The biggest story involving Paul Skenes at the All-Star Game wasn’t anything he did on the field. Or anything he said in an interview.

It came from last Monday’s media availability, when a credentialed media member spoke to Skenes, turned around then recorded themselves filming a video.

“Hey, sorry, just got the best interview of all time with Paul Skenes,” they said, still within earshot of the All-Star. “Future Yankee.”

Future Yankee? Skenes’ confusion was immediately clear. He asked another media member who that was recording the video. But the clip had already been made — and the “news” would follow.

Advertise with us

For Skenes, one of the faces of baseball, a week that was supposed to be a celebration of his third All-Star honor in three years turned into a conversation about where he might pitch next. And at a time with plenty of labor uncertainty, the debate took on a life of its own.

As the Pirates prepare for a three-game series against the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium, it’s worth looking further into what “future Yankee” really means.

Yankees chatter around Skenes shows little sign of slowing down, even with Skenes under contract in Pittsburgh through 2029. It’s typical for large-market teams to covet small-market stars, especially one with the talent of Skenes. Yet these rumors have more smoke than most.

For one, Skenes’ girlfriend, Livvy Dunne, is a New Jersey native who happened to purchase a $2 million apartment in New York City’s West Village in the fall.

Then in November, on the day Skenes won the National League Cy Young Award, the rumors reached a fever pitch. A New Jersey website published an article claiming a former Pirates teammate had heard Skenes say that “he wants to play for the Yankees” and has said it “multiple times.”

Advertise with us

Skenes downplayed the report.

“I don’t know the reporter that reported it,” Skenes said that night. “I don’t know the player that supposedly said that, but the goal is to win and the goal is to win in Pittsburgh.”

Yet now, as the labor dispute rolls on and the “future Yankee” video has gone viral, conversations about Skenes have begun anew.

The Post-Gazette asked MLBPA interim executive director Bruce Meyer about the media member’s comment the following day, as many fans believe that a salary-capped system would allow small markets such as Pittsburgh to retain players of Skenes’ caliber.

Meyer listed off eight different small-market players who signed extensions, from Bobby Witt Jr. to Konnor Griffin to JJ Wetherholt.

Advertise with us

“They are keeping them, and they can,” Meyer said. “And ones who choose not to can afford to do it.”

Yet of the eight players Meyer referenced, all signed their contracts before arbitration and all but one (Witt) signed with less than a year of major league service time. Sure, all are under control long term, but it took a significant gamble from their teams to make it happen.

With Skenes due to hit arbitration next year, it’s too late to do the same in his situation.

MLB commissioner Rob Manfred took a different approach. While not asked directly about Skenes, Manfred made sure to point out the flaws of the current free agent structure while addressing reporters.

“We need to make sure that fans in markets at the beginning of the season have a realistic belief that their team has a chance to win,” Manfred said. “I think that we need a system where fans, particularly in smaller markets, can have some hope that the players that are signed and developed by the organizations can actually stay there through free agency.”

Advertise with us

Meyer called the “future Yankee” comment “very flippant” and added that it’s “a tremendous disservice to Paul.” But he fully supports the choices of free agents.

"Players want to be treated fairly, and they want to play [on] the teams that they think are trying to win,” Meyer said. “Whether big market, small market, they want to be in places where they and their families are comfortable, and they want to be convinced that the team is actually trying to win.”

He added: “If there’s a team that’s not trying to do that and not trying to provide the best experience for players, that team is going to suffer in trying to attract players.”

In the most recent round of CBA proposals, which include a salary cap, MLB proposed limiting free-agent contracts with new teams to five years and $202 million. To retain a player, teams could offer six years and $265 million.

Would that be enough to keep Skenes in Pittsburgh? It’s possible.

Advertise with us

It would also limit his choices. Under the latest proposal, he wouldn’t be able to sign a deal such as Gerrit Cole’s nine-year, $324 million contract with the Yankees or Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s 12-year, $325 million deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Those would be a thing of the past.

But regardless of whether you believe a salary cap is the right system for baseball, the fact that the Pirates have almost no chance of retaining Skenes past 2029 is a problem.

Skenes should have been celebrated last week in Philadelphia with the rest of baseball’s All-Stars. The conversations surrounding him weren’t on his play or his team, but instead on his next club. And that is a major disservice to Skenes, the Pirates, Pittsburgh and to baseball as a whole.

I’ll be watching …

How Mitch Keller comes out of his reset. The Pirates shuffled their rotation out of the All-Star break, essentially skipping Keller’s next scheduled start.

While the move kept Skenes on schedule and lined up the Pirates’ best pitchers together — at least before Friday’s cancellation — it also gives Keller nearly two weeks between starts. He won’t get a better opportunity to fix whatever issues are plaguing him.

Advertise with us

The Jacob Gonzalez/Jared Triolo split. With Konnor Griffin likely out until September, the Pirates saw their hole at shortstop as a big enough problem to use their Comp-A pick on an infielder instead of a reliever.

Gonzalez isn’t proven in the majors, but he was raking in Triple-A. Will he be the Pirates’ everyday shortstop, relegating Triolo to a platoon role? Is Gonzalez intended as depth? Gonzalez impressed in Cleveland, so I’m looking forward to seeing if it this continues and if he can make the role his own.

Crunch time for the bullpen. There are two weeks until the trade deadline, with bullpen help as the clear and obvious need, and there are only so many spots.

Gregory Soto, Mason Montgomery, Carmen Mlodzinski and Yohan Ramirez aren’t going anywhere. Wilber Dotel, Isaac Mattson and Brandon Eisert have minor league options, but they can keep themselves in the majors if they perform.

As for Dennis Santana? He’s out of options, so — assuming the trade deadline goes as expected — he’ll need to impress in his final few appearances if he wants to stay in Pittsburgh. Saturday wasn’t exactly a ringing audition for him or for Eisert.

Advertise with us

They said it …

“I still think that we’re not quite there yet this year and playing our best baseball, which is a really cool opportunity because we’re playing really well right now.” — Braxton Ashcraft

Prospect pictures

The Pirates finally brought one of their top hitters in Greensboro to Altoona, promoting Murf Gray to Double-A on Friday — then seeing him immediately homer.

Duce Gourson moved up, as well, from Altoona to Indianapolis.

So when will the rest of Gray’s Grasshoppers teammates follow? With the trade deadline looming, a promotion can help a potential package look more appealing. However, when those promotions happen can be strategic.

Most teams’ statistical models need a set number of at-bats at each level to determine a player’s value. The Pirates could elect to keep some potential trade chips in Greensboro until closer to the deadline to ensure models use numbers from offense-happy Greensboro instead of the more-pitcher-friendly Altoona.

Advertise with us

The next wave to Double-A should come soon  — but at the deadline, any potential advantage is worth pursuing.

On deck

Court’s not in session

The New York Yankees have the second-best record in the American League, yet they’ve been a completely different team with Aaron Judge out with a rib injury. In the past 30 days, all without Judge, they rank 19th in baseball with a .617 OPS. The Pirates lead the majors at .848.

Yinzerpalooza

Any series against the Chicago Cubs is important, but one that comes days before the trade deadline has added relevance. The Cubs are one of the Pirates’ rivals for a wild card spot and are expected to add starting pitching. We’ll see if reinforcements are here in time for Saturday’s Dr. Robby bobblehead giveaway.

Advertise with us

Bottom of the ninth

One of the Pirates’ best traits this year is how well they’ve responded to the many “sky is falling” losses they’ve had this year. Easily their worst trait is how many “sky is falling” losses they’ve had.

Seven blown leads stand out — one being Saturday’s loss in Cleveland — yet they’re 5-2 following those games.

The Pirates should take pride in their resolve, but these blown leads grew old long ago. The Pirates need to make a deal now to fix the issue instead of waiting the 13 games before the deadline. There’s plenty to be excited about here, so this issue can’t be allowed to tank their season further.