Wednesday, February 19, 2025, 4:37AM |  11°
MENU
Advertisement
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro speaks at a news conference at the United Association Local 524 union building in Scranton, Pa., on Wednesday, March 13, 2024.
5
MORE

Gov. Shapiro calls for Pennsylvania carbon cap and trade market, plus higher clean energy requirements

Commonwealth Media Services

Gov. Shapiro calls for Pennsylvania carbon cap and trade market, plus higher clean energy requirements

Gov. Josh Shapiro unveiled his energy strategy on Wednesday, a two-pronged approach that would create a carbon cap and trade market in Pennsylvania and boost the amount of clean energy delivered to electric utility consumers in the state.

Inside a union hall in Scranton, the Electric City, Mr. Shapiro was flanked by members of a workgroup he assembled to determine whether Pennsylvania should join the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, a carbon cap and trade compact that has divided the general assembly and drawn fierce opposition from fossil fuel powerplant operators.

Mr. Shapiro’s plan, which the governor said would be filed as legislation next week, involves establishing a Pennsylvania-specific carbon pollution cap and trade scheme for the electric power sector, with proceeds going towards utility ratepayer rebates and clean energy projects.

Advertisement

Unlike the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, which sets a limit for carbon emissions across a 12-state area and makes powerplants buy pollution allowances, the Pennsylvania Climate Emissions Reduction Act (PACER) would constrain the market to the Keystone State and its several dozen large power producers.

Among the Democrats who have fought to preserve subsidies for the oil and gas industry is Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia, the state that is ranked second for coal production and fourth for natural gas.
Lisa Friedman
U.S. taxpayers have subsidized fossil fuels for 111 Years, and counting

“We will not take direction from anyone outside of this commonwealth,” Mr. Shapiro vowed during his speech. “This initiative will be established by us, run by us.

“We will set our own cap, we will set our own price. We won’t have any other state determining what is right for us in Pennsylvania.”

The second prong of the effort is a long-awaited increase in the state’s Alternative Energy Portfolio Standards, which today mandate that 18% of the electricity supplied to consumers here comes from renewable and alternative sources. That standard, adopted in 2004, was once innovative but has since been surpassed by many other states.

Advertisement

Mr. Shapiro’s proposal would lift the requirement to 50% by the year 2035, with 35% coming from sources including solar, wind, and new nuclear, 10% from sources like hydropower and fossil fuels co-fired with 80% hydrogen, and 5% from waste coal, municipal solid waste, and coal or natural gas co-fired in a 20% hydrogen blend.

This expands the current list of eligible alternative sources of electricity, mainly with the addition of nuclear energy from small modular reactors (none have been deployed yet in the U.S.), fusion energy, which is not yet commercial, and hydrogen, a zero-carbon-emitting fuel that could be derived from splitting water molecules or reforming natural gas. Pennsylvania has been approved for Department of Energy funding for two hydrogen hubs, one in the east and the other in the west part of the state. Potential hydrogen producers see the electric power market — specifically being able to supply hydrogen for blending with natural gas — as a promising client that would require less infrastructure development than some other proposed uses for hydrogen. 

The governor’s office said his joint plan would save utility ratepayers $252 million in its first five years and projected it would create more than 14,500 jobs.

Reactions from environmental and consumer groups and labor leaders heralded the proposed increase in alternative energy as meaningful and long overdue.

Gov. Josh Shapiro visited the Community College of Allegheny County on the North Shore to discuss his education blueprint and the local workforce on Tuesday, Feb. 27, 2024.
Jan Murphy
200+ Pa. state workers earned more than Shapiro did in 2023

But the Pennsylvania cap and trade proposal elicited less enthusiasm elsewhere.

Carbon market

Mr. Shapiro, who in his gubernatorial campaign broke with his predecessor Tom Wolf and expressed skepticism about RGGI, said he was worried about its impact on energy jobs and consumer energy prices in Pennsylvania.

In April 2023, he convened a working group with members from labor, the power sector, oil and gas companies, coal and renewable energy firms, and consumer advocates, to determine how to proceed. The group released a report in September, saying that while they agreed that there’s a need to reduce carbon emissions from the power sector, they could not come to a consensus about RGGI.

In the meantime, a flurry of legal challenges to Pennsylvania joining RGGI weaved their way through the courts. Plaintiffs argued that Mr. Wolf couldn’t legally order the state to join the regional compact through regulation and that only the general assembly could approve such a move. In November, the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court agreed. Gov. Shapiro surprised some when he said his administration would appeal the decision, if only to protect the power of the executive branch.

On Wednesday, he promised that as soon as he signs the bills enacting his new energy plan, Mr. Shapiro would pull Pennsylvania out of RGGI.

Speakers that followed Mr. Shapiro’s announcement on Wednesday stressed that it was the long, hard work of being in a room together with political opponents during the RGGI workgroup sessions that made them support the governor’s effort.

“We have a starting point,” said Rob Bair, president of the Pennsylvania Building Trades. “I may not agree with 100% of this plan” but doing nothing is not an option, he said.

Jackson Morris, director of state power sector policy, climate and energy at the Natural Resources Defense Council, said the same, stressing that the federal incentives from the Inflation Reduction Act and the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act could be used to pay for Pennsylvania’s vision.

Nevertheless, Mr. Morris said his organization believes that participating in RGGI, along with an increased alternative energy standard, would be the best way to accomplish the goals that the governor laid out.

“But we're also open and eager to explore alternative approaches,” he added.

The Pennsylvania Coal Alliance had the opposite reaction.

“This plan clearly puts Pennsylvania and its businesses at a disadvantage and would shutter the few remaining traditional coal-fired generation sources in Pennsylvania,” the organization said in a statement.

Although during his speech Mr. Shapiro presented the Pennsylvania cap and trade idea as an outgrowth of the working group, the Pennsylvania Coal Alliance noted that a state-specific program was not a recommendation of that effort. Instead, its members weighed the pros and cons of joining RGGI versus a hypothetical carbon market for the 13 states involved in PJM Interconnection, the electric transmission grid that serves Pennsylvania and its neighbors.

“If this plan is implemented,” the group argued, Ohio and West Virginia will be the winners to Pennsylvania’s loser.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com 

First Published: March 13, 2024, 5:43 p.m.
Updated: March 14, 2024, 9:56 a.m.

RELATED
FILE - In a Friday, Aug. 3, 2018 photo, solar panels line the roof of Harmony House as part of a project by Solar Holler in Huntington, W.V. An entire county school system in coal-producing West Virginia is going solar, representing what developer Solar Holler and U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin's office called Wednesday, Nov. 29, 2023, the largest-ever single demonstration of sun-powered renewable electricity in Appalachian public schools.
Anthony Hennen
Feds funding large solar project in Clearfield County
The Brunot Island Generating Station, a 265-megawatt natural gas power plant operated by GenOn that feeds into the electric grid in Pittsburgh during times of peak demand, photographed on Monday, Nov. 29, 2021, in Marshall-Shadeland.
Capitolwire.com
Commonwealth Court hears arguments about Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative
SHOW COMMENTS (112)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Traffic passes by U.S. Steel in Braddock on Friday, Feb. 7, 2025. An activist investor has accused U.S. Steel CEO David Burritt of potential insider trading as the group pressures investors to support its own plan for the iconic Pittsburgh steelmaker, which includes a new board and abandoning a planned merger with Japan’s Nippon Steel.
1
business
Ancora launches ‘Make U.S. Steel Great Again’ campaign, accuses CEO of insider trading
President Donald Trump listens as Elon Musk speaks in the Oval Office at the White House, Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025, in Washington. (Photo/Alex Brandon)
2
news
McCormick on board with Trump, DOGE shakeup while Fetterman blasts 'chaos, confusion'
Pitt’s Jalend Lowe (15) shoots a 3-pointer against Syracuse at the NCAA men’s basketball game on Tuesday Feb. 18, 2025 at Petersen Event Center in Pittsburgh, Pa.
3
sports
Instant analysis: Opportunistic Pitt defense flips another first half deficit into win over Syracuse
Head coach Mike Tomlin and offensive coordinator Arthur Smith watch a receivers and defensive backs drill at Steelers Minicamp at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex Thursday, June 13, 2024.
4
sports
Gerry Dulac: Next season’s major decisions loom this week for Mike Tomlin, Steelers staff
Pittsburgh Steelers running back Jaylen Warren (30) is sacked by Baltimore Ravens cornerback Brandon Stephens (21) at M&T Bank Stadium on Saturday, Jan. 11, 2025, in Baltimore, Maryland.
5
sports
Ray Fittipaldo's Steelers chat transcript: 02.18.25
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro speaks at a news conference at the United Association Local 524 union building in Scranton, Pa., on Wednesday, March 13, 2024.  (Commonwealth Media Services)
Gov. Josh Shapiro appears at the United Association Local 524 union building in Scranton, Pa., on Wednesday, March 13, 2024, during an announcement that he would back legislation to make power plant owners in Pennsylvania pay for their planet-warming greenhouse gas emissions.  (Commonwealth Media Services)
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro speaks at a news conference at the United Association Local 524 union building in Scranton, Pa., on Wednesday, March 13, 2024. Shapiro announced he would back legislation to make power plant owners in Pennsylvania pay for their planet-warming greenhouse gas emissions and require utilities in the nation's third-biggest power producer to buy more electricity from renewable sources.  (ASSOCIATED PRESS)
The Northampton generating station on Wednesday, March 13, 2024.  (ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro speaks at a news conference at the United Association Local 524 union building in Scranton, Pa., on Wednesday, March 13, 2024.  (ASSOCIATED PRESS)
Commonwealth Media Services
Advertisement
LATEST business
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story