HARRISBURG — Amid a growing death toll and mounting pressure from lawmakers and advocates, Pennsylvania officials on Tuesday released a long sought-after list of long-term care facilities where COVID-19 has infected or killed residents.
The information, published by the state Department of Health in a spreadsheet, shows the names of facilities, the county in which each facility is located, the number of resident cases, the number of staff cases, and the number of deaths.
The state redacted information for “facilities with less than five in any of these data points.” That translates to 156 facilities where at least one death occurred, but an exact count was not provided.
With no announcement, the state later published an updated version of the data after providers raised issues with the numbers, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported.
For example, a Delaware County personal care home that can serve 16 residents was reported as having 65 cases. A spokesperson for the health department said there have been issues with data consistency and reporting.
As the situation inside some of Pennsylvania’s long-term care facilities has worsened, lawmakers and advocates for seniors have called on the state and federal government to release the list. Failing to do so, they said, allowed some facilities to hide known cases of the virus from residents, families, staff, and the larger community, and obscured which homes were most in need of resources.
In Allegheny County, there had been releases of data at the Kane Community Living Centers, which reported 18 deaths at its Glen Hazel facility. However, the situation at other homes within the county largely has been a mystery.
On Tuesday, the state’s list shed new light on the homes hardest hit by the COVID-19 outbreak. In Allegheny County, they are:
• Caring Heights Community Care and Rehab, with 65 cases among residents, 22 among staff and 28 deaths.
• St. Barnabas, with 62 cases among residents, 14 among staff and 31 deaths.
• Village at Pennwood, with 41 cases among residents, 11 among staff and 9 deaths.
Brighton Rehabilitation and Wellness Center, in Beaver County, continues to have the highest number of deaths in the state. At least 76 people have died at the facility, where the state has installed a temporary manager and sent in the National Guard for additional support. Lawmakers have called for a federal investigation.
Some living center are disputing the state’s numbers.
Kelly Pynos, the administrator at Loyalhanna Care Center in Latrobe, said her facility has had 22 cases of COVID-19 among its residents, not the 30 cited by the state. She said 21 of its employees have tested positive, while the state said there are 18.
"It is very odd," she said, adding that she has heard from other nursing home administrators who also disagree with the state's figures.
Ms. Pynos does not object to the death total the state provided about Loyalhanna. She said that six residents died who tested positive for COVID-19, but noted that an additional five residents who died never received a test, and are "presumed positive."
All 21 of the employees who tested positive have since recovered, she said.
There are four asymptomatic residents who are awaiting a second negative test result; the rest have since recovered or died, Ms. Pynos said.
"We're coming to the end of our outbreak," Ms. Pynos said. "The worst is behind us."
In early April, U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., called on the federal government to widely release the list of facilities with known cases. And by the middle of last month, the nation’s largest advocate for senior welfare, the AARP, also urged Pennsylvania to do so.
But state officials demurred, first saying the data was too convoluted to make public, and later citing a decades-old disease privacy law. The state reversed course following a federal regulatory change that mandates long-term care facilities report cases to federal officials, and notify residents and families.
State health officials said last week they would release the list in compliance with the rule’s new reporting requirements for data collection, which began Sunday.
Several other states made the names of facilities with cases public prior to federal requirements, however, including New Jersey, Minnesota and Kentucky.
The list released Tuesday by Pennsylvania officials contains alarming statistics. There are roughly four dozen nursing homes or assisted living facilities where at least 20 people have died.
At Parkhouse Rehabilitation & Nursing Center in Montgomery County, 48 people have died and 149 others have been infected. At Gracedale Nursing Home in Northampton County, 44 people have died and 245 others have tested positive for the virus. And at ManorCare Health Services in Sinking Spring, in Berks County, there have been 44 deaths to date.
Deaths in nursing homes and assisted living facilities currently account for more than 68% of all the coronavirus-related fatalities in the state, with 3,086 long-term care residents dead as of Tuesday. Until Tuesday, the state had only released information by county, which showed the highest number of deaths occurring at unnamed homes in Philadelphia, Montgomery, Bucks and Delaware Counties.
Spotlight PA is an independent, nonpartisan newsroom powered by The Philadelphia Inquirer in partnership with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and PennLive/Patriot-News. Sign up for our free weekly newsletter.
First Published: May 19, 2020, 6:09 p.m.
Updated: May 19, 2020, 7:54 p.m.
