Wednesday, January 15, 2025, 1:18PM |  10°
MENU
Advertisement
With new rules that can limit the use of video in making decisions, another golfer might not have to go through what Lexi Thompson experienced at the ANA Inspiration.
1
MORE

Golf hopes to limit video reviews with new rules

Robert Laberge / Getty Images

Golf hopes to limit video reviews with new rules

In a rapid response to the uproar that ensued after Lexi Thompson lost a major championship because of a television viewer, golf’s two major governing bodies have implemented a new decision to the Rules of Golf that will reduce the use of television replay and go back to relying more on a player’s honor when enforcing penalties for rules violations.

In making the joint announcement, the United States Golf Association and the Royal & Ancient Golf Club of Scotland introduced two interpretative terms that can be used to limit the use of video in making decisions — “reasonable standard of judgment” and “naked eye.” The changes come after two major championships on the LPGA Tour in the past 10 months were decided by television replay.

The most recent came in the ANA Inspiration a month ago when Thompson was penalized four shots for a violation that occurred the previous day and was phoned in by a television viewer. That caused a maelstrom of criticism from players on all tours who decried the ability of a television viewer to cost a player a major championship.

Advertisement

“We’re all responsible for applying rules and calling penalties on ourselves,” said Thomas Pagel, the USGA’s senior director of rules. “But we’ve seen situations where there is no way the player or anyone around the player could be aware of that. When dealing with video evidence, should we be holding players to a high standard simply because they’re on television?”

Thompson had a 15-inch par putt on the 17th hole in the third round when she stooped to mark the ball and replaced the ball about an inch away. A television viewer contacted the LPGA Tour the next day, and officials determined it was a clear violation. Thompson was assessed a two-shot penalty for an incorrect spot and another two shots for signing an incorrect scorecard. She went from a three-shot lead to one shot behind and eventually lost to So Yeon Ryu in a playoff.

The new decision means a player can avoid a penalty if a rules official thinks the player made a “reasonable judgment” in replacing their ball on the putting green or taking a drop.

Last summer, Anna Nordqvist was assessed a two-shot penalty in a playoff at the U.S. Women’s Open when her club nicked a few granules of sand while playing a shot from a fairway bunker. The infraction was not detected until a television showed a super slo-motion replay of the shot. Under the new decision, players can avoid a penalty if the violation could not be detected with the naked eye.

Advertisement

It is the second time this year the USGA and R&A made a rule change that was effective immediately. The other — eliminating a penalty for accidental movement of the ball — came as a result of the penalty handed to Dustin Johnson in the final round of the 2016 U.S. Open at Oakmont.

The intent of the new decision is to make sure players who are on television more are not held to a different, if not higher, standard than other players in the tournament.

Top officials had discussed these new standards over the past five years at a rules modernization project. The new set of rules, once it goes through a public comment period, is to take effect in 2019. The USGA and R&A decided not to wait.

Under the new decision, players should not be held to the “degree of precision” that video technology can provide. The rules committee would consider such things as the players’ actions, their explanation and the amount of the discrepancy relative to the drop.

Thompson, who did not speak to reporters after the final round, said in a Golf Channel interview: “I did not mean that at all. I did not realize I did that.”

Two issues the USGA and R&A did not tackle was whether to allow television viewers to call in violations, and whether to add penalty shots for what becomes an incorrect scorecard. That still could be coming.

Golf officials typically care less about the source of information and more about whether a rule was broken and if a penalty should be assessed. Pagel said the new decision on video evidence will minimize the impact viewers have on a competition.

“The moments where you say, ‘Wow, a player is penalized for that?’ Those situations go away. The controversies go away,” he said. “And we think that’s good news.”

The working group also will consider whether to change the centuries-old belief that a scorecard is sacred. The USGA and R&A last year altered the scorecard rule so that players who unknowingly violated a rule that affects their score are docked two shots for an incorrect card. Previously, they were disqualified.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

First Published: April 26, 2017, 4:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Pittsburgh Penguins' Evgeni Malkin (71) celebrates in front of Florida Panthers' Aleksander Barkov (16) after scoring during the first period of an NHL hockey game, Tuesday, Dec. 3, 2024, in Pittsburgh.
1
news
Evgeni Malkin's Stanley Cup rings missing after Penguins star's home burglarized
George Pickens of the Pittsburgh Steelers looks on during a game against the Cincinnati Bengals at Acrisure Stadium on January 04, 2025, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
2
sports
Jason Mackey: Timing is everything with how Steelers handle George Pickens
Russell Wilson, front, and quarterback Justin Fields work out before the Steelers' NFL football game against the Dallas Cowboys, Sunday, Oct. 6, 2024, in Pittsburgh.
3
sports
Mike Tomlin undecided on Steelers starting QB for 2025 season
An aerial view of the neighborhood of Mt. Washington with the Pittsburgh city skyline in the background photographed on Wednesday, Oct. 6, 2021.
4
business
‘What’s the hurry?’: Developers urge city council to be more deliberate in tackling affordable housing
Wegmans Food Market, one of the country’s most popular groceries, is moving into the Pittsburgh region. The Rochester, N.Y.-based chain announced Monday that it plans to open a 115,000-square-foot store in Cranberry.
5
business
Shopping for more? Wegmans Cranberry store might not be its only one in region
With new rules that can limit the use of video in making decisions, another golfer might not have to go through what Lexi Thompson experienced at the ANA Inspiration.  (Robert Laberge / Getty Images)
Robert Laberge / Getty Images
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story