Saturday, March 15, 2025, 8:47AM |  58°
MENU
Advertisement
Spartacus Summers, 5, of Faifley, digs through his storage bed to look for a toy, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, in Clydebank, Scotland. Spartacus' bed was donated to the family two months ago by a local charity.
11
MORE

In Scotland’s suburbs, there's a 'profound moral, ethical duty' to address poverty

Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette

In Scotland’s suburbs, there's a 'profound moral, ethical duty' to address poverty

The Post-Gazette goes to Scotland, where getting kids out of poverty isn't a dream — it's the law

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s year-long exploration of child poverty — its causes and effects, and the solutions available to combat it — leads a team of journalists this week to Scotland. There the Child Poverty (Scotland) Act requires that the national government, local leaders, and the publicly-run health system work together to ensure that by 2030, no more than 5% of kids live in poverty. Find daily dispatches here, and the full story next month.

▪    ▪    ▪

WEST DUNBARTONSHIRE, Scotland — In her 30s, fresh out of college with loans to pay off and her young son Spartacus Summers finally old enough for school, Natalie Muir was in a rush to get a job. Someone told her to drop into the Clydebank High School and check in at the office of a local agency called Working 4 U — which told her to just … slow … down.

Advertisement

That message came from Tricia McGovern, an officer at Working 4 U who would be the perfect aunt or sister. She knows all the angles, has all the connections, and fairly bursts with concern for others’ problems.

A child runs past a line of boarded-up row homes, March 26, 2019, in Duquesne. Duquesne, home to slightly more than 5,500 residents, is one of seven Allegheny County municipalities in which half of or more of the kids live in poverty.
Rich Lord
Pa. tour sheds light on poverty 'box' and yields proposals

Ms. Muir “was quite rightly proud of her achievement, but there was a huge amount of uncertainty that rushed into her life,” said Ms. McGovern. She was the single parent to Spartacus and his sister Monique Summers, 16. So instead of rushing Ms. Muir into a job, Working 4 U helped her to sort through the benefits available to her — and introduced her to the local food bank.

Working 4 U operates in an area west of Glasgow, down the Clyde River, which has a history not unlike the Mon Valley’s.

Gone are the massive Singer Sewing Machine factory and the shipyards that once joined Glasgow’s in producing a big part of the world’s fleets. All that’s left of that now is a giant blue crane known as the Titan that casts its shadow over a massive private-public development site.

Advertisement

“The west of Scotland has for a long time been blighted by deindustrialization,” said Stephen Brooks, the Working4U Manager for West Dunbartonshire Council.

“Areas of Western Scotland became a wasteland,” and of the 90,000 residents of the district, some 35,000 live in neighborhoods that the Scots characterize as areas of “multiple deprivation” — low incomes, limited housing options, high crime — said Mr. Brooks.

Unlike much of the Mon Valley, though, West Dunbartonshire’s government didn’t fall off a fiscal cliff when industry left. That’s because Scottish local government doesn’t rely primarily on the local tax base. Around 85% of the cost of local government (including schools) is covered by allocations from the national government, with the rest covered by property taxes and fees.

In Pennsylvania, it’s basically the reverse. The commonwealth’s cities, boroughs and townships get, on average, 22% of their funding from the state, according to a 2017 analysis by the National League of Cities.

Caroline Mockford, of Govan a neighborhood of Glasgow, left, listens as Sandra Carter, of Edinburgh, speaks during the monthly Poverty Truth Community meeting, Friday, Oct. 25, 2019, at The Pyramid at Anderston in Glasgow, Scotland.
Rich Lord and Michael Santiago
Echoes of Scotland's anti-poverty revolution

The most troubled municipalities get some extra money from state and county sources, but even impoverished North Braddock relies on local sources for around 70% of its budget.

Relatively stable funding allows West Dunbartonshire to build affordable housing, organize activities for young people and put Working 4 U Family Opportunity Hubs in the high schools. That, in turn, allows the schools to steer parents from struggling families directly to the likes of Tricia McGovern, who knows where to find everything from jobs to free kitchen appliances to the food bank.


Natalie Muir sits in the Nurture Room, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, at Clydebank High School in West Dunbartonshire, Scotland. Natalie is a single mother with a 16-year-old daughter and a 5-year-old son.(Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)

Ms. Muir, 34, didn’t want to go to the food bank. “We’re Scottish. We’re very proud, you know,” she explained. But cuts to public benefits, high rent and her student loan payments threatened to push her deep into poverty, and Ms. McGovern not only talked her into going, but drove the groceries to her door.

Now that Ms. Muir has the resources to meet her family’s needs, she’s working with Ms. McGovern on budgeting and setting up a vocational plan in line with her education in beauty therapy.

Under the Child Poverty (Scotland) Act, passed in 2017, local governments have to report annually on their efforts to increase employment and reduce household costs for families in poverty, with the aim of slashing child poverty to minimal levels by 2030.

Mr. Brooks proudly cites the 500 people Working 4 U put into jobs last year, but he also feels he’s rowing against the current.

“Over the next few years there’s going to be a 6% increase in the level of child poverty,” said Mr. Brooks, citing experts’ predictions. “That’s a direct result of the reduction of welfare, the changes in the welfare benefit system.” If the United Kingdom leaves the European Union, the headwinds could be even stronger, he said.

West Dunbartonshire is trying to ensure that any increase in poverty does not result in a spike in homelessness.

“We have a major house-building program underway, to what I would argue is a very high standard of design,” said Peter Barry, head of housing and employability for West Dunbartonshire Council. “We’re building houses so that effectively anybody, with any level of need, can live in the house.”

There are more than 10,500 public housing units in West Dunbartonshire, or roughly ¼ of all homes. Another 7,000 units are run by “social landlords” under a system roughly analogous to the Section 8 program in the U.S. Unlike the U.S., Scottish public housing can accept people of any income level, though the poor get priority.

“As a human being, we have an absolutely innate duty to look out for each other,” said Mr. Barry. “We believe there’s a profound moral, ethical duty to deliver services and to allow our children to flourish — to allow people to tackle problems that are not of their own making.”

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1542 or Twitter @richelord.

First Published: October 24, 2019, 8:01 p.m.

RELATED
From left: Holly Muir, 9, Mark Cleary, 9, Hanford Frimpong, 11, and Summer McKay, 10, all of Bridgeton, listen as Stacy Innerst, children's book illustrator, speaks, Wednesday, Oct. 23, 2019, at Sacred Heart Primary School in Glasgow, Scotland.
Rich Lord and Michael Santiago
If the kids ran Scotland …
Nicole Melville, 29, of Possilpark, a neighborhood in Glasgow, Scotland, at the Possobilities vocational training program on  Tuesday.
Rich Lord and Michael Santiago
Exploring the 'Possobilities' in Scotland's poorest ward
Trisha Gadson, a leader of the Allegheny County Children's Fund Working Group, speaks during a community meeting at the Bethel Park Community Center, Tuesday, June 4, 2019, in Bethel Park.
Rich Lord
Report: County needs new department to address kids' needs
Hanna Abrha holds her son, Eliad, 7 months, as she speaks with Janet Tobin at Cafe Stork, Tuesday, Oct. 21, 2019, at Parkhead Congregational Church in Glasgow, Scotland. Ms. Tobin is the National Health Service’s health improvement manager for North East Glasgow.
Rich Lord and Michael Santiago
In Scotland, families with sick kids receive financial prescriptions
Nellie Brown, left, 6, lounges on the porch bannister as her brother Oliver, 7, plays with a set of toy teeth on April 3 at their family farm straddling Saltlick and Bullskin in Fayette County. Behind the is the milkbarn where their father milks  twice a day. His family has lived on the farmland since the 1700s. In Saltlick, more than half of kids are growing up below the poverty line.
Rich Lord
Grown-up solutions to combat child poverty
A child runs past a line of boarded-up row homes on March 26 in Duquesne. Duquesne, home to slightly more than 5,500 residents, is one of seven Allegheny County municipalities in which half of or more of the kids live in poverty.
Kate Giammarise
Concentrated child poverty worsens in Pennsylvania, study says
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Russell Wilson (3) and Cleveland Browns quarterback Jameis Winston (5) embrace after an NFL football game, Sunday, Dec. 8, 2024, in Pittsburgh.
1
sports
Jason Mackey: Why are the Steelers waiting so long for Aaron Rodgers? There's another option
The dome of the U.S. Capitol is seen in December 2024, when the House previously approved a stopgap funding bill to avert a government shutdown.
2
news
Fetterman says he won’t back government shutdown as funding deadline looms over Senate
The Social Security Administration Building at 6117 Penn Circle North in East Liberty Wednesday, Jan. 2, 2019 in Pittsburgh.
3
news
Social Security Administration to begin withholding full benefits from overpaid recipients
Firefighters and officers respond to a collapsed porch roof on Friday, March 14, 2025, in Oakland. Earlier, during a college party, the roof caved in with over a dozen people on and below the structure. Multiple injuries were reported, and the porch was condemned.
4
local
WATCH: Several injured after roof collapsed on Oakland building
St. Patrick’s Day Parade marchers walk down the Blvd. of the Allies Downtown Saturday, March 16, 2024.
5
local
The luck of the Irish returns to Pittsburgh with Saturday’s St. Patrick’s Day parade
Spartacus Summers, 5, of Faifley, digs through his storage bed to look for a toy, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, in Clydebank, Scotland. Spartacus' bed was donated to the family two months ago by a local charity.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Spartacus Summers, 5, of Faifley, lifts his storage bed to look for a toy, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, in Clydebank, Scotland.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Spartacus Summers squeezes out of a corner after closing his storage bed to look for a toy.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Spartacus Summers, 5, of Faifley, stares quietly out of his room while playing with a toy truck, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Spartacus Summers walks through the halls of his home on his way to his room, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, at Faifley in Clydebank, Scotland.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Natalie Muir, her son, Spartacus Summers, 5, and her daughter, Monique Summers, 16, in their living room, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, in the Faifley neighborhood in Clydebank, Scotland.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Spartacus Summers watches as a toy robot lights up and walks, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, at Faifley in Clydebank, Scotland.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Natalie Muir sits in the Nurture Room, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, at Clydebank High School in Clydebank, West Dunbartonshire, Scotland. Natalie is a single mother with a 16-year-old daughter and a 5-year-old son.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Natalie Muir fixes a wooden name plate with her son's name on it that she intends to hang on the wall of his room.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Spartacus Summers talks about the features of his toy train while playing in his room, Thursday, Oct. 24, 2019, at Faifley in Clydebank, Scotland.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Spartacus Summers plays with toys in his room.  (Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette)
Michael M. Santiago/Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story