Saturday, January 18, 2025, 10:26AM |  29°
MENU
Advertisement
President-elect Donald Trump would have been tried and convicted of election interference in the federal Jan. 6 case if he hadn’t escaped prosecution by winning reelection, special counsel Jack Smith, pictured, said in his final report released after midnight Tuesday.
2
MORE

Special counsel report says Trump would've been convicted for Jan. 6 'unprecedented criminal effort'

Doug Mills/The New York Times

Special counsel report says Trump would've been convicted for Jan. 6 'unprecedented criminal effort'

WASHINGTON — Special counsel Jack Smith said his team “stood up for the rule of law” as it investigated President-elect Donald Trump’s efforts to overturn the results of the 2020 election, writing in a much-anticipated report released Tuesday that he stands fully behind his decision to bring criminal charges that he believes would have resulted in a conviction had voters not returned Trump to the White House.

“The throughline of all of Mr. Trump’s criminal efforts was deceit — knowingly false claims of election fraud — and the evidence shows that Mr. Trump used these lies as a weapon to defeat a federal government function foundational to the United States’ democratic process,” the report states.

The report, arriving just days before Trump is to return to office on Jan. 20, focuses fresh attention on the Republican’s frantic but failed effort to cling to power in 2020 after he lost to Democrat Joe Biden. With the prosecution foreclosed thanks to Trump’s 2024 election victory, the document is expected to be the final Justice Department chronicle of a dark chapter in American history that threatened to disrupt the peaceful transfer of power, a bedrock of democracy for centuries, and complements already released indictments and reports.

Advertisement

Trump responded early Tuesday with a post on his Truth Social platform, claiming he was “totally innocent” and calling Mr. Smith “a lamebrain prosecutor who was unable to get his case tried before the Election.” He added, “THE VOTERS HAVE SPOKEN!!!”

President-elect Donald Trump arrives for a meeting with Republican governors at the Mar-a-Lago Club in Palm Beach, Fla., on Jan. 9, 2025.
Alanna Durkin Richer and Eric Tucker
Judge clears the way for release of special counsel Smith’s report on Trump’s Jan. 6 case

Trump had been indicted in August 2023 on charges of working to overturn the election, but the case was delayed by appeals and ultimately significantly narrowed by a conservative-majority Supreme Court that held for the first time that former presidents enjoy sweeping immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts. That decision, Mr. Smith’s report states, left open unresolved legal issues that would likely have required another trip to the Supreme Court in order for the case to have moved forward.

Though Mr. Smith sought to salvage the indictment, the team dismissed it in November because of long-standing Justice Department policy that says sitting presidents cannot face federal prosecution.

“The Department’s view that the Constitution prohibits the continued indictment and prosecution of a President is categorical and does not turn on the gravity of the crimes charged, the strength of the Government’s proof, or the merits of the prosecution, which the Office stands fully behind,” the report states. “Indeed, but for Mr. Trump’s election and imminent return to the Presidency, the Office assessed that the admissible evidence was sufficient to obtain and sustain a conviction at trial.”

Advertisement

The Justice Department transmitted the report to Congress early Tuesday after a judge refused a defense effort to block its release. A separate volume of the report focused on Trump’s hoarding of classified documents at Mar-a-Lago, actions that formed the basis of a separate indictment against Trump, will remain under wraps for now.

The report is unsparing in its details about schemes undertaken by Trump to undo the presidential contest, accusing him of an “unprecedented criminal effort to overturn the legitimate results of the election in order to retain power.”

It recounts his role in trying to force the Justice Department to use its law enforcement authorities to advance his personal interests and in participating in a scheme to enlist fake electors in battleground states won by Mr. Biden, and it says he directed “an angry mob to the United States Capitol to obstruct the congressional certification of the presidential election and then leverage rioters’ violence to further delay it.”

And it documents his fallout with his vice president, Mike Pence, over Trump’s demands that he refuse to certify the electoral count before Congress on Jan. 6, 2021. It says that just before he left the White House to deliver a speech at the Ellipse that day, he called Mr. Pence one last time and that when the vice president told him that he planned to issue a public statement that he lacked the authority to do as Trump had requested, "Mr. Trump expressed anger at him. He then directed staffers to re-insert into his planned Ellipse speech some language that he had drafted earlier targeting Mr. Pence.”

President-elect Donald Trump met with Sen. John Fetterman this past weekend at the Republican's Mar-a-Lago. Trump described Fetterman as a "commonsense person" after the meeting.
Benjamin Kail
Trump reportedly ‘impressed’ with Sen. John Fetterman after Mar-a-Lago meeting, discussion of U.S. Steel, Israel

Though most of the details of Trump’s efforts to undo the election are already well established, the document includes for the first time a detailed assessment from Smith about his investigation, as well as a defense by Mr. Smith against criticism by Trump and his allies that the inquiry was politicized or that he worked in collaboration with the White House — an assessment he called “laughable.”

“While we were not able to bring the cases we charged to trial, I believe the fact that our team stood up for the rule of law matters,” Mr. Smith wrote in a letter to Attorney General Merrick Garland attached to the report. "I believe the example our team set for others to fight for justice without regard for the personal costs matters.”

The special counsel also laid out the challenges it faced in its investigation, including Trump’s assertion of executive privilege to try to block witnesses from providing evidence, which forced prosecutors into sealed court battles before the case was charged.

Another “significant challenge” was Trump’s “ability and willingness to use his influence and following on social media to target witnesses, courts, prosecutors,” which led prosecutors to seek a gag order to protect potential witnesses from harassment, Mr. Smith wrote.

“Mr. Trump’s resort to intimidation and harassment during the investigation was not new, as demonstrated by his actions during the charged conspiracies,” Mr. Smith wrote.

“A fundamental component of Mr. Trump’s conduct underlying the charges in the Election Case was his pattern of using social media — at the time, Twitter — to publicly attack and seek to influence state and federal officials, judges, and election workers who refused to support false claims that the election had been stolen or who otherwise resisted complicity in Mr. Trump’s scheme," he added.

Mr. Smith also provided fresh analysis about his team’s prosecution decisions, writing that his office decided not to charge Trump with incitement in part because of free speech concerns, or with insurrection because he was the sitting president at the time and there was doubt about proceeding to trial with the offense — of which there was no record of having been prosecuted before.

First Published: January 14, 2025, 11:08 a.m.
Updated: January 15, 2025, 2:59 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (279)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Quarterback Kenny Pickett, left, the Pittsburgh Steelers first-round NFL football draft pick, poses for a photo with president/owner Art Rooney II at the team's training facility in Pittsburgh, Friday, April 29, 2022.
1
sports
Joe Starkey: Steelers offense in disrepair thanks to series of misguided, arrogant decisions
Boston Red Sox relief pitcher Chase Shugart gets a new ball after giving up a three-run home run to Chicago White Sox's Andrew Benintendi during the seventh inning of a baseball game, Saturday, Sept. 7, 2024, in Boston.
2
sports
Pirates acquire right-hander Chase Shugart in trade with Red Sox
Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Alex Nedeljkovic, center, celebrates with teammates after scoring during the third period of an NHL hockey game against the Buffalo Sabres, Friday, Jan. 17, 2025, in Buffalo, N.Y. (AP Photo/Jeffrey T. Barnes)
3
sports
Inside Alex Nedeljkovic’s historic night and more takeaways from a wild Penguins win in Buffalo
Ice on the Allegheny River in Downtown on Tuesday, Jan.14, 2025. Pittsburgh is forecast to see extreme cold weather next week, with wind chills of 25 degrees below zero possible.
4
news
Pittsburgh is under an extreme cold watch. Here's what that means and what to expect.
U.S. Steel Clairton Mill Works in Clairton earlier this month.
5
business
'There is no agreement': Cleveland-Cliffs, USW deny scheming to foil U.S. Steel deal with Nippon
President-elect Donald Trump would have been tried and convicted of election interference in the federal Jan. 6 case if he hadn’t escaped prosecution by winning reelection, special counsel Jack Smith, pictured, said in his final report released after midnight Tuesday.  (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
In this image from video, Aileen M. Cannon speaks remotely during a Senate Judiciary Committee oversight nomination hearing to be U.S. District Court judge for the Southern District of Florida on July 29, 2020, in Washington.  (U.S. Senate via AP)
Doug Mills/The New York Times
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story