The front door of 6109 Fifth Ave., Apt. 2, in Shadyside opens into what was once the formal dining room of the 132-year-old building.
Now used as a (less formal) living room, it still has many of its original details, including a hardwood floor, judge’s paneling, a coffered ceiling and thick wood trim around each of the six windows. A trio of built-in benches form a window seat underneath the leaded-glass bay window.
Hector Naranjo and Yolanda Alvarez have made a number of updates to the condominium over the 20 years they’ve owned it, but they've kept the living room exactly as it was when they moved in.
“We didn’t touch that room,” said Alvarez.
It’s their favorite place in the house.
“I like to lay down on the window seat with a small pillow behind my head,” said Naranjo. “Sometimes I fall fast asleep. It’s very comfortable.”
Adding to the comfort of the room is a working fireplace complete with an intricately carved wooden mantel. To the right of the fireplace is a built-in cabinet and to the left is what Naranjo believes to be an original door with a peephole that, he imagines, was used by the house’s staff more than 100 years ago to see when the owners and their guests were ready for the next course of the meal.
“It’s like a peep into history,” he said.
Built in 1893 on what was then considered “Millionaire’s Row,” the property remained a single-family home until 1985, when it was divided into four condominiums. Naranjo and Alvarez bought Apt. 2 in 2005 for $282,500 when their son, Justin, was a nursing student at the University of Pittsburgh. He was looking for an off-campus apartment to rent and the Miami-based couple started searching for an investment property he could stay in instead.
Justin lived there while he finished his degree. Their other son, Chris, a software engineer, also lived there while he worked remotely. Naranjo and Alvarez now stay there when they visit the city they’ve grown to love.
“It was supposed to be a four- or five-year deal, but 20 years later, we’re still here,” said Naranjo.
During the last two decades, the couple has taken part in the preservation of their home as well as the rest of the building. Alvarez currently serves as treasurer and project manager for the homeowners association. She and Naranjo work with the other owners to make necessary updates like replacing the railings in the front of the building and installing a new floor in the common parlor area.
But now with their sons in different cities and their primary residence still in Florida, they have made the difficult decision to sell.
“The four of us are having a hard time leaving it,” said Alvarez. “It really hurts us to sell the place, but we don’t need it anymore.”
The two-bedroom, 1½-bath condo with 1,820 square feet of living space and a one-car garage is listed for $510,000 (MLS No. 1720699) with Molly Finley of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services (howardhanna.com or 412-427-9668).
The HOA fee is $230 per month and covers heating and cooling in the common parlor area, water, snow removal, yard work and property insurance. Additional parking is available in the front of the building for guests or a second vehicle.
The living room leads to a modern, eat-in kitchen with breakfast bar and a new refrigerator and gas stove. Next to the kitchen is a laundry nook with a full-sized washer and dryer and a powder room.
A separate door opens from the kitchen to a 17-by-12-foot sunroom with Mexican tile that once served as a back deck, but was enclosed by a previous owner. There are six large windows on the room’s external wall that let in a lot of sunlight and a glass door that leads out to a small deck area.
Naranjo and Alvarez installed new floors on the second floor, which has an 18-by-14-foot main bedroom with three closets, a 16-by-11-foot second bedroom and a full bathroom.
The 2025 Allegheny County assessment is $320,000 and annual taxes are $7,994. One of the other four units at 6109 Fifth Ave. sold for $270,000 in January 2024 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us).
Finley, the real estate agent, said that condos in the building don't come on the market very often.
“Homeowners love living there and don’t want to leave,” she said.
Naranjo and Alvarez said they'll miss their home's walkability. They travel by foot to Mellon Park and Bakery Square to eat at Golden Gai and to Highland Avenue, where their favorite restaurants include Muddy Waters Oyster Bar, Noodlehead and Casbah.
“When we come to Pittsburgh, we park our car at our building and leave it there until it’s time for us to go back to Miami,” said Naranjo. “We walk everywhere.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.