Saturday, February 15, 2025, 2:11AM |  28°
MENU
Advertisement
Robert "Faruq" Wideman discusses the controversial homicide case that put him in prison with a life sentence and his struggle to be released during a panel discussion at Duquesne University's Forensic Friday's presentation "From Conviction to Commutation: Revisiting the Robert Wideman case" Friday in Pittsburgh. His brother author John Wideman, at left, who wrote about the case in his 1984 memoir Brothers and Keepers.
1
MORE

Wideman brothers join Judge Manning, others for criminal justice forum

Pam Panchak/Post-Gazette

Wideman brothers join Judge Manning, others for criminal justice forum

Gov. Wolf commuted Robert Wideman's sentence for role in 1975 killing

On the night of Nov. 17, 1975, Robert “Faruq” Wideman and two others, Michael Dukes and Cecil Rice, planned to meet and rob used car salesman Nicola Morena in his lot on Pittsburgh’s Saw Mill Run Boulevard under the guise of selling him a truckload of stolen TVs.

“We predetermined, ‘look, we ain’t going to shoot none of these guys. We’re going to scare them, we got guns, they’ll give us the money,’” Wideman recalled.

But the plan unraveled, and Dukes shot Morena in the back as he ran away. Morena died later after being taken to two different hospitals.

Advertisement

Though Wideman did not pull the trigger, he — along with Dukes — was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole. Rice was convicted of murder in the third degree and has since finished serving his 20-year sentence.

In this Oct. 30, 1998, file photo, Robert Wideman is escorted from an Allegheny County courtroom after being denied bail pending a retrial.
John M.R. Bull
From the Archives: Appeal keeps Wideman in jail; Zappala beats clock, prevents freedom for 23-year prisoner

Questioning felony murder charges for those who didn’t actually commit homicide but were present was the subject of a Friday event at Duquesne University that featured Wideman and his brother, acclaimed writer John Edgar Wideman, who for the first time together spoke about the case and Robert’s 2019 commutation.

“How can you say that I knew my co-defendant would shoot someone? ... It bothers the mind,” said Wideman, now 69 and on parole. “I know they [prisoners serving life on a felony murder conviction] did something heinous, and they should go to jail. I don’t say, ‘oh, they should just be let go with a pat on the back.’ But for the rest of their lives? That’s too harsh.”

Roughly 5,100 prisoners in Pennsylvania are serving life without parole. Of those, an estimated 1,100 were convicted of second-degree murder, according to the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections.

Advertisement

Gov. Tom Wolf commuted Wideman’s sentence in July, something Wideman describes as a “miracle.”

“Listening to the stories about me this morning, all the people who tried to help me ... so many things had to happen for me to be here [today],” he said at the event hosted by the Cyril H. Wecht Institute of Forensic Science and Law.

Wideman’s 44-year prison sentence included a period of false hope in 1998 when he was granted a new trial by former Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge James McGregor after his attorney Mark D. Schwartz presented evidence that medical malpractice, not the gunshot wound, contributed to or caused Morena’s death. (It came to light in the 1980s that Morena’s family had won a $100,000 malpractice settlement the year after his death.)

But District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala filed a last-minute appeal and successfully stopped Wideman’s release — a move that was roundly criticized at Friday’s panel.

In this Feb. 21, 2001, file photo, U.S. Sen. Arlen Specter discusses educational issues with inmate Robert Wideman as he tours the Education Department at the State Correctional Institution of Pittsburgh.
Paula Reed Ward and Liz Navratil
Pa. pardons board votes 5-0 to grant clemency to Robert Wideman in 1975 murder

Last summer, Mr. Schwartz — who viewed Wideman’s ordeal as a “bucket list case” — decided to begin writing a reconsideration letter to the state pardon board.

“A serendipitous thing happened: I get a call from Judge [Jeffrey A.] Manning, and he says ‘this might be the time to petition the pardon board,’” Mr. Schwartz told the audience.

Judge Manning had prosecuted the 1975 case when he was working as assistant D.A.

He told the Friday audience a story about being confronted in public in recent years after running into Cecil Rice at a beer distributor.

While he said he still believes Wideman was “no doubt” the “mastermind” of the robbery scheme, “he was no more guilty than Cecil Rice was” for the murder.

“The problem is there’s two words: without parole,” Judge Manning said.

A longtime critic of the state’s second-degree murder life sentence, the judge spoke in favor of Wideman’s release during the May pardon hearing in Harrisburg. 

The board voted unanimously to grant Wideman clemency.

While the pieces fell in just the right place for Wideman’s pardon, the commutation process is “not the right venue” to address the issue, said John Wetzel, the state’s Department of Corrections secretary, who also spoke at the event.

“It’s the only venue today, but I think it’s not the best solution. I think public policy issues should be handled on the front end from a legislative standpoint, instead of reverse engineering at the back end,” he said.

Wideman’s brother John Edgar, 79, who wrote the 1984 award-winning book “Brothers and Keepers: A Memoir,” about the case and its consequences, shared a new essay about his brother’s release and criticized the political power of the district attorney’s office.

“It won’t change if we don’t change it,” he said.

Mr. Zappala’s office responded to the panel’s criticism of its 1998 decision via a written statement.

“The district attorney is not part of the panel that determines commutations or pardons. We took a position based, in part, on conversations with the victim’s family. Also, as a matter of fact, this individual directed the killing of another person,” wrote spokesman Mike Manko.

Ashley Murray: 412-263-1750 or amurray@post-gazette.com 

First Published: February 14, 2020, 11:02 p.m.

RELATED
In this Oct. 27, 1998, file photo, Robert Wideman sits in Judge James McGreggor's courtroom during a hearing on an appeal for his second-degree murder conviction.
Liz Navratil
Gov. Wolf commutes sentence for Allegheny County man convicted in 1975 murder
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Mark Sevco has been named president of Allegheny Health Network
1
business
Former UPMC executive joins Allegheny Health Network
The North Shore offices of the Post-Gazette
2
business
Federal judge denies NLRB's injunction attempt against the Post-Gazette
Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker Preston Smith (91) celebrates a play while playing the Cincinnati Bengals at Acrisure Stadium on Saturday, Jan. 4, 2025, in the North Shore.
3
sports
Steelers release LB Preston Smith, hire New Castle native Scott McCurley as inside linebackers coach
TSA officials display the proper way to transport a gun in checked luggage during a press conference at Pittsburgh International Airport Thursday, Jan. 23, 2025.
4
news
TSA intercepts loaded pink gun at Pittsburgh International Airport
Justin Fields #2 of the Pittsburgh Steelers looks on from the sideline in the second quarter of a game against the Washington Commanders at Northwest Stadium on November 10, 2024, in Landover, Maryland.
5
sports
Analysis: Steelers could still find a franchise quarterback in Justin Fields, but he’d have to defy history
Robert "Faruq" Wideman discusses the controversial homicide case that put him in prison with a life sentence and his struggle to be released during a panel discussion at Duquesne University's Forensic Friday's presentation "From Conviction to Commutation: Revisiting the Robert Wideman case" Friday in Pittsburgh. His brother author John Wideman, at left, who wrote about the case in his 1984 memoir Brothers and Keepers.  (Pam Panchak/Post-Gazette)
Pam Panchak/Post-Gazette
Advertisement
LATEST news
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story