Saturday, February 15, 2025, 7:48PM |  38°
MENU
Advertisement
1
MORE

Jerry Zahorchak: Pennsylvania must fund local education, for the students' good — and the state's

Tim Tai/Philadelphia Inquirer

Jerry Zahorchak: Pennsylvania must fund local education, for the students' good — and the state's

A judge will decide, perhaps this fall, whether Pennsylvania’s constitutional mandate to provide “a thorough and efficient system of public education” means that every child must receive a quality public education that prepares them to participate in today’s democracy and economy. 

Commonwealth Court Judge Renée Cohn Jubelirer has heard the evidence in a historic school funding lawsuit, William Penn School District v. Pa. Department of Education. The dramatic trial ended in March.

Fewer than half of Pennsylvania students are able to demonstrate proficiency in reading and math. Thousands graduate unprepared to succeed in a world demanding far more than basic literacy. Their schools lack adequate resources.  Their communities lack capacity to raise the necessary funds to meet student needs and cover mandated costs.

Advertisement

Six school districts and two statewide organizations took the extraordinary step of suing state officials. The court will determine whether the legislature must finally provide the resources necessary to meet this constitutional mandate — or whether local school districts and taxpayers will continue to be stuck with inadequate funding, unable to fix this problem on their own. Will the General Assembly commit to supporting this system for all students, including those in low-wealth communities, so all are able to thrive and give back to the commonwealth as workers, taxpayers, and entrepreneurs?

Fifteen years ago, the state legislature commissioned a study to determine the cost of ensuring that by graduation, all students can perform at grade level. I presided over the legislature’s six-year plan to close funding gaps — called adequacy gaps — to ensure that every child had what they need to be college- and career-ready.

But the General Assembly turned away from this commitment, passing the buck to local taxpayers. Since then, problems have snowballed. None of the school districts surrounding my hometown of Johnstown have been able to close the widening funding gaps. The General Assembly has left local taxpayers without good options. Districts can try to raise more locally — or let students go without the resources they need.

This problem was on stark display when schools closed during the pandemic. Districts like Greater Johnstown couldn’t provide all students with laptops for remote learning until many months after schools closed down.

Advertisement

Yet Senate president pro tempore Jake Corman, a legislative respondent in this lawsuit, defends this flawed system. He and other legislators call claims that schools are underfunded “patently false,” while trumpeting recent state spending increases.

In fact, those increases haven’t nearly kept pace with steadily rising mandated costs facing school districts, for pensions, special education, and charter schools in particular. As costs rise, spending gaps between wealthy and poor districts grow.

Sen. Corman argues that our state has higher average spending than other states. But the Census data he cites shows that Pennsylvania’s per-student spending ranks seventh among nine states in our competitive market, the Northeast. Average spending statistics paint a misleading picture. Affluent districts have an abundance of taxable properties and easily raise far more than lower-wealth communities, thus inflating the average.

Similarly, the legislative respondents say Pennsylvania students on average perform adequately on standardized tests, but that unimpressive average hides vast race and class disparities in outcomes resulting from unequal local resources.

Sen. Corman’s arguments obscure a truth: In education, money matters. Increased funding used wisely produces results.

The proof: Fifteen years ago, when Pennsylvania made sustained efforts to close adequacy gaps, student outcomes improved. As Penn State professor Matthew Kelly testified at the trial, students from low-income families fare better in well-resourced districts than their peers in low-wealth districts.

This lawsuit is about the futures of generations of students — making sure they have meaningful, productive lives. If the senator’s defense of the status quo prevails, educators will continue to do the best they can, but we as a commonwealth will continue to fail thousands of children through no fault of their own. Invest now, or really pay later.

I’m hopeful that forward-thinking Pennsylvanians will prevail upon our legislators to make a change that lifts our children and our state for decades to come.

Jerry Zahorchak, former secretary of the Pennsylvania Department of Education, is former superintendent of the Greater Johnstown School District.

First Published: May 25, 2022, 4:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
In Fayette County, voters express renewed hope under the Trump administration, praising his early actions like spending cuts and immigration crackdowns, and grading his first few weeks an "A." Many in the county, where Trump secured 68.4% of the vote, support his executive orders on immigration and federal spending, believing he is fulfilling campaign promises and taking decisive action.
1
news
As Trump's executive orders sow confusion and chaos for some, Western Pa. supporters who voted for him approve
The North Shore offices of the Post-Gazette
2
business
Federal judge denies NLRB's injunction attempt against the Post-Gazette
Pittsburgh Steelers defensive tackle Cameron Heyward (97) looks on with head coach Mike Tomlin, left, prior to the NFL football game against the Philadelphia Eagles, Sunday, Dec. 15, 2024, in Philadelphia.
3
sports
Steelers position analysis: Defensive line the most glaring need heading into NFL draft
Mark Sevco has been named president of Allegheny Health Network
4
business
Former UPMC executive joins Allegheny Health Network
Endy Rodriguez #25 of the Pittsburgh Pirates celebrates after hitting a home run in the 6th inning against the Cincinnati Reds at Great American Ball Park on September 22, 2023 in Cincinnati, Ohio.
5
sports
Endy Rodriguez will primarily catch for Pirates in immediate future — and looks the part post-rehab
 (Tim Tai/Philadelphia Inquirer)
Tim Tai/Philadelphia Inquirer
Advertisement
LATEST opinion
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story