After being delayed by order by President Donald Trump earlier this year, the fiduciary rule intended to protect millions of Americans by requiring that all financial advisers managing retirement accounts act solely in the client’s best interest regardless of commissions or fees is now expected to go into effect on June 9.

Secretary of Labor Alexander Acosta on Tuesday made it clear that the U.S. Department of Labor would not delay the implementation of the rule,  announcing the agency’s intentions in a Wall Street Journal opinion column.

The rule has been strongly opposed by large national firms, such as Merrill Lynch, that have thrived on selling commissioned products. The National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors has argued the rule will impose burdensome restrictions and requirements, and will limit middle- and lower-income retirement savers’ access to services and advice.

Tuesday’s announcement that the rule is going forward may not be the end of the discussion.

Advertise with us

“The rule going live in June is a very good development,” said Andrew Stoltmann, a Chicago-based securities attorney. “But there are storm clouds on the horizon and very powerful forces looking to gut the fiduciary rule and make it meaningless. They are looking at modifying it, changing it and looking for ways not to enforce it.”

The government’s goal is to tackle the problem of conflicted advice in the financial services industry so that there will no longer be different groups of financial advisers working under different standards.

By June 9, all advisers working with clients’ retirement accounts are expected to act under a stricter “fiduciary” standard, where previously they had a choice of acting under a less rigorous “suitability” standard when offering advice on IRAs, 401(k)s and 403(b)s.

Advisers working under the suitability standard are only required to recommend investments that are suitable for clients. Advice provided under that standard may not always be bad, but it leaves room for a number of abuses, such as unnecessarily high commissions and fees for investment products and advice.

“What client doesn’t want their adviser to work in their best interest?” said Paul Brahim, CEO of BPU Investment Management, Downtown. “The fiduciary rule is long overdue. There’s an argument that this rule makes it more expensive for clients to receive advice. My argument is this rule will cause advisers to charge more reasonable fees.”

Advertise with us

The Department of Labor had initially set April 10 as the deadline for the financial services industry to comply, but within a month of taking office Mr. Trump issued an executive order directing the department to halt the implementation for 60 days in order to review the regulation.

There have been changes during the review period.

“In that period, some of the more difficult rules to comply with were adjusted so that firms would have more time to comply,” Mr. Brahim said. “One of them was the Best Interest Contract Exemption. It was loosened and made more reasonable. The rule broadened the opportunity for advisers to sell commissioned and fees products under the fiduciary standard.”

Many firms in the financial services industry, including insurance companies that sell annuity products, expressed disappointment that the rule will soon be implemented.

The Washington, D.C.-based American Council of Life Insurers president and CEO Dirk Kempthome issued a statement, saying: “The American Council of Life Insurers is disappointed that on June 9 a regulation will go into effect that significantly harms consumers’ ability to plan and save for financially secure retirements.

Advertise with us

“... As currently written, the regulation limits retirement savers’ access to education and information about annuities, the only financial products in the marketplace that guarantee lifetime income,” Mr. Kempthorne said.

Pittsburgh financial adviser Carrie Coghill, owner of Coghill Investment Strategies, Downtown, said conceptually the rule is a good one, although it has problems.

“We want to have advisers working in the best interest of clients,” she said. “But the rule assumes that commissioned brokers are not working in the best interest of clients. I don’t agree with that. I know many advisers in the industry who charge commissions and maintain the highest level of integrity.

“Unfortunately, the downside is it may prevent some people from actually being able to seek out financial advice because costs may go up.”

Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.