Wednesday, February 19, 2025, 5:38AM |  10°
MENU
Advertisement
Max Hastings
2
MORE

The Vietnam War was a house of folly until the end

AP

The Vietnam War was a house of folly until the end

As he looked out on the Mekong Delta waterway at Ban Don near the Cambodian border, George Bonville, a member of the A-team of the Special Forces, wondered why men were fighting for control of Vietnam. “It is an agricultural paradise,” Mr. Bonville maintained, “where anybody with a brain can live, work and be comfortable. Only evil people can make war in this place — egad, I thought, I guess I am part of them. But I did not start this disaster. I only hoped to end it.”


"VIETNAM: AN EPIC TRAGEDY, 1945-1975"
By Max Hastings
HarperCollins ($37.50).

For more than 30 years, Vietnam was a killing field. The war ended disastrously, first for France, and then the United States. But, as Max Hastings reminds us in “Vietnam: An Epic Tragedy, 1945-1975,” the Vietnamese people suffered the most from the conflict.

In the book Mr. Hastings, a British journalist who has written more than two dozen books, including accounts of World War II, the Korean War, and clashes in the Falklands and Northern Ireland, draws on extensive archival research and dozens of interviews with participants on all sides, in a comprehensive and compelling narrative that illuminates political and military tactics and strategies — and the daily realities of a war that killed 2 million people.

Advertisement

Mr. Hastings endorses the scathing indictment of American policy that is now a consensus among historians. President Lyndon Johnson’s “fatal error,” he indicates, was to make an almost unlimited commitment to South Vietnam, “where its real strategic interest was miniscule.” The Saigon government was not supported by the people, and the presence of hundreds of thousands of troops wearing sunglasses, helmets and body armor that “gave them the appearance of robots empowered to kill” only legitimized Hanoi.

President Richard Nixon and Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, Mr. Hastings adds, “presided over gratuitous years of carnage, merely to conceal from the American electorate, for their own partisan purposes, the inevitability of humiliation in Indochina.” Mr. Hastings dismisses as “strategic illiteracy” claims that the United States could have prevailed if it had unleashed all of its military might on North Vietnam.

The book also includes some important revisions to standard accounts of the war. Citing a 1992 study, Mr. Hastings suggests that poor people and members of minority groups in the United States may not have borne an “unjust share” of the burden. While 30 percent of Americans killed in the war came from the lowest third of the economic pyramid, 26 percent came from the highest. Of combat deaths, 12.5 percent were blacks and 5 percent Hispanic, loss rates lower than groups’ proportions of draft-age males.

As he documents the incompetence and immorality of the leaders of South Vietnam and the United States, Mr. Hastings points out that “these unpalatable realities” are only half of “the rightful story.” In the 1960s and ‘70s, the mass media and anti-Vietnam War activists “were ignorant of, or blind to, the tyranny prevailing in the North, which was inflicting worse hardships on its own people.”

Advertisement

Surprisingly, perhaps, Mr. Hastings insists that the decision of the U.S. Congress “to half choke the aid pipe to Saigon while the Russians and Chinese kept open their own” in 1974 was “indefensible.” Acknowledging that $945 million was eventually allocated, but also recognizing that more weapons and air strikes would not have changed the outcome, he declares that continued aid “might have gone far to preserve America’s honor in the last phase of the war, while withdrawal tarnished it.” Mr. Hastings does assess the cost, in death and destruction, of prolonging the inevitable.

That said, Max Hastings is surely right to direct attention to the trauma, torture and death visited on Vietnamese soldiers and citizens on both sides. As fighting wound down, a South Vietnamese officer recalled, “There was no time to cry. I was just wondering how to survive.” Given a chance to leave the country, Lt. Khiem begged his parents to accompany him. His mother insisted she must look after her father. After an emotional farewell, Lt. Khiem boarded a boat, learned from his portable radio that the government of South Vietnam had surrendered, and joined in the orgy of tears and prayers.

The government of South Vietnam was history. With the country in the hands of a vengeful North Vietnamese regime, the travails of the Vietnamese people were by no means over.

Glenn C. Altschuler is the Thomas and Dorothy Litwin Professor of American Studies at Cornell University.

First Published: December 28, 2018, 5:00 p.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Traffic passes by U.S. Steel in Braddock on Friday, Feb. 7, 2025. An activist investor has accused U.S. Steel CEO David Burritt of potential insider trading as the group pressures investors to support its own plan for the iconic Pittsburgh steelmaker, which includes a new board and abandoning a planned merger with Japan’s Nippon Steel.
1
business
Ancora launches ‘Make U.S. Steel Great Again’ campaign, accuses CEO of insider trading
Gov. Josh Shapiro is joined in the broadcast booth by Curtis Aiken before the start of Pitt-Syracuse on Tuesday night at Petersen Events Center.
2
sports
Governor Josh Shapiro aims to make Pennsylvania 'compete' in NIL, bring 'stability' to transfer portal
President Donald Trump listens as Elon Musk speaks in the Oval Office at the White House, Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025, in Washington. (Photo/Alex Brandon)
3
news
McCormick on board with Trump, DOGE shakeup while Fetterman blasts 'chaos, confusion'
The WPIAL basketball playoffs are underway.
4
sports
WPIAL boys basketball playoffs: Down go the Highlanders, all the way out of PIAA playoffs
Head coach Mike Tomlin and offensive coordinator Arthur Smith watch a receivers and defensive backs drill at Steelers Minicamp at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex Thursday, June 13, 2024.
5
sports
Gerry Dulac: Next season’s major decisions loom this week for Mike Tomlin, Steelers staff
Max Hastings  (AP)
"Vietnam and epic tragedy : 1945-1975," by Max Hastings.
AP
Advertisement
LATEST ae
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story