David Newell, who grew up in Green Tree, remembers being driven to the Hollywood Theater in Dormont for birthday outings with  friends in the 1940s and early ’50s.

“There was one mother, Mrs. Sanders — I remember her name — she always treated us to a movie,” said Newell, best known as Mr. McFeely on TV’s “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood.”

“We’d go see an Abbott and Costello movie at the Hollywood Theater,” Newell remembered. “And that was just a highlight for me. That’s when my romance with theaters began.”

Newell later went with friends on his own. He recalled seeing such films as “On the Riviera,” starring Danny Kaye, and “Thunder Road,” with Robert Mitchum.

Advertise with us

Those outings ultimately led to his interest in performing, he said.

“The Hollywood is where I saw most of the films of my youth.”

Peggy Lutz, another South Hills resident, remembered matinees that could occupy children for much of an afternoon, serving as inexpensive babysitters. She recalled hundreds of kids in the Hollywood, watching Three Stooges episodes and numerous cartoons.

“Your parents would drop you off at the theater with your bag of popcorn and your dollar for a soda, and you were there all day,” she said.

There was occasional live entertainment, too.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes [local Mickey Mouse Club host] By Williams and the Mickey Mouse Club would show up and they’d do a little stage show,” she said.

The Hollywood Theater, which recently celebrated its 100th anniversary, has changed since those days, alongside numerous owners and periods of darkness. The business environment has shifted significantly as well, with most movie theaters no longer the sturdy community centers they once were.

Reopened nearly a year ago under new ownership and with technological and aesthetic updates, the Hollywood is positioned to once again function as a neighborhood gathering place.

Return to atmospheric roots

Rechristened Row House Hollywood, its latest owner is returning the theater to a style beyond the memory of even older Pittsburghers.

Brian Mendelssohn, co-owner of Row House Cinemas, aims to create a modern interpretation of a so-called atmospheric theater. An architectural style popular during the 1920s, such movie houses often featured ornate decor and artificial skies, to create the illusion of watching a movie outdoors. Stars glittered overhead, and auditorium design evoked perhaps a Mediterranean garden or courtyard.

Advertise with us
Co-owner Brian Mendelssohn's plans for Row House Hollywood tug at its history as a neighborhood spot that integrated events with film screenings. (Justin Guido / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The Hollywood features newly installed atmospheric features, though Mendelssohn said the metamorphosis will continue as funding allows.

In the early 20th century, a trip to the movies wasn’t simply about watching a silent film: The theater itself was part of the spectacle.

While the Hollywood was perhaps not a full-blown atmospheric theater. Mendelssohn called it a “proto-atmospheric” cinema, but it did have some elements, including star fixtures in the ceiling.

At the Hollywood, the stars disappeared over the years, as the interior was stripped and the theater closed and reopened so many times that even historians have trouble keeping track.

But the refurbished Hollywood will not recreate the Spanish or Mediterranean scenes favored by theater designers a century ago. Mendelssohn is taking inspiration from the futuristic cityscape of Fritz Lang's 1927 silent film “Metropolis.”

Advertise with us

“Theoretically, when we’re done, it should feel like you’re in Central Park in this ‘Metropolis’ city watching a movie,” he said.

In fact, the theater reopened last Nov. 6 with a screening of Lang’s science fiction classic.

The project combines old-time theatrical illusion with modern technology. A curved ceiling will become a luminous sky, with lighting that shifts through the colors of sunset before stars appear overhead. The main auditorium’s walls will suggest the division between the aboveground and underground worlds of “Metropolis.”

Beyond architectural flourishes, Mendelssohn wants to restore the sense of occasion that once made going to the movies special. He speaks with some disdain for modern amenities in movie houses, such as reclining loungers and food delivery to your seat.

“To me, what makes a movie theater special isn’t luxury,” he said. “It’s not your living room. The excitement and the reason why you’re willing to spend money going to a movie theater, in my opinion, is the communal experience.”

Advertise with us

A century of changes

The Hollywood opened in September 1926 as a 700-seat movie house on Potomac Avenue, in a borough experiencing a construction boom.

The Liberty Tunnels had opened just two years earlier, making travel between Pittsburgh and the South Hills easier.

“West Liberty Avenue and Potomac were our two main commercial streets, and they mushroomed just like the surrounding residential neighborhoods did,” said John Cunningham, president of the Dormont Historical Society.

The Hollywood was one of three movie theaters operating at one time in the borough. Designed by Pittsburgh architect Charles R. Geisler, its original building included two storefronts and a basement bowling alley.

The theater promoted itself with the slogan, “Where the moon and stars shine.”

Advertise with us

Warner Bros. Pictures purchased the theater in 1930 for a reported $200,000, according to the theater’s official history. It closed during the early years of the Great Depression, before reopening in November 1934, equipped with sound equipment and a new screen to accommodate talking pictures.

A 1948 renovation transformed the theater’s appearance. It was gutted and rebuilt with Art Deco influences under architect Victor A. Rigaumont. The atmospheric decorations disappeared, the bowling alley and storefronts were eliminated, and seating capacity was expanded to more than 1,000. The theater reopened that November with Alfred Hitchcock's “Rope,” starring Indiana, Pa., native Jimmy Stewart.

In 1966, another major remodeling by Stanley Warner Theatres, a subsidiary of Warner Bros., followed. This added hundreds of seats and a wider screen.

The Hollywood Theater in Dormont in the 1970s. (Dormont Historical Society)

But the arrival of suburban multiplexes and changing moviegoing habits began to take their toll. And in 1982, the theater lost its elaborate marquee — dating to the 1948 rehab — when the city widened Potomac Avenue.

The theater closed in 1988, reopened in 1990, changed operators in 1995 and closed again in 1998. It reopened in 2007, run by the child-focused nonprofit Bradley Center, which incorporated the theater into a work-training program for youth.

Advertise with us

That incarnation was short-lived, and still more openings and closings followed.

Keeping the doors open

In 2009, a group of film enthusiasts and community-minded volunteers established the nonprofit Friends of the Hollywood Theater, hoping to preserve a venue that was struggling to survive. The two other theaters in the neighborhood had closed.

“We thought, ‘Let’s take this opportunity, and let’s do it as a nonprofit, because it’s an arts organization,’” said Sandy Stuhlfire, one of the group’s founding members. “We would be better positioned to get some grants.”

The Hollywood became known for screenings of horror, classics, anime and Bollywood films, and special events including showing “The Rocky Horror Picture Show” with a live shadowcast.

“The very first movie we showed was ‘The Philadelphia Story,’ and that was very popular,” Stuhlfire said, referring to the 1940 screwball comedy directed by George Cukor.

Advertise with us
Josh Medina, of Sirkus Dayz, performs outside the Hollywood during a 100th anniversary celebration on Sept. 26. (Justin Guido / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Chad Hunter, managing director of the theater from about 2012 to 2016 who now runs the Pittsburgh Silent Film Society and Festival, helped restore 35mm film projection and introduced professional digital projection. He also brought in an electric organ for performances before screenings.

For Hunter, preserving the Hollywood was about more than maintaining a place to show movies.

“There just aren’t that many historic theaters around,” he said. “We need to save and cherish and support our historic cinemas.”

Running a single-screen theater, however, had become a difficult proposition.

Susan Mazur, a former Friends of the Hollywood board president, recalled financial pressures and disagreements over whether to continue the eclectic programming or emphasize mainstream releases. But she affirmed the popularity of the Friends’ programming.

Advertise with us

“People came from all over the city to see our programming because it was different,” she said.

In 2018, the Theatre Historical Society of America purchased the building, but, by 2023, it was shuttered again.

That year, Mendelssohn began discussions to buy the building from the Theatre Historical Society as a second location for Row House Cinemas, to complement the original Row House theater in Lawrenceville. 

A performance by a plate spinner during the 100th anniversary event offers a nod to the vaudeville performances of the early movie houses. (Justin Guido / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Bringing back the stars

Mendelssohn, a Miami native who came to Pittsburgh to attend Carnegie Mellon University, worked in historic building renovation before becoming a theater operator.

He set about improving the basics — sound, projection, accessibility, heating and cooling systems — while keeping his sights on more ambitious plans.

Advertise with us

To help revive the atmospheric concept, he turned to Mike Hume, a Los Angeles-based theater researcher who specializes in the style. Hume said atmospheric theaters enjoyed a brief period of popularity during the 1920s, offering moviegoers the sensation of visiting faraway places.

“What was going on with atmospheric theaters were, you were bringing the Hollywood movie set out of the screen into the auditorium and letting people experience that different style,” he said.

Hume estimates that roughly 95 historic atmospheric theaters survive in some form in the United States, with about 70 still operating as theaters. The cities that have them are “crazy proud” of them, he said, pointing to one in Bellefontaine, Ohio, which has motorized windmill decor.

Although the Hollywood’s original atmospheric elements were largely destroyed in 1948, the new design reinterprets their underlying idea rather than attempting an exact reconstruction.

Mendelssohn’s unconventional plan to create a sci-fi urban setting gets Hume’s approval.

Advertise with us

“I say go for it,” Hume said. “You’re taking the concept and you’re bending it into what your specific area of interest is.”

Hume advised Mendelssohn on the ceiling’s shape and color, both critical to creating the illusion of an open sky. In the Hollywood's main auditorium, which now seats 389, Mendelssohn is still fine-tuning the lighting.

The pre-show experience that Mendelssohn plans will replace ordinary commercial advertising with ambient music, a simulated sunset and twinkling stars.

The renovation, Mendelssohn said, necessitated addressing many technical details. The original theater was designed so performers could project their voices without amplification. Modern sound systems in this environment, however, can produce unwanted echoes.

“There was no amplified sound in 1926,” he said. “So it was designed where there’s musicians onstage or someone’s onstage doing vaudeville and you could hear it and it projects.”

Advertise with us
Guests — some in 1920s attire — enter the theater during a 100th anniversary celebration of the Hollywood on Sept. 26. (Justin Guido / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Cinema for the TikTok generation

The restoration comes as younger moviegoers are demonstrating an appetite for theatrical experiences.

A Pew Research Center survey conducted in 2025 found that 67% of Americans ages 18 to 29 had attended a movie theater during the previous year, compared with 39% of adults 65 and older.

Hume said he has seen a growing interest in historic theaters — especially youth of “the TikTok generation.”

“If they go to a movie and the organ is playing beforehand, they’re posting that on social media,” he said. “It’s this 100-year-old technology, but … it feels like it’s not just going to a movie, it’s an event.”

The Hollywood is tapping into another aspect of moviegoing nostalgia by offering screenings on 35mm and 70mm film. Enthusiasts value these formats for their warmer feel compared to digital projections.

Advertise with us

Mendelssohn has installed equipment for both formats, alongside digital projection, and recently presented the theater’s first 70mm screening — “Lawrence of Arabia” — under the new ownership.

The renovation also added a 46-seat second screening room, providing space for documentaries, private screenings and film club events.

Mendelssohn plans to extend the Hollywood’s “third space” offerings, including a bar, private karaoke rooms and an expanded arcade. He hopes these will make the theater a destination even for visitors who are not attending a movie.

He is trying to recreate the excitement that movie palaces incited at the birth of cinema.

“At the time, for a quarter, you could go into this beautiful place … [and feel] like you’re rich.”