Monday, February 24, 2025, 11:43PM |  51°
MENU
Advertisement
General manger Ron Francis of the Seattle Kraken and president of hockey operations Jim Rutherford of the Vancouver Canucks speak on the draft floor prior to the start of Round Two of the 2022 Upper Deck NHL Draft at Bell Centre on July 08, 2022 in Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
1
MORE

Jason Mackey: Jim Rutherford has followed a familiar script with Canucks. Is there anything the Penguins can learn?

Getty Images

Jason Mackey: Jim Rutherford has followed a familiar script with Canucks. Is there anything the Penguins can learn?

While Penguins fans endure a second consecutive spring without playoff hockey, a familiar story featuring some Trader Jim guy who used to work here has transpired on the other side of North America.

Yep, ol’ Jim Rutherford, 75 years young, has transformed the Canucks — with just one playoff visit over the previous eight seasons before this one — into legitimate contenders for the Stanley Cup.

Named president of hockey operations and interim general manager on Dec. 9, 2021, four days after former GM Jim Benning was fired, Rutherford has followed a familiar playbook to lead a spectacular turnaround in Vancouver.

Advertisement

The 2019 Hockey Hall of Fame inductee has actually pulled some of the same strings that have characterized his four-plus decades in the game, and there also could be a few lessons for the current Penguins regime.

Pittsburgh Pirates owner Bob Nutting attends pre-game activities before a baseball game between the Pittsburgh Pirates and the St. Louis Cardinals in Pittsburgh on Saturday, June 3, 2023.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
WATCH: When will Pirates' Bob Nutting lose patience with GM Ben Cherington, manager Derek Shelton?

I texted Rutherford to see if he’d be willing to reflect on the past couple of seasons, when the Canucks finished seventh, fifth and sixth before winning the Pacific Division with 109 points in 2023-24.

Rutherford politely declined, explaining he’d rather stay quiet while games were ongoing, which was qualified as a rarity for one of the chattiest GMs in the history of pro sports. But it also doesn’t prevent me from writing what I’ve observed.

Culture change

The Penguins were struggling in December 2015. Former coach Mike Johnston wasn’t reaching any of the team’s star players. The group looked old and slow. Their record after a shootout loss to the Kings on Dec. 11, 2015: 15-10-3.

Advertisement

Swapping Mikes turned out to be a franchise-altering decision, as it resulted in the Penguins rediscovering their identity under Sullivan. The speed, the tenacity, the reliance on young players. It worked then. Resuscitating it now wouldn’t be a bad idea.

It’s been much the same in Vancouver, as Rutherford hired Rick Tocchet on Jan. 22, 2023. The Canucks finished 20-12-4 in 36 games under Tocchet in 2023-24. Now, Tocchet’s direct approach (just like Sullivan), plus the culture created and the respect gained from players has led to arguably the best coaching job in the NHL this season.

Reaching stars

During Rutherford’s Penguins tenure, a primary storyline was bringing out the best in Phil Kessel, which largely happened because of Tocchet. Viewed as a difficult player in Toronto, Kessel was the polar opposite for the Penguins.

You could argue Rutherford hiring Tocchet was the move one of his best players, Brock Boeser, needed to mature. The right winger jumped from 18 goals last season to 40 in 2023-24. His plus/minus went from minus-20 to plus-23.

Penguins defenseman Marcus Pettersson, left, works for the puck in front of Columbus Blue Jackets forward Brendan Gaunce during the second period of an NHL hockey game in Columbus, Ohio, Saturday, March 30, 2024.
Matt Vensel
Contract extension or trade candidate? Marcus Pettersson’s future with Penguins feels uncertain

It sounds simple, but few teams achieve success without their best players being exactly that.

Revamping the defense

It was an ironic storyline from 2014-15, when a Rutherford gamble left the Penguins with only five available defensemen one night. In reality, his Pittsburgh tenure was at least partially defined by improving the team’s back end.

Rutherford added Trevor Daley and Justin Schultz for peanuts. They were huge parts of the two Cup runs. Ron Hainsey was a key deadline addition in 2016-17.

In Vancouver, Rutherford did a few key things. Drafting Quinn Hughes didn’t hurt. Rutherford also pulled off a blockbuster trade to get Filip Hronek, added toughness with Nikita Zadorov and Carson Soucy and brought back another old friend in Ian Cole.

The result was an offensively gifted group that also excelled preventing goals; only four NHL clubs allowed fewer than the Canucks’ 221 during the regular season.

Bold moves

Maybe you’ve heard this before: Rutherford likes to stay active in the trade market. It’s been more than just a funny punchline in Vancouver. While he made his share of trades (and mistakes) in Pittsburgh, Rutherford also did an excellent job of moving on whenever something wasn’t working.

With the Canucks, I think about trading previous caption Bo Horvat to the Islanders, netting the first-round pick that became Hronek. Though he wasn’t responsible for the contract, Rutherford OK’d the most costly buyout in NHL history ($19.3 million) with defenseman Oliver Ekman-Larsson.

Anthony Beauvillier was part of the Horvat trade, the cap space allowing Rutherford to acquire Zadorov. Plus he added Elias Lindholm this year at the deadline.

Rutherford starting with James Neal for Patric Hornqvist set an important tone. The Kessel deal speaks for itself. Even Nick Bonino from his current place of employment. The Pittsburgh comps abound.

Creating an identity

It’s not necessarily the speedy calling card of his Penguins teams, though the Canucks can play fast. But Rutherford, Tocchet and general manager Patrik Allvin (another Penguins transplant) have created a clear identity.

Dakota Joshua (18 goals, 32 points) has helped their bottom-six immensely. Pius Suter was a cheap signing last August who has been a snug fit with Boeser and J.T. Miller (East Palestine). A productive top-six wing on the cheap. Remember those?

Rutherford’s transparency and candor with Canadian media bought time to make changes and mitigate negativity — same as Pittsburgh — while the Canucks have done well to extend deserving players such as Miller, Elias Pettersson and even Boeser (three-year deal).

The conclusion

None of this is to say the current Penguins regime is incompetent. Far from it. I actually think highly of president of hockey operations Kyle Dubas, and I’m eager to see how he repositions the Penguins this offseason.

But if there’s anything to learn from 2015-17, as well as how it came apart, it’s that the Penguins need to rediscover their identity. They certainly need to get more fast and physical, as Rutherford can attest, and those moves are rarely subtle in nature.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and @JMackeyPG.

First Published: May 14, 2024, 2:15 p.m.
Updated: May 15, 2024, 2:13 a.m.

RELATED
Riverhounds midfielder Kenardo Forbes has logged more minutes than anyone in USL history and is the only player in club history with 200 or more appearances.
Jason Mackey
Jason Mackey: Why keep doing this? For Riverhounds’ Kenardo Forbes, the answer is simple
Penguins' Kris Letang talks to reporters on Thursday, April 18, 2024, in the locker room at the UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex in Cranberry during an end-of-season news conference.
Matt Vensel
Kris Letang, 2 other Penguins players have undergone surgery since season ended
Pittsburgh Pirates starting pitcher Paul Skenes delivers during the first inning of his major league debut during a baseball game against the Chicago Cubs in Pittsburgh on Saturday, May 11, 2024.
Jason Mackey
Jason Mackey's sports chat transcript: 05.17.24
Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Alex Nedeljkovic stops a shot in the second period of an NHL hockey game against the Colorado Avalanche Sunday, March 24, 2024, in Denver.
Matt Vensel
Penguins will be well represented at this year's IIHF world championship
Valtteri Puustinen #48 of the Pittsburgh Penguins skates against the New York Islanders at UBS Arena on December 27, 2023 in Elmont, New York.
Matt Vensel
Valtteri Puustinen earns new contract from Penguins after becoming NHL regular this spring
Pittsburgh Penguins new president of hockey operations, Kyle Dubas, center, answers a question during a press conference announcing his new role with the team at the PPG Arena on Thursday, June 1, 2023, in Downtown.
Matt Vensel
Penguins lose their first-round pick after NHL draft lottery
SHOW COMMENTS (11)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, shown delivering his budget address in early February, said on Monday that a federal freeze of money intended for Pennsylvania is over.
1
news
Gov. Shapiro says federal freeze and blockages of $2.1 billion for Pa. are now over
Agents took Rachel Marie Powell, 40, of Sandy Lake, into custody in New Castle on Feb. 4, 2021.
2
news
Pardoned for Jan. 6, 'Pink Hat Lady' came home to a new reality in Western Pa.
The Downtown Pittsburgh skyline, with the view from Station Square on Thursday, May 30, 2024.
3
news
DHS director says Allegheny County could face reduction in millions of dollars for Medicaid, other services
Pittsburgh Steelers cornerback Cory Trice Jr. (27) intercepts a pass during a failed two-point conversion by the Kansas City Chiefs at Acrisure Stadium on Wednesday, Dec. 25, 2024, in the North Shore. The Kansas City Chiefs won 29-10.
4
sports
Brian Batko's Steelers chat transcript: 02.24.25
Pirates first-round pick Konnor Griffin hits against the Twins at LECOM Park in Bradenton, Florida, on Sunday, Feb. 23, 2025.
5
sports
Pirates top pick Konnor Griffin has raised eyebrows at spring training. Next step is learning to be a pro
General manger Ron Francis of the Seattle Kraken and president of hockey operations Jim Rutherford of the Vancouver Canucks speak on the draft floor prior to the start of Round Two of the 2022 Upper Deck NHL Draft at Bell Centre on July 08, 2022 in Montreal, Quebec, Canada.  (Getty Images)
Getty Images
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story