Sunday, February 23, 2025, 9:26AM |  27°
MENU
Advertisement
Pennsylvania Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine provides an update on the coronavirus as Gov. Tom Wolf listens in March in Harrisburg.
1
MORE

A blow against tyranny

Joe Hermitt/The Patriot-News via AP

A blow against tyranny

The road to hell is paved with good intentions.

While the loss of life due to COVID-19 should not be minimized, life has been hellish indeed for many thanks to Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf’s lockdown orders.

Now, a federal judge has declared some of Mr. Wolf and Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine’s mandates unconstitutional, striking a fierce first blow against what many have deemed to be a government power grab.

Advertisement

Three cheers for checks and balances, even during a pandemic.

In a measured opinion, U.S. District Judge William Stickman IV declared restrictions on gathering sizes, business closures and the stay-at-home order to have been unlawful infringements under the First and 14th amendments .

He’s right to acknowledge that state officials were acting in good faith to protect the public and that this isn’t the first time the government has infringed upon individual liberties during an emergency.

However, the indefinite length of the restrictions and lack of an exit strategy are critical factors: “It is now September and the record makes clear that Defendants have no anticipated end-date to their emergency interventions,” Mr. Stickman wrote.

Advertisement

Put another way, what began as a way to protect citizens has evolved into an inconsistent application of penalties and punishments.

Of course this is unconstitutional.

The double standard between political protests and other outdoor gatherings, the cover-up of a deal that allowed a car show in Carlisle to host up to 20,000 attendees, and the logical quandary of limiting some events by building capacity and others by absolute number were capricious moves at best, politically expedient at worst.

The business closures were similarly fickle, as Mr. Wolf’s team never defined what made some businesses “life-sustaining” while forcing others to close. Many such businesses in fact sold the same products or services as others that remained open. How is this justifiable?

Finally, the stay-at-home order — it was not a quarantine, which would have applied to infected populations, not the public at large — has not been lifted even now, only mitigated. The state can reinstitute that order at any time.

Mr. Wolf responded the day after the ruling that he would appeal the decision, calling some of the criticisms of his handling of the virus “conspiracy theories” and pointing out that the economy is reopened.

What blatant deflection.

The fact that hundreds of small businesses have been forced to close and thousands of Pennsylvanians have been forced to sign up for unemployment is not a conspiracy. The heartbreak of families kept apart and elderly relatives passing away alone in nursing homes while mass public funerals continue to be held for public figures is immoral. And legally, the restrictions can be reinitiated any time the state determines that the virus is spreading too quickly.

Enough.

Most Americans support commonsense safety measures like masking and social distancing, but the time for devastating and draconian exercises of state authority is long past. America’s commitment to individual liberty does not account for Mr. Wolf’s “new normal,” and constitutional principles are not fair-weather propositions.

First Published: September 17, 2020, 10:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (136)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
The University of Pittsburgh's Cathedral of Learning
1
business
Amid funding uncertainty, Pitt pauses doctoral admissions
Pirates outfielder DJ Stewart gets congratulations from teammates after his home run against the Baltimore Orioles in the first game of the Grapefruit League season at Ed Smith Stadium in Sarasota, Fla., on Saturday, Feb. 22, 2025.
2
sports
5 takeaways from Pirates' spring training victory over Orioles
York County District Attorney Timothy J. Barker reacts during a news conference regarding the shooting at UPMC Memorial Hospital in York, Pa. on Saturday, Feb. 22, 2025.
3
news
Police officer killed, gunman dead in shooting at UPMC Memorial Hospital in York
A new report advises retirees in 2025 to aim for just 3.7% when withdrawing from savings -- down from 4%. Over a 30-year retirement, that could mean the difference between financial security or outliving your cash in your 80s or 90s, financial experts say.
4
business
How much can retirees safely withdraw from their nest eggs? Financial experts weigh in.
Preston Coleman, 52, was beaten and strangled inside an Aliquippa VFW on Jan. 5, 2025, in what police described as a vicious, unprovoked attack.
5
news
Bartender working at Aliquippa VFW during beating that left man unconscious facing charges
Pennsylvania Secretary of Health Dr. Rachel Levine provides an update on the coronavirus as Gov. Tom Wolf listens in March in Harrisburg.  (Joe Hermitt/The Patriot-News via AP)
Joe Hermitt/The Patriot-News via AP
Advertisement
LATEST opinion
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story