Sunday, March 30, 2025, 10:01PM |  64°
MENU
Advertisement
Pitt defensive back Paris Ford, middle, and linebacker Elijah Zeise congratulate defensive back Therran Coleman after he intercepted a ball intended for Syracuse wide receiver Nykeim Johnson to win the game in overtime last week at Heinz Field.
1
MORE

Underdog mentality doesn't sit well with Pitt vs. No. 5 Notre Dame

Matt Freed/Post-Gazette

Underdog mentality doesn't sit well with Pitt vs. No. 5 Notre Dame

It was such a good line that it was hard to believe Pitt center Jimmy Morrissey came up with it on the spot.

“I don’t want to be known as a giant-killer,” Morrissey said when asked about facing No. 5 Notre Dame on the road Saturday afternoon. “I want to be known as a giant.”

One of those quotes that will end up in Pitt football lore, maybe even find its way onto a T-shirt, if the Panthers can stun the Fighting Irish this weekend and avoid snapping their streak of two consecutive seasons with a victory against a Top 5 team.

Advertisement

That uncanny tendency, more than anything, makes this matchup worth chattering about. The story isn’t whether Pitt can handle the mystique of Notre Dame football in South Bend. If the Irish roll, it will be because they’re the better team, not because the Panthers got spooked by “Touchdown Jesus” or the “Rudy” factor. But don’t just take it from the players.

Darrin Hall carries against Saturday afternoon against Notre Dame at Notre Dame Stadium. Pitt led the No. 5 Fighting Irish, 7-6, at halftime.
Brian Batko
Pitt falls to unbeaten Notre Dame 19-14

“Pitt has been in this situation multiple times — where Notre Dame has had a good season going, the Panthers have come to South Bend and made it a good game,” said veteran sportscaster Mike Tirico, now in his second season doing Notre Dame play-by-play on NBC. “I wouldn’t expect anything less from them.” 

It’s a safe bet that Tirico will set the scene on the broadcast when it comes to Pitt’s history with one of college football’s biggest brands. Nine of the past 11 meetings decided by single digits, two of the past three at Notre Dame Stadium needing overtime, and a 2-2 split in the past four matchups in South Bend.

Both of those Pitt wins won’t soon be forgotten by its fans, regardless of the Notre Dame connection. When your starting quarterback drops a postgame curse word on live TV — “I’m so proud of this [expletive] football team,” Tyler Palko bellowed — and you pull out a road victory in four overtimes, it almost doesn’t matter who you beat for those memories.

Advertisement

It might just be a bonus when it’s Notre Dame.

“Yeah, it’s cool to go into Notre Dame,” said Morrissey, who was shown the Palko video by former teammate Adam Bisnowaty and called it “pretty funny.” “I’ve never been there before, never really grew up being a fan, but it’ll be cool. It’s a historical college football place.”

Kenny Pickett, however, did grow up an Irish fan, passed down from his grandfather to his dad to him. Before he became Pitt’s starting quarterback, Pickett wanted to be Brady Quinn, but those rooting interests are “put on hold” for his family, at least for the time he’s a Panther.

Pickett has already been there, done that, when it comes to shocking a Top 5 opponent, and did it in his first career start last season against No. 2 Miami. Pitt might’ve earned the “giant-slayer” label by ending that perfect season, 54 weeks after doing the same thing to eventual national champion Clemson, even if it’s not something on Morrissey’s radar.

Notre Dame head coach Brian Kelly, right, talks with Pitt head coach Pat Narduzzi after Saturday's game at Notre Dame Stadium. Kelly's team won, 19-14.
Brian Batko
Pat Narduzzi explains baffling fake punt in Pitt's loss at Notre Dame

“I think what Jimmy’s saying is that you don’t view anyone as a giant,” said tailback Qadree Ollison. “Especially in the game of football, you respect all and fear none.”

The Panthers respected their previous opportunities this season against highly ranked foes but got blown away by No. 8 Penn State and No. 10 Central Florida. Both were No. 13 at the time, and very unlucky draws for Pitt.

But coach Pat Narduzzi has found a way to rally his troops when it was least expected the past two seasons. Junior safety Damar Hamlin — who was recruited heavily by Notre Dame and played with Irish nose guard Kurt Hinish at Central Catholic High School — acknowledged that Narduzzi “definitely gets us going” from a motivational standpoint, but that the key to those past upsets is more than that.

“Coach Duzz is a guru,” Hamlin said. “He definitely knows what he’s doing. He reads offenses so well. Coach Duzz can do anything. Under him, we can do anything.”

The big picture for this game is juicy enough, but the subplots are there, too. Hinish is one of three Western Pennsylvania natives playing for coach Brian Kelly, with Monroeville’s Robert Hainsey a sophomore starter at right tackle, by way of IMG Academy in Bradenton, Fla. The backup to Hainsey, who spent his first two seasons at Gateway High School, is North Allegheny graduate Josh Lugg. Former Pine-Richland star Phil Jurkovec is a freshman quarterback behind starter Ian Book, while another Central Catholic alumnus, linebacker David Adams, left the program in the offseason due to injuries.

On the Pitt side, defensive tackle Amir Watts will have about a dozen friends and family members in attendance from his native Chicago, just 100 miles away. Kicker Alex Kessman grew up in Clarkston, Mich., cheering for the Michigan Wolverines and attended their 2011 game against Notre Dame, the first in prime time at Michigan Stadium.

Last time first-year defensive coordinator Randy Bates was in South Bend, he was linebackers coach for Northwestern in a 43-40 overtime upset of the Irish. Last time Pitt was there, the Panthers nearly spoiled No. 3 Notre Dame’s unbeaten season, but blew a 20-6 fourth-quarter lead to fall, 29-26, in three overtimes. Those overtimes followed a shaky fourth-down pass interference call on Pitt that extended a fourth-quarter Notre Dame touchdown drive, and included a missed Pitt field goal that should’ve been an Irish penalty. These Panthers aren’t returning looking for any could’ve, would’ve, should’ve-been moral victories.

“If that’s your mindset, you’re already beat,” Pickett said. “That’s a terrible mind set to have going into a game, trying not to get blown out. We’re going in to win every game we have, no matter what the team is or what the situation is. If that’s our mindset, we’re screwed. So we’re going in to win. That’s all I know, and that’s what I’ve felt all week. That’s what we feel every week we prepare.”

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.


Matchup: Pitt Panthers (3-3) vs. No. 5 Notre Dame Fighting Irish (6-0), Notre Dame Stadium, Notre Dame, Ind.

When: 2:41 p.m., Saturday.

TV, Radio: WPXI; KDKA-FM (93.7), Sirius Channel 205, XM Channel 385.

DYK? Tony Dorsett’s 303 rushing yards in Pitt’s 34-20 win upset of Notre Dame in 1975 remain the most all-time by a player against the Irish.

First Published: October 12, 2018, 3:04 p.m.

RELATED
Pitt cornerback Jason Pinnock runs to a drill during practice Monday, Aug. 6, 2018 at UPMC Rooney Sports Complex.
Brian Batko
Pitt-Notre Dame key matchup: Fighting Irish's big receivers will test Panthers secondary
Pitt kicker Conor Lee celebrates with teammates after kicking the game-winning field goal against Notre Dame, Nov. 1 2008, in South Bend, Ind.
Adam Bittner
Remember that wild Pitt-Notre Dame game from 2008?
Pitt defensive back Therran Coleman directs the band after he intercepted a ball intended for Syracuse wide receiver Nykeim Johnson to win the game in overtime Saturday.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Brian Batko's Pitt football chat transcript: 10.10.18
Quintin Wirginis speaks after being announced as one of three team captains during the Pitt football annual kickoff luncheon Aug. 24 at Heinz Field.
Brian Batko
Quintin Wirginis, Pitt football captain, out for the season after knee injury
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Wendle Hopkins, 69, said he was once thrown 40 feet during a mine explosion in McDowell County, W.Va., that left him severely burned and hospitalized for six weeks in 1974. “All I saw was a row of fire and it burns you,” he recalled.
1
business
Deep fear in coal country: DOGE cuts put region's miners and families on edge
John Streicher, professor of neuroscience and pharmacology at the University of Arizona, pipetting samples in his lab.
2
news
Cannabis terpenes shown to prevent pain in new study
MIAMI, FLORIDA - MARCH 30: Andrew Heaney #45 of the Pittsburgh Pirates pitches in the first inning against the Miami Marlins at loanDepot park on March 30, 2025 in Miami, Florida. (Photo by Leonardo Fernandez/Getty Images)
3
sports
Instant analysis: Pirates' David Bednar stumbles again, allowing Marlins to win on a wild pitch
Police said Gerhardt Konig, a former UPMC doctor, tried to throw his wife off of a massive cliff in Oahu on Monday, March 24, 2025.
4
news
Harrowing details surface into former UPMC doctor's alleged attempt to kill his wife in Hawaii
FILE - A worker pulls leaves from the flower of a cannabis plant at Greenlight Dispensary, Oct. 31, 2022, in Grandview, Mo. The Biden administration's push to reclassify marijuana as a less dangerous drug won a strong endorsement Wednesday, July 17, 2024, from Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear, who said “the jury is no longer out” on its medical uses as an alternative to opioids that ravaged the Bluegrass State with overdose deaths. (AP Photo/Charlie Riedel, File)
5
opinion
Editorial: Recreational marijuana is not the answer to Pa.'s long-term budget woes
Pitt defensive back Paris Ford, middle, and linebacker Elijah Zeise congratulate defensive back Therran Coleman after he intercepted a ball intended for Syracuse wide receiver Nykeim Johnson to win the game in overtime last week at Heinz Field.  (Matt Freed/Post-Gazette)
Matt Freed/Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST sports
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story