up for 'lost time’ after missing 7 weeks with groin injury
Kenny Pickett of the Pittsburgh Steelers and Pittsburgh Steelers offensive coordinator Matt Canada speak on the sidelines in the first half at Acrisure Stadium on November 02, 2023 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Paul Zeise
Paul Zeise: Steelers can continue to win ugly because they protect the football better than anyone else
Tennessee Titans quarterback Will Levis is tackled by Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker T.J. Watt at the Acrisure Stadium during an NFL game on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in the North Shore.
Gene Collier
Gene Collier: Steelers can avoid officials' wrath easily — just play better
Steelers Kenny Pickett and Dan Moore Jr. celebrate a touchdown during the first quarter of the game against the Titans at Acrisure Stadium on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
How long can Kenny Pickett get away with only showing up in 4th quarter?
Steeler Joey Porter Jr wave the Terrrible Towel before the game against the Titans at Acrisure Stadium on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023.
Brian Batko
Inside the 3 major tweaks that preceded Steelers’ win vs. Titans
Steelers wide receiver Diontae Johnson scores the game-winning touchdown against the Titans at Acrisure Stadium on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023.
Gerry Dulac
Matt Canada's sideline debut, Broderick Jones' 1st start at right tackle help Steelers earn tough 'TNF' win
Pittsburgh Steelers offensive coordinator Matt Canada, left, sits with quarterback Kenny Pickett, right, during the first half of an NFL football game against the Tennessee Titans, Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in Pittsburgh.
Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo
So far, so good for Steelers after 1st game with Matt Canada calling plays from the sideline
Pittsburgh Steelers running back Najee Harris runs the ball and is hit by Tennessee Titans linebacker Azeez Al-Shaair at the Acrisure Stadium during an NFL game on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in the Northshore.
Ron Cook
Ron Cook: Najee Harris and Jaylen Warren carried Steelers offense to a pivotal win
Steelers QB Kenny Pickett talks with offensive coordinator Matt Canada during the game against the Titans at Acrisure Stadium on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023.
Ray Fittipaldo
Ray Fittipaldo's Steelers report card: Kenny Pickett does it again in the 4th quarter
Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker Markus Golden (44) celebrates a tackle during an NFL football game, Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in Pittsburgh.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
WATCH: Paul Zeise and Adam Bittner react live to Steelers-Titans
SHOW COMMENTS (180)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Ohio State quarterback Will Howard passes against Notre Dame during first half of the College Football Playoff national championship game Monday, Jan. 20, 2025, in Atlanta.
1
sports
Steelers NFL draft big board: Best fits at quarterback
Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts, center, and teammates run the 'Tush Push' play during an playoff game against the Washington Commanders, Sunday, Jan. 26, 2025, in Philadelphia.
2
sports
Ray Fittipaldo: The Packers are right. The NFL should ban the 'Tush Push'
Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Alex Nedeljkovic takes a timeout during the first period of an NHL hockey game against the Washington Capitals in Pittsburgh, Saturday, Feb. 22, 2025.
3
sports
Penguins rally after Alex Nedeljkovic’s outburst, beat the Flyers in overtime
The 1860s farmhouse at 317 James St. in Verona has a new gray and black color scheme.
4
life
Buying Here: Brooklyn chef snaps up an 1860s farmhouse priced at $230K
Janet Broniecki pushes a cart of bread into a temperature-controlled proofer to let the dough rise before baking. Mancini's  produces 10,000 loaves a day, 7 days a week.
5
life
Iconic Eats: McKees Rocks-based Mancini’s Bakery has been feeding the area since 1926
Tennessee Titans quarterback Will Levis (8) and Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Kenny Pickett, right, meet on the field after an NFL football game Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, in Pittsburgh. The Steelers won 20-16.  (AP)
AP
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story