Michael Ernette knew his property taxes were too high when he faced a stark decision: pay what he owed or let the aging pipes beneath his home freeze again this winter. On top of his bills, he couldn’t afford repairs.

For Leo Quigley, it took comparing his tax bill to his neighbors’, one of whom has a newer home and was paying less than half of what he does.

Flavia Laun spent months fighting a tax increase on her house, skipping doctor appointments, losing sleep and dipping into her savings to foot the bill.

In 2025, all three Western Pennsylvania homeowners signed on to separate lawsuits with the same demand: fair property taxes.

Advertise with us

Across the state, property taxes are based on outdated values: Pennsylvania is the only state in the country that does not require regular property reassessments, tax attorneys said.

As a result, many counties — including Allegheny — have not reassessed in over a decade; in some areas, it’s been more than 50 years. In such places, some homeowners in growing neighborhoods are getting tax breaks, while those in stagnant areas — often low-income Pennsylvanians — are paying more than they should.

That’s because property taxes, without a reassessment, don’t automatically change as property values rise and fall.

“It doesn’t feel fair at all,” said Mr. Ernette, of East Huntingdon, a Walmart Auto Care Center service manager who lives paycheck to paycheck.

“I’m more than willing to pay the taxes,” he added. “Just a fair chunk.”

Advertise with us

Allegheny County’s last countywide reassessment was in 2012. Since then, the taxable values of homes, office towers, and sprawling warehouses have remained largely frozen — except when appeals trigger reassessments.

Property owners and the taxing bodies — the city, county and school district — can file appeals when they believe a property is over- or under-valued, meaning taxes are too high or too low.

Since 2020, an unprecedented surge in appeals has slashed the value of the region’s most lucrative properties, eroding the tax base that funds schools, public safety and other critical services, a Post-Gazette analysis found.

The pandemic marked a watershed moment. High-profile office towers emptied out as work moved online. That trend, paired with a court-ordered change in the way the county determines real estate values, prompted thousands of appeals — and larger tax cuts than ever before.

The Post-Gazette reviewed thousands of property records to measure the impact of appeals on county and municipal finances. The analysis found that appeals filed over the past four years cost the county, city, and surrounding municipalities an estimated $25 million combined in tax revenue in 2025.

Advertise with us

In Pittsburgh alone, the tax base has shrunk by more than $1 billion since 2022, pushing the city deeper into a budget crisis as some of the most valuable buildings Downtown halved their tax bills through appeals.

To cut their losses, taxing bodies have lodged a slew of appeals against homeowners, increasing tax bills for thousands of people. But it hasn’t been enough to stanch the bleeding.

More than a dozen municipalities in Western Pennsylvania had to increase property taxes for 2026 to balance their faltering budgets, including Pittsburgh. Across the state, residents’ bills will rise — including many already paying more than their homes are worth in taxes.

“The inequities are just sitting there for anyone to look at,” said Dominick Gambino, former head of Allegheny County’s Office of Property Assessments.

It’s an “equal opportunity” problem: taxing bodies and residents both pay the price, Pittsburgh Public Schools Solicitor Ira Weiss said.

Advertise with us

As the crisis has grown, so have calls for a solution.

But revising all property values can lead to broad tax increases, a risk that’s made full reassessments the “third rail of county politics,” Mr. Weiss said. For decades, few elected officials have pulled the trigger, hesitant to shoulder the blame for higher taxes.

In Allegheny County, this year could be a turning point. At least four ongoing lawsuits filed by both taxing bodies and homeowners are pushing for an immediate reassessment. And experts say chances of success are high.

“At this point,” said Allegheny County Council President Patrick Catena, “I believe it is going to be court-ordered.”

‘It will only get worse’

Last month, the copper pipes under Mr. Ernette’s mobile home froze, unfroze and froze again, leaving him without running water for several days. But it wasn’t a shock, the 52-year-old said. He’s known for years that the pipes should be replaced.

Advertise with us

For Mr. Ernette, spending money on home repairs means putting off other payments — such as his property tax bill. In the past, he’s gone without water for four days and crawled under his home with a hair dryer to thaw out pipes.

“A lot of times, you’re robbing Peter to pay Paul, so to speak,” Mr. Ernette said. After he was laid off during the pandemic, the U.S. Navy veteran spent months searching for work. Now, he doesn’t have much saved up.

Mr. Ernette is a member of the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee, a nonprofit suing the state over its property assessment system. The group represents hundreds of low-income Pennsylvanians and claims many are taxed for more than their homes are worth, court filings show.

Family photos and Bible verses line the walls of Mr. Ernette’s small mobile home in Westmoreland County, a sign he’s lived there longer than anywhere else. Since he purchased the 1993 trailer over a decade ago, it’s endured regular wear-and-tear — the vinyl floor panels in his small kitchen are chipped; the roof could use repairs, he said.

But the property’s taxable value has not changed because the county’s last reassessment was in 1972.

Advertise with us

As a result, Mr. Ernette’s home is assessed at nearly double the amount it’s worth today, court filings show. Due to rate increases, his property taxes have gone up every year since 2017; he paid more than $1,000 in 2025, according to property records.

“It will only get worse,” Mr. Ernette said. As properties lose value, homeowners in counties without regular reassessments don’t see their tax bills decrease.

Consider the Mon Valley, where many properties have not been reassessed in years. In North Braddock, Mayor Cletus Lee said his home in the center of the borough is now “surrounded by blight,” or properties that have fallen into disrepair since he moved in.

Flavia Laun sits in her Churchill home on Thursday, Feb. 4, 2026. Laun, a retired senior living on a fixed income whose property tax bill increased after the school district filed an appeal on her home, has filed a lawsuit against Allegheny County calling for a countywide property reassessment. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“They’re everywhere,” the mayor said. “If I could have framed everything [a decade ago] and flipped it, I could show you the changes of how it looked then and now.”

Compare the Mon Valley to Quaker Valley, or the Hill District to Squirrel Hill, and property values have trended in opposite directions over time, while most assessments remain frozen, said Mr. Gambino, a tax consultant.

Advertise with us

“A wise man once told me: one person’s tax break is everyone else’s tax,” added Michael Suley, chair of the board that hears property appeals in Allegheny County.

For low-income families, a home is the most important investment because it can gain value over time, said Barney Ousler, a Mon Valley Unemployed Committee director.

But a high tax bill poses a barrier: “It means you don’t have money to do other things, including repairing your home so that it has the value it can have,” Mr. Oursler said.

When homeowners push off repairs, properties deteriorate. Real estate values fall further. But across Pennsylvania, tax bills stay the same.

As of 2023, lower-valued properties were over-assessed compared to higher-value properties in Pittsburgh and six of the county’s other 10 largest municipalities, a study funded by the Heinz Endowments shows.

Advertise with us

“It wears at people, because it doesn’t happen all at once,” Mr. Oursler said. “This is a slow process of essentially carrying more of the tax burden without really knowing it.”

‘Skewed data’

Most homeowners don’t know how their taxes compare to others, or how to file appeals and challenge their bills, Mr. Oursler said. In Allegheny County, only about a third of all appeals on residential properties over the past four years were filed by homeowners themselves, the Post-Gazette found.

Appeals often require time for hearings and money for legal representation. Without help from experts familiar with the process, it’s difficult to win, Mr. Oursler said.

“If I could invest the time and money into it, I would do it,” Mr. Ernette said. “But this is the first that I’m aware of it.”

Commercial property owners, on the other hand, file appeals en masse and often win, the Post-Gazette’s analysis shows.

Advertise with us

During the past four years alone, appeals have shaved nearly $2.2 billion off the value of all commercial properties in Allegheny County — a decline driven by struggling office buildings that has cost the city and county millions in revenue.

The COVID-19 pandemic opened the floodgates. As offices closed, Downtown Pittsburgh’s skyscrapers emptied out and their value nosedived — a “generational” shift that the office market is still recovering from today, said Sharon DiPaolo, a tax attorney who represents commercial property owners.

“My clients were losing their buildings,” she said. Several of Downtown’s most iconic skyscrapers have faced recent foreclosure actions.

A major change to the common level ratio — which is used to adjust a property’s taxable value — added fuel to the fire.

The ratio helps account for how much real estate prices have changed since Allegheny County’s last reassessment in 2012.

Advertise with us

As prices shift, the ratio drops. It’s updated every year by the state, based on data from Allegheny County.

A lower ratio means appeals can result in larger tax cuts.

In 2022, a court ruled that Allegheny County was submitting skewed data to the state to keep the ratio from falling lower — and triggering greater tax losses, court filings show. “There could be no doubt,” the judge’s opinion read, that the county had been “cooking the books.”

To balance the scale, the court ordered a sharp decrease in the ratio. It’s continued to fall since, sitting at roughly 50% today — down from 81.1% before the court’s decision, according to court filings.

Previously, the taxable value of a property worth $100,000 would be $81,100. Under today’s ratio, its value would drop to about $50,000.

Advertise with us

As a result, “most of the high-end properties appeal now, no matter who wins or loses,” said Mr. Suley, chair of the county’s appeals board.

‘A perfect storm’

Since 2022, 83 properties in the Golden Triangle have won, on average, a 44% cut to their assessed value, the Post-Gazette found. That includes markers of the Downtown skyline, like the 31-story Highmark Tower. After an appeal last year, the building’s value dropped by more than $63 million, slashing its tax bill in half.

Just a week later, the value of One Oxford Centre — another iconic office tower on Grant Street — also plummeted millions of dollars due to an appeal.

“When you have a perfect storm like the [ratio] drop and sinking values; when no one has looked at a particular property for four, five or 10 years — that can lead to enormous, sea-change levels of value all at once,” said attorney Ed Hirshberg, who represents property owners. “That is what Allegheny County is seeing now.”

If these Downtown properties were never reassessed, Pittsburgh would have collected an additional $7.1 million in tax revenue last year — enough to cover the city’s entire parks budget.

Advertise with us

That’s a significant loss for a city strapped for cash. Property taxes are Pittsburgh’s largest revenue source, Mayor Corey O’Connor told the Post-Gazette. For years, Downtown propped up the city, accounting for about a quarter of all property taxes.

But the city’s skyline is no longer a reliable moneymaker. Paired with other major budget holes, blows to Pittsburgh’s property tax base have left some essential services — such as public safety — critically underfunded.

“We all need roads. We all need schools,” Ms. DiPaolo said, adding that she supports regular, countywide reassessments and all property owners paying their fair share. “It has to be funded. It has to be a stable base, and property tax [was] the most stable, reliable base.”

There’s no reprieve in sight: in 2025, Allegheny County and municipal governments lost another estimated $10 million in tax revenue, due in part to the region’s office towers winning more steep reductions.

And this year, Allegheny County’s appeals board has already decided more than 5,000 cases, eliminating over $150 million from the tax rolls.

Advertise with us

Amid the growing loss, Pittsburgh Public Schools has tapped into funds set aside for emergencies and delayed upgrades at campuses, Mr. Weiss said. Allegheny County is at risk, too — property taxes make up almost half of the county’s revenue, a spokesperson confirmed.

“Municipalities, the county and school districts are going to have to look at where to tighten their belts,” Mr. Hirshberg said.

The ‘newcomers tax’

Facing budget shortfalls, municipalities and school districts have clawed back some lost revenue through retaliatory appeals, often lodged against recently sold properties.

Sales prices can prove a property’s value has increased since the last reassessment. As a result, new homeowners in Allegheny County are hit with tax increases just after moving in — a pattern dubbed “the newcomers tax.”

Ms. Laun has seen this strategy work to her detriment. She spent months shopping around before she found her three-bedroom home in Churchill. It seemed like a perfect fit, located near friends and a hospital — the support she needed to manage several chronic illnesses.

Advertise with us

But just five months after moving in, an appeal from Ms. Laun’s school district, Woodland Hills, raised her tax bill by more than 10%, she said. The retiree living on a fixed income was still unpacking boxes.

Ms. Laun felt “totally in the dark” and spent months combing through dozens of articles about property taxes in Pennsylvania. “From everything that I read,” she said, “nothing made sense to me.”

Like Ms. Laun, more than 20,000 homeowners in Allegheny County were hit with appeals from the taxing bodies during the past four years alone.

As commercial property values plummet, school districts and municipalities are playing offense, filing scores of appeals and raising property taxes on homes across the county.

But it’s not nearly enough to offset losses. Over the past four years, appeals filed against residential properties in the county raised values by about $270 million, records show.

Flavia Laun looks towards paperwork used in a lawsuit she filed against Allegheny County calling for a countywide property reassessment while sitting in her Churchill home on Thursday, Feb. 4, 2026. Laun is a retired senior living on a fixed income whose property tax bill increased after the school district filed an appeal on her home. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

During the same period, the value of commercial buildings fell by more than eight times that amount.

“They can’t appeal their way out of this hole,” Ms. DiPaolo said.

More than a dozen municipalities in Western Pennsylvania raised their property taxes for 2026, in some cases doubling rates or increasing them for the first time in more than half a century. Pittsburgh’s 20% tax hike was its first in a decade.

In Allegheny County, 28 of 43 school districts also raised rates last year, according to the Allegheny Institute for Public Policy. These increases came on the heels of the county’s own historic property tax increase.

“No one wants to raise taxes,” said Mr. Gambino. “But at this point … you don’t really have a choice.”

As bills rise, homeowners and taxing authorities have forged an unlikely alliance, calling for countywide property assessments in courts across the region.

At least four ongoing lawsuits could trigger reassessments in Allegheny County — and, in one case, across the whole state.

“If I have to appeal every single year, this is not a solution,” said Ms. Laun, a plaintiff in one of the suits.

“This is like my illnesses — I’m just putting Band-Aids on a big thing,” she added. The 65-year-old suffers from lyme disease and other autoimmune conditions. “It’s a systemic [issue], and it’s not right. I felt discriminated against.”

Courts could issue decisions on all four lawsuits in 2026, attorneys involved said, nudging Allegheny County closer to a reassessment than it has been in years.

System is ‘completely broken’

A lawsuit triggered Allegheny County’s last reassessment in 2012. Across Pennsylvania, that’s become the new normal, said Mr. Hirshberg, the property tax attorney.

“Reassessments at the county level only occur at gunpoint,” he said.

In Allegheny County, the last reassessment caused “well-chronicled financial challenges” for some lower-income homeowners, the Heinz Endowments’ study found. Last year, many of those residents called Mr. Catena, the Allegheny County Council president, when the county increased property taxes.

“[They said], ‘Please don’t raise my taxes, I’m struggling and I’m trying to do the best that I can,’” Mr. Catena said. “That’s the problem — there’s no good answer to this.”

This month, Allegheny County Council approved a bill that would protect vulnerable residents from major tax increases during a reassessment. And state laws restrict the amount of revenue taxing bodies can earn from the effort. But the threat of higher bills still looms.

Reassessments are also a large undertaking. Allegheny County’s last effort took three years and cost upward of $20 million to complete, a county spokesperson said. Conducting another could be a tall order for a county facing more revenue loss from thousands of appeals this year.

“The court doesn’t care about how we pay for it,” Mr. Catena said. “They’re just going to order it to be done.”

In 2025, state Sen. Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline, introduced a bill, now under consideration, that would require regular reassessments in all Pennsylvania counties. An independent board convened to advise Allegheny County on local matters is also hearing from experts about the issue and will provide recommendations this year.

But as all four lawsuits progress, the clock is ticking: delaying reassessments only makes them more expensive, officials said.

Meanwhile, Pittsburgh City Council in late 2025 called on the county to launch another reassessment.

The county has called on the state to solve the problem.

And homeowners have called on all three.

Added Mr. Weiss: “The system in Allegheny County is completely broken.”