Friday, March 28, 2025, 4:40AM |  51°
MENU
Advertisement
Carmen Gentile.
3
MORE

'Blindsided by the Taliban': A journalist loses an eye in Afghanistan, but gains insight

Nish Nalbandian

'Blindsided by the Taliban': A journalist loses an eye in Afghanistan, but gains insight

“Blindsided by the Taliban” by Carmen Gentile is interesting and worth reading for three reasons.

The first is the extremely difficult circumstances the author is put in. While embedded as a journalist in a U.S. military unit in Afghanistan, he is hit in the head and badly wounded by a rocket-propelled grenade fired at him by an Afghan, presumably a soldier of the Taliban that U.S. forces are fighting there.


"BLINDSIDED BY THE TALIBAN"
By Carmen Gentile
Skyhorse Publishing. $24.99.

The second reason to read it is that it comprises an excellent, clear picture of an American journalist’s relationship with his immediate clients who are the purchasers of the news he collects, sometimes in horrid places like rural Afghanistan.

Advertisement

That work is then transmitted to the ultimate clients, Americans and citizens of other countries who, on the basis of that news, are supposed to make sense of what their governments have them involved in as taxpayers and as parents and friends of the soldiers, diplomats and journalists they send to these places.

The battlefields where they are sent include Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen. If America’s so-called leaders mess up, this list could also include Iran, North Korea or Ukraine.

These are all places where the heads of people such as Mr. Gentile can get blown off or, as in his case, get almost blown off, with devastating consequences.

A third reason to read it is the language and description of the lifestyle of a younger literate adventurer such as Mr. Gentile. Older folks, like your reviewer, whose fighting days are over should appreciate it.

Advertisement

The book itself presents the reader a challenge. It is not a straight chronological account leading from the moment when the shell plows into his head to the time when he returns to where it happened, has another look and remembers.

It also jumps around the different sites in which he lived, loved and recovered. If one reads the titles of the chapters, it is possible to get an idea of the flow of events and, particularly, of his recovery from his dire wounds and the “before” and “after” of the attack on him.

There are what I would judge to be some profound truths in the book.

He describes the Afghans as “the hardiest people on the planet.” I would agree with that. They were dealt a lousy piece of real estate, seem to be able to make money only from growing and marketing opium, and have had the misfortune to have a raft of people crawling all over them, including the British, Russians and Americans.

Another deep, accurate observation he makes is, “There’s an inherent loneliness that comes from seeing and experiencing things the vast majority of people never will.”

One doesn’t try to explain oneself to them because it would take too long and is too complicated, and thus one gets cut off alone. In his case, he lost part of his sight, and who knows what else, when he was gravely wounded in Afghanistan, where he wanted to be.

“Blindsided by the Taliban” is Mr. Gentile’s effort to enable us to understand him, Afghanistan, journalists and much else. There is some humor in it that adds M&Ms to the sometimes grim trail mix of what he went through.

He broke me up when he described Gen. David Petraeus as “like Mick Jagger with a chest full of medals.” I appreciate his George Orwell quote on journalism: “printing what someone else does not want printed.”

Dan Simpson, a former U.S. ambassador, is a Post-Gazette associate editor (dsimpson@post-gazette.com).

First Published: March 11, 2018, 10:00 a.m.

RELATED
SHOW COMMENTS (0)  
Join the Conversation
Commenting policy | How to Report Abuse
If you would like your comment to be considered for a published letter to the editor, please send it to letters@post-gazette.com. Letters must be under 250 words and may be edited for length and clarity.
Partners
Advertisement
Oneil Cruz #15 of the Pittsburgh Pirates looks on prior to a game against the Miami Marlins on Opening Day at loanDepot park on March 27, 2025 in Miami, Florida.
1
sports
3 takeaways from the Pirates' opening day loss to the Marlins
The BNY Mellon Center.
2
business
BNY to move employees into new building by 2027
 Hundreds gathered at the winners circle at The Meadows Racetrack and Casino in Washington County on Wednesday, March 26, 2025 to pay tribute to a driver killed in an accident on the track. Hunter Myers, 27, died of head injuries a day after an incident involving another driver and horse on March 19.
3
local
Driver with 'bigger-than-life personality' honored at Meadows horse track a week after his death
The Cathedral of Learning, centerpiece of the University of Pittsburgh campus
4
business
Three more Pitt researchers lose NIH funding
Sen.-elect Dave McCormick and Sen. John Fetterman
5
news
McCormick, Fetterman joint book event comes as constituents press for town halls
Carmen Gentile.  (Nish Nalbandian)
Carmen Gentile.
"Blindsided by the Taliban," by Carmen Gentile.
Nish Nalbandian
Advertisement
LATEST ae
Advertisement
TOP
Email a Story