Healthcare workers have a growing concern about the use of artificial intelligence in medical decisions as evidenced by recent labor contracts as use of the new technology soars among doctors and nurses, new research shows.

A new study shows how fast AI is becoming part of everyday medical care as organized labor catches up to the trend on the frontlines of medicine.

The three-year contract Allegheny General Hospital nurses approved in late October, for example, contains first-ever language recognizing AI’s use in supplementing direct nursing care, which protects nurses’ clinical judgement and nurse-to-patient ratios that have been part of AGH’s labor agreements for decades.

“Bargaining unit members have a right and responsibility to exercise clinical judgement” when interfacing with AI in the workplace, according to the contract.

Advertise with us

AGH nurses also want a voice in how AI is used in the hospital, stipulating that it was a “valid topic” for discussion by internal nursing practice councils.

Some 1,500 AGH nurses and nurse practitioners are represented by SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania and AI is used throughout Allegheny Health Network and its corporate parent Highmark Health in various ways, from clinical to administrative.

Over the life of the new contract, AGH nurses will receive average total raises of nearly 16%, with a minimum $8 an hour raise for nurses with more than five years experience. Management also committed to ending forced rotating work shifts, the union said, which require nurses to switch from working days to nights within the same workweek.

AHN officials declined to comment on the contract.

The agreement came after nurses voted by a margin of 99% to conduct informational pickets and authorize a strike, if terms were not reached. Strike votes by nurses at Pittsburgh hospitals date back to at least 2006, but there has never been a walkout by nurses in the city.

Advertise with us

The Allegheny General contract and AI language come as a new study of nearly 952,000 clinicians found soaring use of AI by doctors and nurse practitioners: monthly active users increased to 703,265 in June 2026 from just 355 users in January 2024, for OpenEvidence, a popular AI-enabled clinical information platform, according to a study that appeared in the Journal of the American Medical Association in October.

Nurse practitioners and physician assistants submitted more queries per active user than doctors, the study found. For physician queries, 33.1% were about medical treatment and management, while questions about diagnosis accounted for 13.9%.

In all, doctors and nurses submitted 271 million queries to the AI-enabled clinical information platform during the 2.5-year study.

Organized labor has taken notice of how hospital management uses the technology.

Like the AGH contract, a 2025 Kaiser Permanente agreement with the Alliance of Health Care Unions recognized AI as a complement, rather than a replacement for human judgment.

Advertise with us

Also last year, the New York State Nurses Association reached a contract at Northwell South Shore University Hospital that banned the mandated use of AI by nurses in making clinical decisions, while adding protections for nurses who question or override AI recommendations.

At the same time, Americans say they are generally open to AI in healthcare, but they want humans making the final calls, according to a new study by the Pew Research Center, a nonpartisan think tank based in Washington, D.C. The openness drops off for decisions that directly drive diagnoses or insurance decisions: 60% of Americans surveyed were uncomfortable with AI in their own healthcare for tasks like diagnoses and treatment, according to a study released in recent weeks.