Saturday, February 22, 2025, 10:28AM |  25°
MENU
Advertisement
Lisa Mahoney, a resident of East Palestine for 31 years, attends an EPA open house event at the high-school in East Palestine on Friday, March 24.
3
MORE

The EPA waited weeks to test for dioxins after East Palestine derailment. Residents and advocates now demand more transparency.

(Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The EPA waited weeks to test for dioxins after East Palestine derailment. Residents and advocates now demand more transparency.

Linda and Russell Murphy left an open house at East Palestine High School on Thursday evening with more questions than answers.

The school’s gymnasium has turned into a hub for informational forums for residents impacted by the Feb. 3 train derailment. But the sparsely attended event Thursday, intended to inform residents about preliminary soil sampling results, seems to represent a growing exhaustion felt among residents as they try to pick up the pieces of their lives.

Image Description

“If you've been here over the past couple weeks, you'll see that the tables are dropping off,” Mrs. Murphy said. “The attendance is terrible because it can feel pointless. You can't see what the dioxins will do. You can't see the cancer coming.”

Advertisement

Earlier this month, the EPA ordered Norfolk Southern to sample for dioxins, a highly toxic, cancer-causing substance, in East Palestine. Residents and advocates are now demanding more transparency around the testing process, which a Norfolk Southern contractor began about a week and a half ago.

U.S. Sen. John Fetterman (D-PA) last month in Washington.
Jonathan D. Salant
John Fetterman pushes for railroad safety in first bill as a senator

Over 100 organizations in Ohio, Pennsylvania and across the country made their concerns known in a joint letter to the EPA. The letter, sent March 13, outlines several recommendations to rebuild public trust and comprehensively address the possible release of dioxins.

The letter, among other recommendations, asked the EPA to conduct the testing rather than Norfolk, to allow the public to weigh in on its sampling plan, to implement medical monitoring and to expand the scope of its testing beyond soil, including farm animals, wildlife and waterways.

One of the letter’s key orchestrators, Mike Schade of Toxic-Free Future, said his organization discovered that Norfolk’s contractor, a Netherlands-based consulting company known as Arcadis, had created a preliminary soil sampling plan on the same day they sent the letter. But Mr. Schade said the same problems still stood.

Advertisement

“The sampling plan was developed really quickly, and the EPA signed off on it pretty quickly,” Mr. Schade said. “And to date, as far as I'm aware, there wasn't an opportunity for impacted communities to provide input. So for all those reasons, we decided to still move forward with sending the letter because these issues still remain true today.”

A myriad of questions have swarmed around several toxic chemicals the Norfolk train was carrying when it crashed, including vinyl chloride, which is associated with a rare form of liver cancer and other health effects.

But more than the vinyl chloride itself, public health experts such as Stephen Lester of The Center for Health, Environment and Justice, a Virginia-based nonprofit, are deeply concerned about the byproducts that the vinyl chloride and other chemicals created during Norfolk’s controlled explosion in five hazardous tanker cars.

“That generated a chemical that's very toxic,” he said. “That chemical traveled in that black cloud into the community. That chemical is referred to as dioxin.”

Protesters stop on a bridge as workers tend to clean up efforts on Saturday, March 25, 2023, East Palestine Ohio.
Steven Mufson
DOJ sues Norfolk Southern over toxic East Palestine train derailment

Exposure to dioxins can cause cancer, reproductive damage, developmental problems, immune effects, skin lesions and other adverse health effects. It’s also a chemical that’s slow to break down once it is in the environment, according to the EPA’s site.

Mr. Lester believes dioxins should have been immediately tested for due to the known danger of burning chemicals like vinyl chloride, rather than six weeks later.

“They were actually dismissing it and minimizing, which didn't make any sense, because it's well documented that when you burn that kind of chlorinated chemical, you will generate dioxins,” Mr. Lester said. “Given that dioxins form on black particulate matter, which that cloud was packed full with, there's no reason to think it wouldn't be there.”’

Judith Enck, founder of Beyond Plastics, an initiative that focuses on plastic pollution, has handled environmental crises as a former EPA regional administrator under the Obama administration.

She said the EPA made two mistakes after the derailment. The first, waiting too long to test for dioxins and second, allowing a railroad contractor to lead the testing.

“I know what the EPA is capable of,” she said. “There's no question they should have been doing this themselves, and not hand it off to the company's contractor because there's already deep distrust within the community. The EPA needed to recognize that.”

Mr. Schade said Toxic-Free Future did not hear from the EPA until last Tuesday after they followed up on their letter. He said the EPA agreed to meet with advocacy groups to hear their concerns. That meeting has yet to be scheduled.

For now, experts are reviewing the 117-page plan released earlier this month. One area of concern for Mr. Lester is that the plan indicated soil sampling would largely depend on “visual inspections” for ash, soot and other remnants of the derailment and chemical burn.

Mr. Lester said relying on visual inspections is a highly unusual approach, since the surface soil has been altered since the derailment first happened. Finding residuals or fragments on the ground would not be “very likely six weeks out from the incident,” he said.

Other environmental factors like rain could also push the toxins deeper into the soil, so surface soil collection wouldn’t be adequate. It’s also unclear what detection limit is being used to find the various forms of dioxin, as it can be highly toxic at very low concentrations, Mr. Lester said.

Arcadis’ plan did not note any future sampling from water or farm animals, even though Mr. Lester said this is standard procedure when looking for dioxin contamination.

“This is a standard experience with dioxin exposure,” Mr. Lester said. “Dioxin accumulates in animals. So any cow, goat or animal that would graze on land and grasses where the dioxin settled will be consuming it. That will eventually get into the milk, into the meat, into the cheese. The only way you'll know is if EPA goes out and does the testing in the places where these questions exist.”

Mark Durno, response coordinator for the U.S. EPA, spent Thursday evening fielding such questions from residents to explain soil sampling efforts.

He said the sampling plan was initiated about a week and a half ago, and the agency wanted to share preliminary results for soil, which was collected mostly from the outskirts of East Palestine, including agricultural parts of Beaver County, to keep the community informed.

Mr. Durno said they expect to release the final results in the next several weeks.

“The good news is that all the levels of semi volatile organic compounds and dioxins have all come back with our preliminary results looking like typical background levels in urban and rural areas,” he said.

He said the EPA did not conduct dioxin sampling earlier because they didn't see the primary byproducts they were looking for after the release, so secondary byproducts like dioxins weren’t a concern.

“We did some analysis to determine whether or not we thought dioxins were a concern, and we didn't believe there would be an issue,” he said. “However, the community spoke up loudly, and so when a community has been traumatized by an event like this, you do everything you can to help them understand.”

He assured that the visual inspections are not the only determining factor for where they sample soil and that the EPA is closely inspecting Arcadis’ work.

“We don't have a problem with this contractor,” he said. “But we have to oversee them to make sure it's being done right. That's part of our responsibility as a public agency. Hopefully, when all the sampling is done, we'll be able to say we see no appreciable impacts on this area.”

The Murphys hope for the same outcome for their small community. The couple said they don’t know where to buy hay to feed their horses or whether they will eventually get sick from the grass they graze on. And as planting season comes up soon, the couple is wondering about the food they eat themselves from nearby farms, wondering if the crops will be safe.

“Their train crashed, and it derailed us,” Mr. Murphy said. “They need to fix it.”

First Published: March 27, 2023, 9:30 a.m.
Updated: March 27, 2023, 4:36 p.m.

RELATED
Darlington Township in Beaver County, just over the Ohio border from the site of the Feb. 3 East Palestine train derailment.
Ford Turner
Pa. wants Norfolk Southern to reimburse farmers who lost meat sales after the East Palestine derailment
In this Feb. 6, 2023, file photo, South Beaver police block Route 51 as smoke billows from the train derailment site a few miles away in East Palestine, Ohio.
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Beaver County school district sues Norfolk Southern over chemical plumes
Norfolk Southern CEO Alan Shaw testifies about the Feb.3 derailment in East Palestine, Ohio, before the Pennsylvania state Senate Veterans Affairs and Emergency Preparedness Committee, March 20, 2023, in Harrisburg, Pa. (AP Photo/Marc Levy)
Ford Turner
'Who was the trigger man?' Pa. lawmakers grill Norfolk Southern CEO over chemical burn in East Palestine
Norfolk Southern CEO Alan H. Shaw, center-top, sits with local journalists for a round table discussion at the Centenary United Methodist Church on Thursday in East Palestine.
Jordan Anderson
In East Palestine, Norfolk Southern CEO pledges again to help reeling residents
Heather Bable and her son, Ashton, pose for a photograph, Feb. 25, 2023 at Sprinklz On Top restaurant in East Palestine, Ohio. Ms. Bable and her children live less than a half-mile from where a train derailed in a fiery crash Feb. 3, forcing them to evacuate and raising fears about contamination of air, soil and water.
John Flesher
Aches, rashes and fear: Trauma remains after Ohio derailment
Melanie Johnson, resident of Darlington Township, on Friday, March 10, 2023.  Her property on the North Fork of the Little Beaver Creek is just miles downstream of East Palestine, Ohio.
Jordan Anderson
‘We’re afraid to drink our water’: Beaver County families want assurances after the train derailment
SHOW COMMENTS (19)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Preston Coleman, 52, was beaten and strangled inside an Aliquippa VFW on Jan. 5, 2025, in what police described as a vicious, unprovoked attack.
1
news
Bartender working at Aliquippa VFW during beating that left man unconscious facing charges
The University of Pittsburgh's Cathedral of Learning
2
business
Amid funding uncertainty, Pitt pauses doctoral admissions
Mayor Ed Gainey during  a press conference at the Downtown Public Safety Center on Thursday. He angrily criticized what he believes negative media coverage of his work as mayor.
3
opinion
Brandon McGinley: ‘The wheels are coming off’ the Gainey administration
On the UPMC Mercy Pavilion's rooftop terrace, the Rehabilitation Garden provides a safe environment where patients can practice navigating training ramps, steps and diverse surfaces like gravel, turf and concrete. The garden includes fragrant herbs and other pleasant sensory stimuli.
4
business
East Liberty-based artificial intelligence firm raises $250 million, deploys AI platform in 100 healthcare systems
Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey addresses the media at a construction site in Garfield being rebuilt as part of his Keep Pittsburgh Home: Housing for People, Not for Profit program designed to create affordable housing and forestall speculators within the Pittsburgh Housing Market, Friday, Feb. 21, 2025.
5
news
New Gainey initiative takes aim at ‘predatory’ real estate investors to boost affordable housing
Lisa Mahoney, a resident of East Palestine for 31 years, attends an EPA open house event at the high-school in East Palestine on Friday, March 24.  ((Pittsburgh Post-Gazette) )
Part-time massage therapist Lyndsay De La Rosa Guy holds her son Calep De La rosa, 2, during an EPA open house event at the high-school in East Palestine on Friday, March 24.  ((Pittsburgh Post-Gazette) )
U.S. EPA response coordinator Mark Durno talks to attendees of an EPA open house event at the high-school in East Palestine on Friday, March 24.  ((Pittsburgh Post-Gazette) )
(Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story