Wednesday, February 12, 2025, 10:37AM |  31°
MENU
Advertisement
Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman, R-Indiana.
1
MORE

Editorial: Return some of Pennsylvania's surplus to the people — but not too much

Alicia Chiang/ Post-Gazette

Editorial: Return some of Pennsylvania's surplus to the people — but not too much

A bid by Penn­syl­va­nia Senate Re­pub­li­cans — with the sup­port of sev­eral of their Demo­cratic col­leagues — to cut the state’s earned in­come and elec­tric­ity taxes is cer­tainly tan­ta­liz­ing: Tax cuts in the Key­stone State are few and far be­tween.

But they also un­der­cut Re­pub­li­cans’ own ar­gu­ments, which are largely sound, about the im­por­tance of fis­cal re­spon­si­bil­ity, even as Penn­syl­va­nia sits on record re­serves. The state’s fi­nan­cial sta­bil­ity — much like Pitts­burgh’s — is more frag­ile than it ap­pears. Per­ma­nently cut­ting rev­e­nues by $3 bil­lion would de­plete the sur­pluses Penn­syl­va­nia has ac­cu­mu­lated, al­most en­tirely due to the fed­eral pan­demic stim­u­lus wind­fall, in only about three years.

The pro­posal is the mir­ror im­age of Gov. Josh Sha­piro’s pro­posed 2024-2025 bud­get, which would spend $3 bil­lion more than the com­mon­wealth ex­pects to bring in.

Advertisement

It sets up a clas­sic de­bate: Should the state re­turn $3 bil­lion to the peo­ple in the form of tax cuts or in the form of spend­ing on gov­ern­ment ser­vices?

Either way, it’s too much. Mak­ing per­ma­nent $3 bil­lion an­nual com­mit­ments, whether in tax cuts or in spend­ing, will quickly draw down the state’s his­toric re­serves. That will leav­e a deep­ened struc­tural def­i­cit that a fu­ture gov­er­nor or leg­is­la­ture will have to rem­edy.

The pru­dent ap­proach would be to drain less of the re­serves — say, un­der $2 bil­lion — and to split that be­tween new spend­ing and mod­est tax breaks.

The tax cuts passed the Senate, 36 to 14, in early May. They would cut Penn­syl­va­nia’s in­come tax by 9%, bring­ing it down from 3.07% to 2.8%. They would also elim­i­nate the gross re­ceipts tax as ap­plied to elec­tric­ity com­pa­nies — 5.9% on all funds com­ing into the firm — and re­quire that the sav­ings be passed on en­tirely to cus­tom­ers.

Advertisement

With a me­dian in­come of about $73,000, the in­come tax cut would save the av­er­age Penn­syl­va­nia house­hold about $200 per year. While es­ti­mates of av­er­age elec­tric­ity bills vary, get­ting rid of the gross re­ceipts tax would prob­a­bly save the av­er­age house­hold an­other $100 or so.

A fair com­pro­mise that would keep the best of the GOP pro­posal, while pre­serv­ing the state’s fis­cal sta­bil­ity and the pos­si­bil­ity for more spend­ing, would be to keep the in­come tax at 3.07% — or, at most, cut it to an even 3% — but ditch the gross re­ceipts tax.

Gross re­ceipts taxes, which tax all rev­e­nues re­gard­less of source, are no­to­ri­ously in­ef­fi­cient and pu­ni­tive. As ap­plied to util­i­ties, they are deeply re­gres­sive — even more than the state’s flat in­come tax — be­cause poorer house­holds pay a greater pro­por­tion of their in­come for elec­tric­ity. While an in­come tax cut would be scaled based on in­come, end­ing the gross re­ceipts tax would be felt more equally by ev­ery­one.

It’s good pol­i­tics and good pol­icy to re­turn some of Penn­syl­va­nia’s wind­fall to the peo­ple. But it must be done right, or else fu­ture Penn­syl­va­nians will have to pay for it.

First Published: June 10, 2024, 9:30 a.m.
Updated: June 10, 2024, 1:15 p.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (75)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Pittsburgh Steelers owner Art Rooney II walks around the field before an NFL football game between the Denver Broncos and the Pittsburgh Steelers, Sunday, Sept. 15, 2024, in Denver.
1
sports
‘Trade Tomlin or sell the team’: Billboard put up in Pittsburgh targeting Steelers ownership
Malphine Fogel, 95, talks to the Post-Gazette about her son, Marc Fogel, who was detained in a Russian prison for more than three years and is now on his way home on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025, in Butler.
2
news
With wedding soup and lasagna, Marc Fogel's mother prepares for his homecoming
3
news
Retired Pittsburgh police officer accused of shooting teen boy in the leg
Toronto Blue Jays' Spencer Horwitz, right, walks to the dugout after striking out as Texas Rangers' Jonah Heim celebrates the team's win in a baseball game in Arlington, Texas, Wednesday, Sept. 18, 2024. (AP Photo/Tony Gutierrez)
4
sports
Source: Pirates first baseman Spencer Horwitz to miss start of spring training
President Donald Trump greets Marc Fogel at on the South Lawn at the White House, Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025, in Washington.
5
news
Feeling like the 'luckiest man on Earth,' Marc Fogel returns to U.S. after more than 3 years in Russian custody
Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman, R-Indiana.  (Alicia Chiang/ Post-Gazette)
Alicia Chiang/ Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST opinion
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story