Wednesday, February 19, 2025, 2:26PM |  15°
MENU
Advertisement
PLEASE WITHHOLD MY BYLINE/CREDIT.) For Local. The Rev. Richard Freeman, president of the Pennsylvania Interfaith Impact Network, leads about two dozen other people in prayer outside the Allegheny County Courthouse during an interfaith service in response to the 16 deaths since March 2020 at the Allegheny County Jail Thursday, Sept. 1, 2022, in Downtown. Hosted by the Pennsylvania Interfaith Impact Network, the prayer service honored the victims and their families and called for change at the Allegheny County Jail. (Nate Guidry/Post-Gazette)
1
MORE

Editorial: Public autopsy reports will make Allegheny County more transparent and just

Post-Gazette

Editorial: Public autopsy reports will make Allegheny County more transparent and just

The Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court has ruled in favor of Pittsburgh Institute for Nonprofit Journalism director Brittany Hailer, who has long sought to liberate Allegheny County’s autopsy reports so the media and the public can hold public agencies accountable. This is a victory for transparency and for justice, especially for people who die in the custody of police or the county jail.

Ms. Hailer began this legal battle in December 2020 when she filed a Right-to-Know (RTK) request for the autopsy report for Daniel Pastorek, 63, who died in the custody of the Allegheny County Jail. The county rejected this request on the grounds that autopsy records, except for the name of the deceased and the cause and manner of death, are specifically exempted from the state’s RTK law.

However, the state’s Coroner’s Code directs county medical examiners to produce all autopsy records when they are requested and a fee is paid. Allegheny County had relied on ambiguous language in the code for first- and second-class counties to withhold these records, but the Commonwealth Court rightly determined that it is “absurd” that autopsy reports would be public records in every county except the two most populous, Allegheny and Philadelphia.

Advertisement

The decision means that any citizen or member of the media can receive a full autopsy report for $500, a toxicology report for $100 and other documents for other fees. More importantly, it means that the public can scrutinize the details of medical examiners’ records, which is essential because the cause and manner of death are technical determinations that, on their own, can be misleading.

For instance, in the case of Jim Rogers — who died after an interaction with Pittsburgh Police in Bloomfield in October 2021 — the Allegheny County Medical Examiner reported that he died of “acute global hypoxic ischemic injury of the brain.” That means that his brain was deprived of oxygen, probably due to cardiac arrest, but it says nothing about what might have contributed to the cardiac arrest. Given the trauma he had just experienced at the hands of Pittsburgh Police, who tased him several times, it is logical to assume this violence played a role. But the bare-bones information released by the county leaves it to assumption and speculation.

Further, the examiner’s determination that Mr. Rogers’ death was “accidental” doesn’t much help. In most states, examiners choose from five possible manners of death: natural, accidental, homicide, suicide and undetermined. National guidelines indicate the “accidental” only means there is no or little evidence of intent to cause death. But a person, and especially a law enforcement officer acting with the imprimatur of the state, can still be morally and legally liable, whether due to negligence or malice, for an officially “accidental” death.

This ruling should open a new era of investigation into deaths in police and correctional custody in Allegheny County — both those that have already happened and those, unfortunately, still to come. As the city continues to wait for a decision on criminal charges for the officers in the Jim Rogers case, Ms. Hailer’s victory gives others a better chance for justice.

Advertisement

First Published: July 14, 2023, 9:30 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (1)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
President Donald Trump listens as Elon Musk speaks in the Oval Office at the White House, Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025, in Washington. (Photo/Alex Brandon)
1
news
McCormick on board with Trump, DOGE shakeup while Fetterman blasts ‘chaos, confusion’
Mt. Lebanon's Kim Seaver (back row, right) was a member of the Post-Gazette Fabulous 5 girls basketball all-star team in 1996. Other players are (from front left) Monessen's Gina Naccarato, Penn Hills' LynnDee Howell, McKeesport's Swin Cash and (front right) Mount Pleasant's Michelle Katkowski.
2
sports
Mike White's Prep Talk: Basketball stars of yesteryear have sons and daughters in WPIAL quarterfinals
Gov. Josh Shapiro is joined in the broadcast booth by Curtis Aiken before the start of Pitt-Syracuse on Tuesday night at Petersen Events Center.
3
sports
Gov. Josh Shapiro aims to make Pennsylvania 'compete' in NIL, bring 'stability' to transfer portal
The WPIAL basketball playoffs are underway.
4
sports
WPIAL boys basketball playoffs: Down go the Highlanders, all the way out of PIAA playoffs
Former detainee Marc Fogel stands with a U.S. flag around his neck as he is welcomed to the White House after he was freed from Russia in Washington, DC, on February 11, 2025. Fogel, a US teacher detained in Russia since 2021 on drugs charges, was released February 11 after an "exchange" with Moscow, the White House. Trump said he hoped Fogel's release could mark the start of fresh ties with Moscow to end the Ukraine war.
5
news
Marc Fogel returns to Pittsburgh after release from Russian custody and medical evaluation
PLEASE WITHHOLD MY BYLINE/CREDIT.) For Local. The Rev. Richard Freeman, president of the Pennsylvania Interfaith Impact Network, leads about two dozen other people in prayer outside the Allegheny County Courthouse during an interfaith service in response to the 16 deaths since March 2020 at the Allegheny County Jail Thursday, Sept. 1, 2022, in Downtown. Hosted by the Pennsylvania Interfaith Impact Network, the prayer service honored the victims and their families and called for change at the Allegheny County Jail. (Nate Guidry/Post-Gazette)  (Post-Gazette)
Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST opinion
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story